It's a
Kobayashi Maru (T-H-L-K-D) for ArbCom. Everyone has a differing view on civility and, with multiple cultures represented on Wikipedia, no major consensus will ever emerge to define a "civil" environment. Many Wikipedians are standing up for or against Malleus, so any decision or indecision will cause a rift in the core community. No one can win this. Everyone is going to lose.