FORUM WARNING [2] Division by zero (Line: 2933 of /srcsgcaop/boardclass.php)
One SlimVirgin question answered -
     
 
The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> One SlimVirgin question answered, while two more emerge in its place.
WordBomb
post
Post #1


Ãœber Member
*****

Group: Regulars
Posts: 513
Joined:
Member No.: 309



There's been a bit of speculation as to the nature of the long-deleted Slimv account.

As I mentioned last week, I have several database dumps, which I've been painstakingly reviewing in search of insights on this and the many other odd deletions made by Musical Linguist in early June of 2006.

Trust me when I say: there is some wild stuff in there.

Wild.

The main SlimVirgin content you'll have to wait for, but Slimv I shall share with you now.

It would appear that Slimv made a single edit in her career, logged November 5, 2004 to the article on Mordacai Vanunu, the guy who revealed the existence of Israel's nuclear weapons program in the mid-80s.

When Vanunu squealed, he was smart enough to do so from England, but that didn't stop the Mossad from capturing and imprisoning him in Israel for 18 years.

Slimv's contribution to the article provided some very unique insights into the role Sunday Mirror owner Robert Maxwell might have had in revealing Vanunu's treason.

Though it's been deleted, you can still see the substance of Slimv's addition by looking at the diffs that previously surrounded it.

When you do, ignore every thing above Line 15, as this is the edit that followed Slimv's. The changes you see below Line 15 were made by Slimv.

Remember, Musical Linguist said that deletion was a result of personally identifying information included in the edit. Either that's the case, or it's not. If it is: whoa. If it's not: whoa.

It's also worth noting that Musical Linguist deleted at least one edit from the Robert Maxwell article at the same time she was deleting the Vanunu edit and Slimv's user page.

One more thing.

Six days after Slimv made her one and only edit, followed a few hours later by SlimVirgin's inaugural contribution, two things happened: Mordacai Vanunu was re-arrested, and Yasser Arafat assumed room temperature. That was a busy week for Israeli intelligence.

This post has been edited by WordBomb:
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
BobbyBombastic
post
Post #2


gabba gabba hey
******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,071
Joined:
From: BADCITY, Iowa
Member No.: 1,223



As I read the newest edit supplied by WordBomb last night, this stood out:

QUOTE
First, although America blamed Libya publicly for the bombing for the first time after August 1990, insiders knew from around October 1989 that the focus of the investigation had turned to Libya.


Which constitutes original research, etc, but who is an insider here? Slim? What kind of insider? This need to discuss inside knowledge is not compatible with someone in fear of their life for being exposed as a spy. It rings true Brandt's theory of a former insider remembering back to the "good old days".

QUOTE(blissyu2 @ Tue 7th August 2007, 12:03pm) *

QUOTE(anthony @ Tue 7th August 2007, 10:21pm) *

This actually points more toward her being a "reporter who interviewed CIA" than "CIA agent".


Why? There was a point in time where I was worried that ASIO were going to murder me in relation to my knowledge of PA and hence whenever I wrote about it I claimed that I was interviewing an unknown someone in relation to it.


Slim has never said that she has interviewed anyone, to my knowledge, and she has never confirmed that she was a journalist. All she claims, in a roundabout way, is insider knowledge. This suggests that she doesn't mind so much keeping herself in a grey area, and may actually find it quite "sexy" that people do/did believe she was something more than she is/was.

QUOTE
In fact, it was my own personal knowledge. I did this for my own personal safety.


I have it on your word that you are not an intelligence agent, so it doesn't surprise me that you would do that. Suggesting that SlimV the intelligence agent would do the same thing as you, the non intelligence agent, then saying that she is an intelligence agent because she did the same thing you would is not linear thinking. A decent agent, with convictions, would not even discuss this, and even if they did, it would not be via anonymous edits to WP claiming insider knowledge. This smacks of a person that wants to show off what they know, a quality not becoming of someone in intel/counter intel, etc.

I understand why these edits were oversighted, as they add evidence to Linda Mack the journalist, but it is contrary to Linda Mack the intelligence agent. Linda Mack the intelligence agent is the story that made slashdot, because it is the sexier story. The coverup has created more controversy than the original deed.

