CBM has some respect in my book. Krimpet gets a shit ton of respect for putting up with first being attacked on the secret mailing list, then putting up with this and what not.
Guettarda reminds me of another editor (guess who?) and seems to argue just for the sake of arguing.
My two cents on it all.
Also:
Krimpet shows she's perfectly capable of defending herself (though she does call the people here loons).