QUOTE(MBisanz @ Wed 2nd December 2009, 7:15pm)
This new evidence shoot numerous large holes in what my understanding was thus far and concerns me on several levels.
This feels like one of those "it's a pity they can't both lose" situations. But really, I'd suggest that the ArbCom take a very hard line here. Gerard is poison for Wikipedia, and this mess just drives the point home.