If anyone involved in this were in intelligence they would be fired, and folks like this get fired a little differently than you and I. In my mind, the idea of Linda Mack the intelligence agent can be put to bed, but the unwitting (dupe) asset or agenda pushing activist remains, among other possibilities.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
jorge
post
Post #3


Postmaster
*******

Group: On Vacation
Posts: 1,910
Joined:
Member No.: 29



QUOTE(BobbyBombastic @ Tue 7th August 2007, 5:11pm) *


If anyone involved in this were in intelligence they would be fired, and folks like this get fired a little differently than you and I. In my mind, the idea of Linda Mack the intelligence agent can be put to bed, but the unwitting (dupe) asset or agenda pushing activist remains, among other possibilities.

If she was just your bog standard journalist why does she (as far as anyone can find) only appear to have published one article? Has she been writing under a pseudonym?
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
BobbyBombastic
post
Post #4


gabba gabba hey
******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,071
Joined:
From: BADCITY, Iowa
Member No.: 1,223



QUOTE(jorge @ Tue 7th August 2007, 4:24pm) *

QUOTE(BobbyBombastic @ Tue 7th August 2007, 5:11pm) *


If anyone involved in this were in intelligence they would be fired, and folks like this get fired a little differently than you and I. In my mind, the idea of Linda Mack the intelligence agent can be put to bed, but the unwitting (dupe) asset or agenda pushing activist remains, among other possibilities.

If she was just your bog standard journalist why does she (as far as anyone can find) only appear to have published one article? Has she been writing under a pseudonym?

There are unexciting possibilities one can explore, but I do not know this to be fact, although I agree with you that's all I know of. Perhaps she did write under a pseudonym. But let's not forget that she seems to be an emotional person. For instance, she did drop out after the plane went down. For her to simply up and quit journalism due to an emotional issue seems likely.

