QUOTE(It's the blimp, Frank @ Fri 19th August 2011, 5:24pm)
Jehochman complains about the Wikipedia Review:
QUOTE
The notable editor forums have the effect of smearing and harassing the named editors, not just Cirt.
Mr. Jehochman, may I ask how this is different than the Wikipedia Administrators' Noticeboard, other than that the target list is different?
Much as I hate to agree with Jehochman, he does have a point. A list of the names of all the "Notable editors" forums is displayed by just one click on the main page of this forum. The equivalent would be that you could click somewhere on the Wikipedia Main Page and get a list of editors in particular disfavour. If you can do that, I've never seen it. Also, I assume that these forums are Google-able, whereas WP:AN is not.
Then again, anything on WP obviously gets vastly more exposure than things here.