FORUM WARNING [2] Division by zero (Line: 2933 of /srcsgcaop/boardclass.php)
Cleaning up after Dr. Blofeld -
     
 
The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> Help

This forum is for discussing specific Wikipedia editors, editing patterns, and general efforts by those editors to influence or direct content in ways that might not be in keeping with Wikipedia policy. Please source your claims and provide links where appropriate. For a glossary of terms frequently used when discussing Wikipedia and related projects, please refer to Wikipedia:Glossary.

> Cleaning up after Dr. Blofeld, ..he can do it himself (Yepp: I'm quitting wp)
The Adversary
post
Post #1


CT (Check Troll)
*****

Group: Regulars
Posts: 801
Joined:
Member No.: 194



Whaw: who would have guessed: after years of complaining and raging again "the cabal" on wp; the person to force me out of turns out to be...Dr. Blofeld (T-C-L-K-R-D) ,

May I introduce myself, I am Huldra (T-C-L-K-R-D) on wp (Btw; I have criticized SlimVirgin every way I could for these last few years....except for her silly user-name. As I am probably the only person on WP to have chosen an even sillier user-name (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/biggrin.gif) )

Now, about 3 years ago, utterly pissed off by Jayjg and Slim, I found my own quiet little corner of Israel/Palestine -articles: Palestinian Arab villages depopulated during the 1948 Palestine War

It was a strange little corner of Wikipedia; every now and then some newbie would start a horrible stub, often half in Arabic, with tons and tons of WP:OR. Typically they would only do a few edits (less that 20) and then disappear from WP totally......which then the "clean-up-task-force" (read: mostly me, Al Ameer son, Tiamut, Ashely (when he´s not blocked) ) would come along and clean up.

So we would turn this into Al-Muzayri'a . And this into Al-Nabi_Yusha' . And this into Saqiya.

Not superb any of them, but at least a decent start. This last one is typical: I think someone simply put the Khalidi-text (in Arabic) through some automatic translation ..so you get gems like "in recent years on the assignment," ...meaning: "in the last years of the (British) Mandate (of Palestine)" (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/tongue.gif)

Oh, and some we just never got around cleaning up: Al-Ja'una

So, slowly, steadfast during the last couple of years we have been progressing. The huge template has been invaluable...but I could only navigate around it because many of the links were red.

Until yesterday. Blofeld comes along and find he does not like red links, and decides that he will start all the red-linked villages...and turn the whole template into on huuuge green soup. And does just that.

Now, I cannot manage to navigate with it anymore.
Oh, well, Blofeld say he will work on the articles, and he does, but he does not have the sources (books). So far he has added nothing to the "public knowledge", he only copies from web-sites which were freely available, anyway. Re-inventing (or: re-writing) the wheel, so to speak. Now, if actually got hold of the books and educated himself on the topic: great. But I fear that in a short time he will be gone (he has a million other articles to attend too, as he has informed us.)

I liked this comment about reaching 3 mill articles on wp: "great, I've managed to poo in every room in the house"

Well, I leave it to Blofeld to clean up his own diarrhoea, eh, poo. I´m out.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
Dr. Blofeld
post
Post #2


New Member
*

Group: Contributors
Posts: 37
Joined:
Member No.: 13,284



Hi! Finally I have been able to get through here and set the record straight. Well you might have heard I abandoned my old account for creating those stubs . Maybe your grilling of me at WR was what was needed to really make me think about the short term consequences of drilling small stubs and not to be so engrossed in planning covering topics. But I am honestly not a vindictive editor.. Believe it or not I do have respect for the views of you guys as at the end of the day the site is supposed to be enjoyed but if people really hated those stubs and me as a result this is not good. The thing is I do have good abillities to write articles but because the amount of notable content missing was often unbearable I resorted to low grade stubs to try to start as much as I could. This was not for narcissistic or malicious reasons, genuinely it wasn't I actually thought I was doing what was right. However recent events and hitting 3 million and realising the amount of shite articles that exist on really notable subjects
as really made me stop and think. Personally I think it is better we have half decent articles on notable topics than drilling in new stubs to add to the workload. I have been trying to get hold of you for ages as I really do care about content and am actually a person with feelings too!

