|
Re-purposing Dalmatia, Amazon.com and dubious sources |
|
|
|
|
Replies
Milton Roe |
|
Known alias of J. Random Troll
Group: Regulars
Posts: 10,209
Joined:
Member No.: 5,156
|
QUOTE(thekohser @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 11:11am) Looks like SlimVirgin just discovered this scam for the first time. I thought she was a reader and participant here? Welcome to 2009, Slim! I don't know what's funnier, the fact that she said "her" FA article was being sold by Amazon for $49, or the fact that Amazon indeed not only does that, but says it's available too on Kindle. For a couple of years I've pointed out that WMF could actually take the text of all the FA articles (indeed, all the articles on WP, leaving out only stubs and porn for quality not space purposes) and stick it all on one 32 GB micro-SD card. Even 64 GB, which you could put in any cellphone with a STI-MICROSD/64 port. That's GIGA, not megabytes. (No, not in the iPhone, but that's due to Apple and Jobs prejudice against plug-in anything). So now the palpable irony. The WMF has millions which they could be using to get all print WP, or some selection of all FA articles, pics and all, on microSD for all cell phones, and even Kindle readers themselves (which now cost $150). It isn't happening. Instead, their articles are being scraped one-by-one and sold by Amazon/Kindle for thousands of times the cost. (IMG: smilys0b23ax56/default/wacko.gif) I don't know how long WMF can take this, but I suspect some kind of direct deal with Kindle will be too tempting to pass up. With the profit of course going to the foundation. And then used from there for anybody's wild projects, including the usual ones that benefit Wikia in some clever and non-direct way. But meanwhile, still no WP on micro-SDs. It's obvious, efficient, could be very cheap, and yet due to market forces, it's not going to happen soon. Argghhhh. (IMG: smilys0b23ax56/default/frustrated.gif)
|
|
|
|
thekohser |
|
Member
Group: Regulars
Posts: 10,274
Joined:
Member No.: 911
|
QUOTE(Milton Roe @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 2:56pm) But meanwhile, still no WP on micro-SDs. It's obvious, efficient, could be very cheap, and yet due to market forces, it's not going to happen soon. Argghhhh. (IMG: smilys0b23ax56/default/frustrated.gif) Is there anyone selling porn on micro-SDs? If not, then I don't see a market for Wikipedia on micro-SDs, either. If a medium hasn't already been exploited profitably for porn, then that medium is not going to be exploited at all for Wikipedia. I'm not saying the two are related, of course, but it's sort of like another rule of thumb that I've never had disproved to me: You will never find an Olive Garden that is not within 3 miles of McDonald's. (And usually, it's less than 1 mile away.) In this case, there actually is a relationship between the two. Darden Restaurants, when selecting potential locations for a new Olive Garden, examines whether or not there is a successful McDonald's franchise nearby. If so, they contend that the market would be able to sustain an Olive Garden, too. They let McDonald's do the dirty work of site selection, in other words. This post has been edited by thekohser:
|
|
|
|
Milton Roe |
|
Known alias of J. Random Troll
Group: Regulars
Posts: 10,209
Joined:
Member No.: 5,156
|
QUOTE(thekohser @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 12:27pm) QUOTE(Milton Roe @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 2:56pm) But meanwhile, still no WP on micro-SDs. It's obvious, efficient, could be very cheap, and yet due to market forces, it's not going to happen soon. Argghhhh. (IMG: smilys0b23ax56/default/frustrated.gif) Is there anyone selling porn on micro-SDs? If not, then I don't see a market for Wikipedia on micro-SDs, either. If a medium hasn't already been exploited profitably for porn, then that medium is not going to be exploited at all for Wikipedia. And your basis for this reasoning is what? It's happened ONCE with the internet and you generalize from this single case? There is some text porn on both Kindle and on SD cards, but with SD you need a reader, and portable porn suffers from poor resolution screens (porn is inherrently much more visual than text-based material). So it's not a very natural combination. Whereas, Kindle and text readers works much better for an encyclopedia. And why would anybody put porn text on an SD anyway? As a business model, it sucks. Wikipedia has never HAD a business model. So your argument falls flat, there. Porn survives on the internet by ads and by serving as a leader to get clients into stuff they DO pay for. Wikipedia can only do a little of that (with Wikia) and it's at the limit, now. I do wonder what will happen to WP when its donations dry up and it has to pay for itself by commercializing its content. The fact that an organization is non-profit does NOT mean that it can't make any money-- it only puts great constraints on what it use the money FOR. The Red Cross charges people for blood, just as an example. But they can't make any stockholders or owners any money doing that (since there aren't any owners). They have to use it to pay for the services that process the blood. WMF could presumably use license fees to pay for server charges and programmers and office space and Jimbo's expensive wine. Well, on that last one, the COO would probably geek again. But many a non-profit does pay expense accounts of this type, as well as fat salaries. WP might end up licensing or commercializing its content in some way to keep itself financially afloat in the future. One very obvious way would be a license for a download to a Kindle 4 or whatever, or an SD card containing WP, where some of the cost is some sort of "licence-fee." Right now, Amazon/Kindle uses SD cards and 3G downloads, but they also use a proprietary content format, and they charge on a lot of personal items to convert to that format. They also keep 1/3 to 2/3 (approximate) of the profits on stuff they sell under copyright, splitting the rest with those who control the copyright.* Such a deal could be done with WMF. Again, subject to restrictions on what a 501-c-3 can do with the money it "makes." * In a famous case, Kindle owners who downloaded Orwell's 1984, then had Kindle electronically erase their copies when it later decided it had no rights to distribute 1984. This was quite Orwellian, a fact which escaped nobody's notice. Lawsuits ensued. Amazon won't do that again.
|
|
|
|
Eva Destruction |
|
Fat Cat
Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,735
Joined:
Member No.: 3,301
|
QUOTE(Milton Roe @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 9:59pm) WP might end up licensing or commercializing its content in some way to keep itself financially afloat in the future. One very obvious way would be a license for a download to a Kindle 4 or whatever, or an SD card containing WP, where some of the cost is licence-free. Right now, Kindle uses a proprietary format, and they charge on a lot of personal items to convert to that format. They also keep 1/3 to 2/3 (approximate) of the profits on stuff they sell under copyright, splitting the rest with those who control the copyright. Such a deal could be done with WMF. Again, subject to restrictions on what a 501-c-3 can do with the money it "makes."
Jimbo is planning this. Quite how it's been "in development" since 2003 is anyone's guess, but since Wikipedia is currently plastered with "please check this list of proposed articles for inclusion" notices ( example) I presume there's actually going to be some movement on this.
|
|
|
|
Milton Roe |
|
Known alias of J. Random Troll
Group: Regulars
Posts: 10,209
Joined:
Member No.: 5,156
|
QUOTE(Eva Destruction @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 2:09pm) QUOTE(Milton Roe @ Wed 22nd September 2010, 9:59pm) WP might end up licensing or commercializing its content in some way to keep itself financially afloat in the future. One very obvious way would be a license for a download to a Kindle 4 or whatever, or an SD card containing WP, where some of the cost is licence-free. Right now, Kindle uses a proprietary format, and they charge on a lot of personal items to convert to that format. They also keep 1/3 to 2/3 (approximate) of the profits on stuff they sell under copyright, splitting the rest with those who control the copyright. Such a deal could be done with WMF. Again, subject to restrictions on what a 501-c-3 can do with the money it "makes."
