The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
> On Deck, The next request to be served is...
MaliceAforethought
post Fri 1st July 2011, 12:06am
Post #1


u Mad?
***

Group: Contributors
Posts: 206
Joined: Tue 21st Jun 2011, 6:54am
From: Wonderland
Member No.: 57,801



Up Next
  • NSLE [deadmin] (May-June 2006)
  • Alienus [case] (June-August 2006)
  • A Man In Black [case] (Feb-June 2009)
  • EEML [Manning vs Shell Kinney] (late 2009)
  • Chacor/NSLE [RfA attempts] (September 2006/March 2007)
  • Jiujitsuguy [Off-wiki lobbying] (August/September 2010)
  • C68-FM-SV (16 May 2008 - 24 September 2008)
  • Attack sites/WP:BADSITES (September-October 2007)
  • 174.115.134.69/Tyciol [ban] (September 2010)
  • Zscout370 [flash desysop] (December 2007)
  • Why does Jimbo hate the Bishzilla (pre-2009)
  • Allegations of apartheid [case] (Aug-Oct 2007)
  • SlimVirgin [defrocking] (Nov 2008)
  • Jeff Merkey info here
Missing Dates
  • Changes to AC list [kicking old AC off] (no date)
  • The Law/Undertow [AC knowledge of socking] (no date)
  • Tanthala39 [flame out] (no date)
  • Casliber/John Vandenberg/Kirill/Coren [resignations] (various)
  • RMHED [being a tool] (frequently)
  • Jimbo [puppeteer] (entire history)
  • Runtshit [vandalism] (no date)
  • Blissyu2/Zordrac [ban] (no date)
  • Blu Aardvark [ban] (no date)
  • Melsaran [ban] (no date)
  • MidnightBlueMan / Mister Flash [ban] (no date)
  • VampWillow / AlisonW [dueling admin accounts] (no date)
  • Aitais [case] (no date)
No Information
  • David Shankbone [no incident] (no date)
  • Danny Wool [no incident] (no date)
  • Catolun? Doran [no incident] (no date)
  • Brad Patrick [no incident] (no date)
  • Rand Montoya [no incident] (no date)
  • Cirt [no incident] (no date)
  • Mattisse [no incident] (no date)
  • Haiduc [no incident] (no date)
  • Off2riorob [no incident] (no date)
  • ArmedBlowfish/AB [no incident] (no date)
  • Ottava [moar] (no date)
  • JIDF/David Applebaum[no incident] (no date)
  • ED [no incident] (no date)
  • GNAA [no incident] (no date)
  • Sergeant Snopake and Nathanr [no incident] (no date)
Greedy
  • Abd-William M. Connolley (July-Sep 2009)
  • Clarification (17 Sep-10 Oct 2009)
  • Clarifications (Jan-April 2010)
  • AE requests 31 December, 2009, by MastCell/27 February, 2010, by SamJohnston/17 March, 2010, by Enric Naval/18 June, 2010, by Hipocrite/5 January, 2011, by TenOfAllTrades
Fill in dates or details to get a bump up the list.

Completed RequestsNothing Found
  • Abd/EnergyNeutral May 2011 (no discussion on any en list)
  • The Hunger arbitration case (Cirt was called "Smeelgova" then): June to August 2006 (no mention in 2006)
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
melloden
post Fri 1st July 2011, 3:04am
Post #2


.
****

Group: Contributors
Posts: 450
Joined: Tue 30th Nov 2010, 4:43pm
Member No.: 34,482



Sophie - November to December 2010, probably on both ArbCom and functionaries lists if you have the archives for the latter too?
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Abd
post Fri 1st July 2011, 8:03pm
Post #3


Postmaster
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,916
Joined: Tue 18th Nov 2008, 10:52pm
From: Northampton, MA, USA
Member No.: 9,019

WP user page - talk
check - contribs



Abd [AC cases/Fritzpoll/EnergyNeutral] (various)

Activity might begin as early as 25 April 2009, with the opening of Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Abd and JzG

However, that first RfAr was pretty uncontroversial, really; what would be interesting would be if bias were earlier revealed. What was in public seemed fine, as to any arbitrator behavior.

Things got intense during Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Abd-William M. Connolley where certain arbitrators ignored the proposals of the drafting arb -- who had actually investigated -- and the decision radically reversed.

Later, there were massive gaps in my activity with probable gaps in mention of me and related issues, but matters continued to be brought before ArbComm, almost entirely raised by others, until I finally requested clarification at the end of April, 2011, which request was refused. I did email arbcom-l in early May, as I recall.

While any prior mentions of me would be unlikely, they would of course be of interest to me.

Anything relating to Fritzpoll's mentorship offer for me in late 2009 or early 2010, and his later resignation, would be of interest.

EnergyNeutral was just me, so almost certainly Abd would be mentioned if this even came up. EnergyNeutral was entirely May, 2011.