You'll be pleased to know I abandoned my old account and started afresh a week ago and have recently been fleshing out articles on German politicians and Greek museums like Dion Archaelogical Museum, even Bashshit if you care to look not to mention adding references to articles in the BLP list (on my item list check my new user page) and rmeoving spam from south asian articles like Pakistan. I am actually much happier creating good content and slowing down rather than having to resort to robot mode. I will still create the odd new articles every now and again but will try to make it a start class if possible and maybe DYK.Will never create a "sub stub" again, that is a promise, I mean it. As yet nobody on WR has really acknowledged what I've been doing with my new account and that I've reformed and that I really dislike stubs as much as you guys do and that I only did them to try to work towards improving coverage in the long term however bad an attempt
it was. I geuinely am very sorry for the trouble it caused.. A few days ago I actually redirected hundreds of politician stubs back into a list because it was pintless having them and I want to help cleanup, You are just waiting to see "Dr. Blofeld" spewed across the new pages in robo format. Never again, seriously. Only time will tell, and if everynow and then you check to see what Himalayan Explorer is up to these days you might even be pleasantly surprised....

Although it really is time to change focus on wikipedia anyay and focus on quality, really it is very worrying when you hit a random category and you just know most of the articles will either be short or unreferenced, I am admittedly imfluenced by what others say and think of me and if people view me in hate as this robotic kid it is definately time to change. I do thrive on encouragement, as most people do, and have always been affected by criticism, if I can help make people happier with doing something useful rather than problematic I would prefer not to have a lot of people hating my guts. I think time is too short to not enjoy things and if none of us enjoy short stubs (it wasn't exactly a bundle of fun for me creating them either) then it will be no more. Given that I have had a lot of eperience as Blofeld on wiki this has not been an easy thing for me to do and I hope you at least show me some respect for changing and now focusing on expanding those stubs that
that that "bastard" Blofeld created.

I am equally keen to support Huldra, and am willing to do what takes to convert problems into something beneficial.
Keep in touch if you want, I am, well, a little different from what was said about me in person, anyway.... And the Blofeld name was not because I am a juvenile spotty teenager, I'm 26 years old and actually dress quite well and do actually have interests in playing guitar and piano and sports although I admittedly spent way too much time on wiki as I'm sure a lot of people can confess to, but we have a lot of potential which needs to be fullfilled!!... The name was to provide a bit of relief from the stress and serious issues that often go on there at ANI etc and to try to not take myself too seriously....

Anyway thanks for whipping my arse into shape, I definately feel better doing what I#m doing now, but please try to not attacking me as this dreadful lowlife and at least recognise I have changed because I do partly respect you views on wiki and partly feel the same way as you do in regards to quality anyway as hard to believe it may seem, this is why I give enough of a damn to have abandoned my old account and ending it. I really hope you will start to see me in different light and that I have feelings, as well as goals to work towards on wikipedia and want it to be an enjoyable site as much as you guys do, and most of all, I am on your side!!.

Now you are free to burn Blofeld on the stake if you think that would put an end to all his "Aevil" but I would rather move on and work towards expanding those stubs that Blofeld created as well as cleaning up the shite from the Pakistani and Indian place articles. Man have you seen them? They glorify the local taxi driver as a famous dude LOL. List of 2500 schools in CAP LOCKS. The thing is we have recently gained 17,000 new articles not through me but by other people, as we speak there are people generating one liners about insects without any content, it will always be a problem until something is done to curb growth. IN thinking about it, it might not be a bit idea to set a minimum new article at say 1 kb of actual text to stop sub stubs being generated in future. I for one am certainly open to this and would be happy to discuss. On a personal note, if you want an article expan (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/smile.gif) ded please let me know, as long as it isn't about something like physics
or maths LOL. Name a geography or cultural article you want expanded and I'll see what I can do.

Best regards,

P.S. I like you too Horsey.....

User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
everyking
post
Post #3


Postmaster
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,368
Joined:
Member No.: 81



QUOTE(Dr. Blofeld @ Sun 30th August 2009, 11:17pm) *

Hi! Finally I have been able to get through here and set the record straight. Well you might have heard I abandoned my old account for creating those stubs . Maybe your grilling of me at WR was what was needed to really make me think about the short term consequences of drilling small stubs and not to be so engrossed in planning covering topics. But I am honestly not a vindictive editor.. Believe it or not I do have respect for the views of you guys as at the end of the day the site is supposed to be enjoyed but if people really hated those stubs and me as a result this is not good. The thing is I do have good abillities to write articles but because the amount of notable content missing was often unbearable I resorted to low grade stubs to try to start as much as I could. This was not for narcissistic or malicious reasons, genuinely it wasn't I actually thought I was doing what was right. However recent events and hitting 3 million and realising the amount of shite articles that exist on really notable subjects
as really made me stop and think. Personally I think it is better we have half decent articles on notable topics than drilling in new stubs to add to the workload. I have been trying to get hold of you for ages as I really do care about content and am actually a person with feelings too!