Jimbo is planning this. Quite how it's been "in development" since 2003 is anyone's guess, but since Wikipedia is currently plastered with "please check this list of proposed articles for inclusion" notices ( example) I presume there's actually going to be some movement on this. Yes, they're working hard on WP 0.8 now, with the goal of a big electronic off-line production when they make it to "1.0". So far as I can tell, however, they're thinking in terms of CD's and DVD's, and it' hasn't hit anybody that they strip the text and go to SD, Kindle-readers, and webphones (without needing to connect, so you can read on an airplane). They're nashing their teeth at the people who have done this with proprietary WP-readers, but that's how THOSE people make their money. There's a whole generation of generic text-readers coming up (we're already at Kindle 3.0-- probably a breakthrough in the market) and many webphone e-book aps. The obvious "gap" is WP not being able to filter the cuss words out of its content, and so on. Nor get rid of all the IP vandalism they'll allowed in, over the years, without a lot of real "work." So, there is karma. But in the meantime, it means that a decently clean version of WP best articles aren't available offline. Which is pretty silly, considering.
|
|
|
|
Posts in this topic
thekohser Re-purposing Dalmatia thekohser I guess this thread was FAIL? dogbiscuit
I guess this thread was FAIL?
Nah, just didn... The Wales Hunter Does the same go for all of the books by the same ... thekohser
Does the same go for all of the books by the same... The Wales Hunter To answer my own question, it looks possible.
Pro... Grep
Problem here - if Wikipedia/the WMF/whoever don... Milton Roe
Problem here - if Wikipedia/the WMF/whoever don... Sarcasticidealist
Problem here - if Wikipedia/the WMF/whoever don... The Wales Hunter I'm currently trying to determine whether thos... thekohser I now discover that this was discussed, and flippa... carbuncle
I now discover that this was discussed, and flipp... thekohser So, call me crazy, but I reported Alphascript Publ... thekohser
...I reported Alphascript Publishing to the GNU F... thekohser So, I decided to try an experiment, at the suggest... Eva Destruction
What do you all think? Any bets on whether she a... thekohser
What do you all think? Any bets on whether she ... Abd Thing is, Bibles and Shakespeare aren't typica... thekohser
[quote name='thekohser' post='199847' date='Thu 1... Abd Don't be an idiot, Abd.Why not? Isn't it m... The Wales Hunter
But, you want an example of idiocy, how about the... thekohser
But, you want an example of idiocy, how about the... carbuncle
[quote name='Abd' post='199925' date='Fri 16th Oc... thekohser
Here's an idea - [b]if people are willing to ... carbuncle
[quote name='carbuncle' post='199962' date='Fri 1... thekohser
Of course, Amazon is likely to ban you for this.
... CharlotteWebb
Here's an idea - if people are willing to buy... Milton Roe
Here's an idea - if people are willing to bu... CharlotteWebb
[quote name='CharlotteWebb' post='199967' date='F... thekohser
Thing is, Bibles and Shakespeare aren't typic... thekohser Just received this e-mail today:
Funny, neither... WikiWatch
Just received this e-mail today:
Funny, neithe... thekohser
Four months later and still no legal action has b... thekohser Alphascript Publishing is now nearing 40,000 title... cookiehead Some deutschefellow has a boner against Amazon for... milowent
Some deutschefellow has a boner against Amazon fo... thekohser Edit: post made irrelevant, thanks to mods helpfu... lilburne Just a thought but most wikipedia articles are bui... TungstenCarbide
... For a couple of years I've pointed out t... Text
Is it a symbiotic relationship or a parasitic re... dtobias Dalmatia is where Dalmatians come from, all 101 of... thekohser It looks like even European university libraries a... WikiWatch These books don't deserve two stars - they des... Milton Roe
These books don't deserve two stars - they de... Detective
The truth of the matter is that authors have been... EricBarbour Just checked Amazon again, and they are still list... thekohser
Just checked Amazon again, and they are still lis... thekohser
[quote name='EricBarbour' post='278409' date='Wed... mnemonic
[quote name='EricBarbour' post='278409' date='We... Emperor
In the Kohs-centric universe, everything that hap... mnemonic
In the Kohs-centric universe, everything that ha... lilburne
[quote name='Emperor' post='303296' date='Mon 19t... SB_Johnny
[quote name='Emperor' post='303296' date='Mon 19t... Cunningly Linguistic
[quote name='Emperor' post='303296' date='Mon 19t... Somey I suppose that if I use my 'favourite' wor... Cunningly Linguistic
I suppose that if I use my 'favourite' wo... SB_Johnny
Some of my best material ended up in dev/nul :ro...
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
| |