I know he said he'd prefer to have AfD's be decided strictly by vote-count, but that isn't necessarily inconsistent with this idea that admin recalls should at least require a rationale of some sort. Besides, an AfD is a whole different kettle of fish, right?
It's an interesting problem, but if you ask me they should ban the actual pedophilia advocates
first. If they can manage that, hopefully the issue will go away and they won't have to do anything about the "oh, but they're people too and they have feelings and should have the same right to edit as everyone else" folks.
Still, why is
HerostratusÂ
(T-C-L-K-R-D)
still an administrator? They dealt with
HaiducÂ
(T-C-L-K-R-D)
finally, so I don't see why they're fooling around with this.