You deserve a lot of credit for this. Thanks for accepting the criticism (and looking past the mean-spirited parts of it), and I hope you keep up the good work on Wikipedia.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
The Adversary   Cleaning up after Dr. Blofeld  
Mariner   You have learnt a lesson the hard way Now you are...  
Sarcasticidealist   I'm always disappointed when I find out the Wi...  
One   I'm always disappointed when I find out the W...  
Somey   I saw him at Naked short selling last summer. He c...  
One   I saw him at Naked short selling last summer. He ...  
A Horse With No Name   Oops, wait, there's a [url=http://en.wikiped...  
The Adversary   Ah, my very last DYK: "Did you know, that The...  
A Horse With No Name   (That´s part of horsey that I´m eating in ...  
Apathetic   I was literally sitting crying my eyes out last ...  
A Horse With No Name   I was literally sitting crying my eyes out last...  
EricBarbour   I was literally sitting crying my eyes out last ni...  
The Adversary   It really isn't the end of the world, though....  
jayvdb   [quote name='Apathetic' post='189900' date='Tue 1...  
everyking   [quote name='Apathetic' post='189900' date='Tue ...  
Milton Roe   There is also a feature which allows each person ...  
jayvdb   [quote name='jayvdb' post='190030' date='Wed 19th...  
Milton Roe   (And I´m female! And, eh, born a true tr...  
Emperor   Oh boy. I have been working on these 48-villages...  
The Adversary   [quote name='The Adversary' post='189898' date='T...  
Emperor   Yes you've thrown a footnote in, but it sounds...  
Floydsvoid   And anyway, I am also a [url=http://en.wikipedia...  
A Horse With No Name   As an aside, I always thought Xeno a bit of a dou...  
CharlotteWebb   Not that I would, I don't know you from Adam ...  
Milton Roe   [quote name='Milton Roe' post='190125' date='Thu ...  
CharlotteWebb   But no, it's apparently not politically corre...  
JohnA   (And I´m female! And, eh, born a true t...  
The Adversary   (And I´m female! And, eh, born [url=htt...  
EricBarbour   I started "collecting" information about...  
Emperor   I know. However, there are other wikis. Some are ...  
Milton Roe   [quote name='EricBarbour' post='189951' date='Tue...  
Emperor   Of course. I like red links. They are one of t...  
A Horse With No Name   If the main article says that the primary Buttcra...  
Milton Roe   I am a hopeless collector, normally I collect ite...  
The Adversary   I still maintain the damage these people have don...  
JohnA   [quote name='The Adversary' post='189898' date='...  
The Adversary   <snip> I need all the cheap thrills I can g...  
Milton Roe   [quote name='The Adversary' post='189947' date='W...  
JohnA   [quote name='The Adversary' post='189947' date='...  
A Horse With No Name   I'm just amazed that someone can announce her...  
The Adversary   I'm just amazed that someone can announce her...  
JohnA   I'm just amazed that someone can announce he...  
The Adversary   No, and for the same reason I don't debate ra...  
JohnA   No, and for the same reason I don't debate r...  
Newyorkbrad   I'm always disappointed when I find out the W...  
Sarcasticidealist   No, Newyorkbrad is Newyorkbrad, because that's...  
A Horse With No Name   No, Newyorkbrad is Newyorkbrad, because that...  
Lar   [quote name='Sarcasticidealist' post='190047' dat...  
AlioTheFool   I'm always disappointed when I find out the ...  
Newyorkbrad   [quote name='Newyorkbrad' post='190046' date='Wed...  
GlassBeadGame   [quote name='Newyorkbrad' post='190046' date='We...  
Newyorkbrad   Please tell me you changed your password and emai...  
Somey   Oh, well, Blofeld say he will work on the article...  
Apathetic   There's a proposal up at the village pump to c...  
Somey   There's a proposal up at the village pump to c...  
Friday   I ran into this Blofeld kid once before.. I don...  
Milton Roe   So, slowly, steadfast during the last couple of ...  
Apathetic   A shame. Some people (ahem) managed to get enough...  
Milton Roe   A shame. Some people (ahem) managed to get enoug...  