Daniel Brandt may be able to address this, although I sometimes wonder if there are some things he is holding close to his chest... (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/biggrin.gif)
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
WordBomb   One SlimVirgin question answered  
the fieryangel   Six days after Slimv made her one and only edit, ...  
Unrepentant Vandal   [quote name='WordBomb' post='40662' date='Sat 4th...  
Disillusioned Lackey   Very interesting. However, if she's an agent...  
blissyu2   So hang on. Is SlimVirgin this person?: Ameri...  
Unrepentant Vandal   So hang on. Is SlimVirgin this person?: Amer...  
anthony   Of course, how did SlimV know this information? ...  
WordBomb   So hang on. Is SlimVirgin this person?:American...  
GlassBeadGame   So hang on. Is SlimVirgin this person?:America...  
h.hagenstroem   Was this information released to the public? Is ...  
WordBomb   It was more than public. F.e. [url=http://www.uni...  
WordBomb   Please nobody interpret the following as my placin...  
Unrepentant Vandal   The timing of this flurry of edits one week prior...  
WordBomb   The obvious question that springs to mind: How cle...  
guy   And, for the record, I'm amazed they didn...  
WordBomb   [quote name='WordBomb' post='40820' date='Sun 5th...  
LamontStormstar   For some reason, Deuxmachina (probably a Jayjg so...  
jorge   And, for the record, I'm amazed they didn...  
blissyu2   I added this to our blog page "comprehensive ...  
WordBomb   By the way, this was not the only contribution by ...  
BobbyBombastic   After reading that garbage prose, I'm tempted...  
anthony   "Vanunu, immediately upon his release from pr...  
blissyu2   Well, SlimVirgin has referred to herself in the pa...  
blissyu2   From what we can tell, the only reason that the ed...  
guy   Welcome, Herr Hagenstroem.  
BobbyBombastic   This is interesting information. :o what do som...  
blissyu2   Perhaps SlimV is not SlimVirgin at all, but is the...  
Unrepentant Vandal   The reality is that most likely agents from every ...  
blissyu2   I think you overestimate the importance of Wikipe...  
Unrepentant Vandal   [quote name='Unrepentant Vandal' post='40941' dat...  
anthony   Now, if you were a secret service, and you saw t...  
dtobias   I think you overestimate the importance of Wikipe...  
blissyu2   I think you overestimate the importance of Wikip...  
Kato   The reality is that most likely agents from every...  
GlassBeadGame   The reality is that most likely agents from ever...  
Kato   If LM had prior intelligence handlers she might h...  
GlassBeadGame   If LM had prior intelligence handlers she might ...  
Cedric   Not an actual intelligence agent, but some sort o...  
everyking   Logically, it seems almost inconceivable it could ...  
blissyu2   Logically, it seems almost inconceivable it could...  
jorge   Logically, it seems almost inconceivable it coul...  
BobbyBombastic   Logically, it seems almost inconceivable it could...  
Unrepentant Vandal   Off topic: My short theory that may go along with...  
anthony   BTW, for all we know other edits were oversighted...  
WordBomb   Anthony: If she had been selected as an agent, th...  
jorge   Off topic: My short theory that may go along wit...  
Somey   The writing wasn't put there by someone else a...  
jorge   The writing wasn't put there by someone else ...  
anthony   I think people's perceptions have been distor...  
jorge   I think people's perceptions have been disto...  
anthony   [quote name='anthony' post='41019' date='Sun 5th ...  
Daniel Brandt   Too many of you are painting this black and white....  
Kato   By the time she gets to Wikipedia, she may have b...  
Herschelkrustofsky   Too many of you are painting this black and white...  
Jonny Cache   Too many of you are painting this black and whit...  
Herschelkrustofsky   Slim probably realized that by owning articles o...  
Jonny Cache   The more interesting question at this point is, ...  
LamontStormstar   Daniel has a point. That's why SlimVirgin kin...  
WordBomb   I've reconstructed the oversighted Slimv edits...  
blissyu2   I've reconstructed the oversighted Slimv edit...  
LamontStormstar   I've reconstructed the oversighted Slimv edit...  
anthony   [quote name='WordBomb' post='41329' date='Mon 6th...  
blissyu2   This actually points more toward her being a ...  
Daniel Brandt   "Many Lockerbie-watchers found it revealing ...  
blissyu2   Mack calls this theory "naive." In fact...  
Infoboy   Additional support for Cooley's statement was...  
Somey   What was the first tip off way back in the day to ...  
Daniel Brandt   What was the first tip off way back in the day to...  
jorge   There are unexciting possibilities one can explo...  
Unrepentant Vandal   But let's not forget that she seems to be an ...  
blissyu2   Okay, let's consider some scenarios: Scenario...  
blissyu2   I think that, unquestionably, Linda Mack changed h...  
LamontStormstar   7) One guy I knew was seriously in to roleplaying...  
blissyu2   7) One guy I knew was seriously in to roleplayin...  
gomi   Or maybe she was kicked out of MI5, tried to get ...  
Cedric   [quote name='LamontStormstar' post='41631' date='...  
blissyu2   [quote name='LamontStormstar' post='41631' date=...  
gomi   So if perhaps Linda Mack had a roleplaying charact...  
blissyu2   So if perhaps Linda Mack had a roleplaying charac...  
jorge   So if perhaps Linda Mack had a roleplaying charac...  
blissyu2   I think it is more likely she or they chose the s...  
jorge   I think it is more likely she or they chose the ...  
blissyu2   [quote name='blissyu2' post='41723' date='Wed 8th...  
Somey   ...maybe she was kicked out of MI5, tried to get a...  
LamontStormstar   [quote name='blissyu2' post='41643' date='Wed 8th...  
The Adversary   Slimmy has claimed to have "journalistic expe...  
WordBomb   Also; one of Slimmys oversighted edits mentioned A...  
Adam Smithee   My guess: Slimmy didn´t even get a cup of tea ...  
Kelly Martin   As someone who's lurked these related threads,...  
Herschelkrustofsky   This is the most reasonable, and to my eyes the m...  
gomi   [quote name='Kelly Martin' post='117308' date='Mon...  
Heat   This is the most reasonable, and to my eyes the ...  
DevilYouKnow   Has she actually published anything, other than l...  
Somey   What "letters to the editor?" I'm no...  
Milton Roe   This is the most reasonable, and to my eyes the m...  
prospero   By comparison with Canada, the US is Agent Capita...  
Disillusioned Lackey   Unfortunately......... she's not in Canada...  
Dzonatas   What is it now, somewhere around a thousand US tro...  
Disillusioned Lackey   What is it now, somewhere around a thousand US tr...  


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now: