The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> Help

This subforum is for critical evaluation of Wikipedia articles. However, to reduce topic-bloat, please make note of exceptionally poor stubs, lists, and other less attention-worthy material in the Miscellaneous Grab Bag thread. Also, please be aware that agents of the Wikimedia Foundation might use your evaluations to improve the articles in question.

Useful Links: Featured Article CandidatesFeatured Article ReviewArticles for DeletionDeletion Review


Forum Topics Replies Last Post Info
New Posts Biographies of Living Persons
This subforum is used for discussion of actual biographical material on Wikipedia. Its contents are hidden from search engines.
303 5,783 Last Post Thu 26th September 2013, 7:32pm
In: Chelsea Manning
By: Retrospect

21 Pages V < 1 2 3 4 > »  Start new topic
> Articles
    Topic Title Replies Topic Starter Views Last Action
No New Posts  
Paid editing
The encyclopedic version
6 jayvdb 2,492 24th 2 12, 9:28pm
Last post by: HRIP7
No New Posts  
Cult of Personality
more systemic bias
12 It's the blimp, Frank 3,170 23rd 2 12, 12:48pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
Destiny
another crap article
6 Peter Damian 1,637 18th 2 12, 7:17pm
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
12 papaya 2,809 17th 2 12, 12:50pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
Shamrock Shake  * 12
Granola-types have it in for McDonald's
34 Emperor 15,335 16th 2 12, 10:49pm
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
3 EricBarbour 1,703 10th 2 12, 6:29pm
Last post by: Versa
No New Posts  
41 EricBarbour 11,017 8th 2 12, 12:49am
Last post by: Vigilant
No New Posts  
Fisting
Wikipedia not censored etc
3 Peter Damian 2,124 5th 2 12, 1:20pm
Last post by: Mister Die
No New Posts  
2 Peter Damian 1,195 4th 2 12, 8:33pm
Last post by: Mister Die
No New Posts  
3 Mister Die 1,925 2nd 2 12, 9:40am
Last post by: Mister Die
No New Posts  
Copy protection
or how Wikipedia pushes its own agenda
8 thekohser 1,574 1st 2 12, 1:20am
Last post by: lilburne
No New Posts  
1 cookiehead 1,087 28th 1 12, 4:43am
Last post by: milowent
No New Posts  
36 Tarc 6,533 28th 1 12, 3:49am
Last post by: Zoloft
Moved  
Moved: Scholars who've asked for their biographies to be deleted
Catholics, Buddhists, feminists, Muslims ...
-- HRIP7 -- 26th 1 12, 6:19am
Last post by: HRIP7
No New Posts  
1 thekohser 1,575 23rd 1 12, 6:43pm
Last post by: Michaeldsuarez
No New Posts  
353 thekohser 77,230 16th 1 12, 3:26am
Last post by: Tarc
No New Posts  
The King of Rome
Some sauce with your pigeon?
6 carbuncle 1,789 14th 1 12, 9:51pm
Last post by: Fusion
Moved  
Moved: Ben Breedlove
-- melloden -- 6th 1 12, 12:06am
Last post by: SB_Johnny
No New Posts
Wikipedia Article Traffic Statistics
Henrik's Hit Parade : WATS UP DOC?
5 Jonny Cache 7,673 5th 1 12, 8:06pm
Last post by: carbuncle
No New Posts  
5 Peter Damian 1,677 4th 1 12, 7:12pm
Last post by: iii
No New Posts  
Oyo Empire
Does it still exist?
8 Emperor 1,936 29th 12 11, 4:27pm
Last post by: Emperor
No New Posts  
Comcast  * 12
20 thekohser 6,299 27th 12 11, 11:20pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
31 thekohser 6,841 27th 12 11, 10:47pm
Last post by: thekohser
No New Posts  
2 Brutus 1,054 25th 12 11, 10:45pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
45 EricBarbour 10,837 13th 12 11, 1:48pm
Last post by: Michaeldsuarez
No New Posts  
2 EricBarbour 1,241 8th 12 11, 3:59am
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
17 Peter Damian 2,265 5th 12 11, 4:15pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
21 MZMcBride 5,608 30th 11 11, 1:17pm
Last post by: carbuncle
No New Posts  
Friedrich Paulus
what was his job in Dresden in the 1950's?
3 thekohser 1,254 26th 11 11, 3:07pm
Last post by: Emperor
No New Posts  
Jacques Derrida
Article rot
8 Peter Damian 4,251 24th 11 11, 6:15pm
Last post by: Maunus
No New Posts  
Female masking unmasked  * 12
It rubs the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again.
23 carbuncle 4,468 22nd 11 11, 2:06am
Last post by: Alison
No New Posts  
Philosophy
always improving, and quickly
8 Peter Damian 1,680 21st 11 11, 9:58pm
Last post by: GlassBeadGame
No New Posts  
Methods of passing as a female
or you can just set up a WP account...
9 the fieryangel 1,560 20th 11 11, 10:51am
Last post by: HRIP7
No New Posts  
Contempt of Parliament
Bad MPs go to the Tower
3 The Joy 1,174 20th 11 11, 12:25am
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
"News Aggregator" cat articles
...Spam Farm Heaven
1 Piperdown 761 19th 11 11, 3:21am
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
Scandalous boobs in the pregnancy article
Split from "Dreadstar" in the editors forum
6 SB_Johnny 1,608 18th 11 11, 1:03am
Last post by: jayvdb
No New Posts  
Pregnancy  * 123
NSFW image
46 Shalom 11,920 17th 11 11, 2:24pm
Last post by: wikieyeay
No New Posts  
21 The Joy 3,278 15th 11 11, 8:39pm
Last post by: Wikifan
No New Posts  
13 radek 2,182 14th 11 11, 9:35pm
Last post by: Detective
No New Posts  
3 A Horse With No Name 2,983 8th 11 11, 12:17am
Last post by: mydog
No New Posts  
5 EricBarbour 1,260 6th 11 11, 9:10am
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
4 Peter Damian 1,467 2nd 11 11, 7:44pm
Last post by: iii
No New Posts  
4 The Joy 1,110 24th 10 11, 10:43pm
Last post by: jd turk
No New Posts  
American imperialism
= Wikipedia
5 Peter Damian 3,650 24th 10 11, 9:15pm
Last post by: papaya
No New Posts  
1 The Joy 1,555 24th 10 11, 9:12pm
Last post by: papaya
No New Posts  
2 communicat 1,012 8th 10 11, 4:31pm
Last post by: communicat
No New Posts  
23 thekohser 6,010 6th 10 11, 9:23pm
Last post by: EricBarbour
No New Posts  
50 -DS- 10,775 6th 10 11, 6:49am
Last post by: Herschelkrustofsky
No New Posts  
Current events on Wikipedia
Here we go again
8 EricBarbour 2,318 19th 9 11, 1:00pm
Last post by: thekohser
No New Posts  
BBDO
Arrogance or Ignorance?
2 the_undertow 1,732 11th 9 11, 10:57am
Last post by: EricBarbour
21 Pages V < 1 2 3 4 > »  Start new topic
3 User(s) are browsing this forum (3 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

New Posts  New Replies
No New Posts  No New Replies
Hot topic  Hot Topic (New)
No new  Hot Topic (No New) 
Poll  Poll (New)
No new votes  Poll (No New)
Closed  Locked Topic
Moved  Moved Topic
 



-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 20th 11 17, 11:44am