Apathetic   [i][b]Good red links help Wikipedia—they ...  
Milton Roe   [quote name='Milton Roe' post='189907' date='Tue ...  
CharlotteWebb   The whole assumption behind the satement that ...  
Anonymous editor   Dr. Blofeld is a pox on Wikipedia. He creates thou...  
Tarc   Apparently Blofeld lurks here, as he's on the ...  
nableezy   Apparently Blofeld lurks here, as he's on the...  
Tarc   [quote name='Tarc' post='189885' date='Tue 18th A...  
Cock-up-over-conspiracy   Since I cant say this on-wiki after a warning for ...  
A Horse With No Name   Oh, I love Blofeld -- good for you, character...  
Anonymous editor   Same old, same old. We saw this with Aitias, who t...  
A Horse With No Name   Well, now Smashville unblocked him. That was fun....  
nableezy   Of course it isn't - what stupid behavior...  
A Horse With No Name   Of course he has a right to create these articles...  
The Adversary   Of course he has a right to create these articles...  
Cla68   Blofeld once asked me to start an article that was...  
The Adversary   Adversary, you didn't want those articles cre...  
Floydsvoid   Yo, Somey, he's making it personal :D BloTar...  
Somey   Yo, Somey, he's making it [url=http://en.wikip...  
Sarcasticidealist   And frankly, how dare this "Protonk" cha...  
A Horse With No Name   I his defense, I'm a huge narcissist. Well,...  
The Joy   What was most infuriating was AdjustShift's co...  
Somey   Mass stub creation of the sort this "Blofeld...  
EricBarbour   It would be helpful to coin a new term for this so...  
Grep   I notice that there's rather little interest i...  
Kelly Martin   I notice that there's rather little interest i...  
Moulton   Harden not your core.  
LaraLove   Whaw: who would have guessed: after years of comp...  
One   He and a partner or two just created a few thousa...  
LaraLove   He and a partner or two just created a few thous...  
One   My thoughts exactly. I don't recall if it was...  
LaraLove   Yeah. I've just caught up to the end of the t...  
everyking   Oh, God. He does this with BLPs too? It's bad...  
Somey   There is a big difference between naming and shami...  
LaraLove   Oh yea, and can a mod split off JohnA's unrela...  
Mr. Mystery   (Btw; I have criticized SlimVirgin every way I ...  
LaraLove   Fantastic example of his narcissism: March 1, 200...  
The Adversary   Fantastic example of his narcissism: March 1, 20...  
Milton Roe   I really wish someone with scrip-writing ability...  
Somey   Another: Fix things so that really short stubs [b]...  
The Adversary   Another: Fix things so that really short stubs [b...  
Milton Roe   [quote name='Somey' post='190130' date='Thu 20th ...  
LessHorrid vanU   [quote name='Somey' post='190130' date='Thu 20th...  
Apathetic   I wonder if a bot could be written to auto delete...  
LessHorrid vanU   I wonder if a bot could be written to auto delet...  
Milton Roe   Feh! When I was at school the smart kids at m...  
Kelly Martin   I also want to put in my vote for typing as one of...  
The Adversary   I also want to put in my vote for typing as one o...  
A Horse With No Name   I believe you may be falling for a red herring he...  
The Adversary   Amazing the sad lives some people leave, isn...  
Somey   Oh, come on -- give the Blo Baby a break. He is w...  
A Horse With No Name   Also, I don't have "block buttons" ...  
Kelly Martin   I believe you may be falling for a red herring her...  
WikiWatch   I believe you may be falling for a red herring he...  
jayvdb   I really wish someone with scrip-writing abilit...  
Nerd   I've said it before, I'll say it again: I ...  
Apathetic   Lara, do you have a link to the AFD on the politi...  
Nerd   Lara, do you have a link to the AFD on the polit...  
LaraLove   I just saw this gem from Protonk: "I'm fi...  
A Horse With No Name   I just saw this gem from Protonk: "I'm f...  
grievous   Self-fluffing creation of meaningless stubs aside,...  
The Adversary   Self-fluffing creation of meaningless stubs aside...  
Apathetic   [quote name='grievous' post='190257' date='Thu 20...  
Nerd   [quote name='grievous' post='190257' date='Thu 2...  
Sarcasticidealist   I'm partial to A Nobody's prior username, ...  
A Horse With No Name   [quote name='Apathetic' post='190262' date='Thu 2...  
LaraLove   I got an email from a butthurt Blofeld with threat...  
A Horse With No Name   I got an email from a butthurt Blofeld with threa...  
LaraLove   I got an email from a butthurt Blofeld with thre...  
A Horse With No Name   His user space is sprinkled with images of himself...  
Apathetic   The french commune articles (all thirty thousand o...  
Nerd   [quote name='A Horse With No Name' post='190267' ...  
Apathetic   Oh? The only image of him I ever saw was of his ...  
Eva Destruction   I got an email from a butthurt Blofeld with threa...  
A Horse With No Name   I got an email from a butthurt Blofeld with thre...  
grievous   I've created a handful of articles, and trust...  
Malleus   I've created a handful of articles, and trus...  
LaraLove   His user space is sprinkled with images of himsel...  
Robster   [quote name='Eva Destruction' post='190279' date=...  
LaraLove   Isn't that some level of threat? Doesn't...  
Robster   [quote name='Robster' post='190329' date='Thu 20t...  
Malleus   You know that if you had been the one to make any...  
LaraLove   You know that if you had been the one to make an...  
everyking   [quote name='Malleus' post='190359' date='Thu 20t...  
Cedric   Normally that would be understandable, but as I r...  
CharlotteWebb   "Perhaps a little something involving . . . ...  
LessHorrid vanU   "Perhaps a little something involving . . ....  
CharlotteWebb   I even briefly looked for a picture of the archet...  
A Horse With No Name   [quote name='Robster' post='190329' date='Thu 20t...  
everyking   My problem with Blofeld's stubs isn't that...  
EricBarbour   This is all pointless. Speculating on how to prev...  
Moulton   Index finger to the corner of the mouth signifies ...  
A Horse With No Name   Index finger to the corner of the mouth signifies...  
Anonymous editor   He got himself renamed to Himalayan Explorer. Not...  
Eva Destruction   He got himself renamed to Himalayan Explorer. No...  
Nerd   He got himself renamed to Himalayan Explorer. N...  
The Adversary   Just the idea to start hundreds of BLP articles i...  
Somey   Finally: I said I NEEDED the big [url=http://en....  
A Horse With No Name   Wow, this guy is more fun than a barrel of monkeys...  
Apathetic   Hi! Finally I have been able to get through h...  
A Horse With No Name   Hi! Finally I have been able to get through ...  
A Horse With No Name   You deserve a lot of credit for this. Thanks for ...  
Malleus   Hi! Finally I have been able to get through ...  
Dr. Blofeld   The dilemna I always faced was balancing the sheer...  
RMHED   The dilemna I always faced was balancing the shee...  
A Horse With No Name   Yo Blo, 'tis obvious you care about da 'p...  
The Adversary   And welcome to the Review, Blofeld/HE! I will...  
Dr. Blofeld   :) :) :) :) :) Thankyou all. Huldra you may ...  
A Horse With No Name   Now I do have a LOT of articles to expand and clea...  
CharlotteWebb   Hey, Blo, nice work on the DYK for this: [url=htt...  
A Horse With No Name   Hey, Blo, nice work on the DYK for this: [url=ht...  
Dr. Blofeld   :blink: Officially the area was measured during th...  
Apathetic   Take a break from that and finish some more ITAL f...  
Malleus   :blink: Officially the area was measured during t...  
nableezy   Dunums or no dunums, I continue to be very impres...  
CharlotteWebb   :blink: Officially the area was measured during t...  
The Adversary   Yes, great to see that Blofeld, or rather HE, is e...  
CharlotteWebb   The [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunam]Dunam...  
thekohser   In the interest of disclosure, it was Blofeld who ...  


Reply to this topicStart new topic
2 User(s) are reading this topic (2 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now:
 
     
FORUM WARNING [2] Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home2/wikipede/public_html/int042kj398.php:242) (Line: 0 of Unknown)