This post has been edited by Abd: Fri 1st July 2011, 8:05pm
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
the fieryangel
post Sat 2nd July 2011, 9:14am
Post #4


the Internet Review Corporation is watching you...
********

Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,990
Joined: Tue 21st Nov 2006, 9:49pm
From: It's all in your mind anyway...
Member No.: 577



David Shankbone May 2008 incident : Gretab/MusikFabrik/"hiatus"
Jan-March 2009 incident : David Saranga/Michael Lucas/Israel
December 2009 site ban

Haiduc Jan-Feb 2010 site ban


User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
thekohser
post Sat 2nd July 2011, 2:28pm
Post #5


Member
*********

Group: Regulars
Posts: 10,274
Joined: Thu 1st Feb 2007, 10:21pm
Member No.: 911



QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Thu 30th June 2011, 8:06pm) *
  • Catolun Doran [no incident] (no date)

Catolun?
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
the fieryangel
post Sat 2nd July 2011, 2:31pm
Post #6


the Internet Review Corporation is watching you...
********

Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,990
Joined: Tue 21st Nov 2006, 9:49pm
From: It's all in your mind anyway...
Member No.: 577



Here's another : blocking of self-identified pedophiles : February-March 2007 per : http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...ified_pedophile
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Proofreader77
post Wed 6th July 2011, 5:55am
Post #7


Neophyte


Group: Contributors
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon 25th Jan 2010, 5:30am
From: California
Member No.: 16,819

WP user page - talk
check - contribs



Proofreader77 Feb-March 2010
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Bishonen
post Wed 13th July 2011, 4:01pm
Post #8


Neophyte


Group: Contributors
Posts: 7
Joined: Wed 20th Feb 2008, 6:32pm
Member No.: 4,966

WP user page - talk
check - contribs



QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Fri 1st July 2011, 12:06am) *
  • Jimbo blocks Bishonen (July 2009)
  • Proofreader77 (Feb/March 2010)
  • Guido den Broeder info here
  • Cool3/Cool three (Feb 2010)
  • NSLE [deadmin] (May-June 2006)
  • Alienus [case] (June-August 2006)
  • A Man In Black [case] (Feb-June 2009)
  • EEML [Manning vs Shell Kinney] (late 2009)
  • Chacor/NSLE [RfA attempts] (September 2006/March 2007)
    Fill in dates or details to get a bump up the list.

    Please note that it wasn't me that requested the "Jimbo blocks Bishonen" topic. But if the more specific dates would be convenient, here they are:

    22 May 2009: Jimbo blocked me for three hours. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...h=-1&tagfilter= I think, per gossip I've heard, that there was some hot action on ArbCom-L about that block.

    20 July 2009: I filed for arbitration of Jimbo. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...oldid=306113495

    1-3 August 2009: After much discussion, some of which I had access to, ArbCom refused a full case and instead passed a motion reproaching me muchly and Jimbo a smidgeon: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...Proposed_motion.

    Bishonen
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    thekohser
    post Wed 13th July 2011, 4:20pm
    Post #9


    Member
    *********

    Group: Regulars
    Posts: 10,274
    Joined: Thu 1st Feb 2007, 10:21pm
    Member No.: 911



    QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Thu 30th June 2011, 8:06pm) *
    • Cool3/Cool three (Feb 2010)
    Fill in dates or details to get a bump up the list.


    I believe the key dates for Cool3 would be about January 13, 2010 through February 8, 2010. I'll be curious to see what the esteemed ArbCom had to say about that one!
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Abd
    post Thu 14th July 2011, 9:29pm
    Post #10


    Postmaster
    *******

    Group: Regulars
    Posts: 1,916
    Joined: Tue 18th Nov 2008, 10:52pm
    From: Northampton, MA, USA
    Member No.: 9,019

    WP user page - talk
    check - contribs



    from the list, Abd [Abd and WMC case] (no date).

    This was actually the most significant case, it was a precursor to the Climate Change arbitration, a place where ArbComm dodged the opportunity to address the Climate Change cabal. Formal name: Abd-William M. Connolley.

    Case Opened on 11:57, 15 July 2009 (UTC)
    Case Closed on 22:30, 13 September 2009 (UTC)

    There were clarification requests

    September 17, 2009, filed by IP, allegedly it was me, but it wasn't, archived , archived October 10
    January 1, 2010, filed by me, archived January 10.
    January 11, 2010 , filed by William M. Connolley, archived February 2.
    January 27, 2010, filed by me, archived March 10
    March 16, 2010, filed by Enric Naval, archived 7 April.

    The April/May activity, 2011, was already provided, thanks.

    There were arbitration enforcement requests relating to this case, filed
    31 December, 2009, by MastCell
    27 February, 2010, by SamJohnston
    17 March, 2010, by Enric Naval
    18 June, 2010, by Hipocrite
    5 January, 2011, by TenOfAllTrades

    I don't know if the enforcement requests received any ArbComm attention.

    Geez, I really was harassed, I never compiled a list of these in one place. Seems to me I missed an AE request, too.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Cla68
    post Thu 14th July 2011, 11:13pm
    Post #11


    Postmaster
    *******

    Group: Regulars
    Posts: 1,763
    Joined: Fri 18th Apr 2008, 5:53pm
    Member No.: 5,761

    WP user page - talk
    check - contribs



    I would be curious to see the behind-the-scenes discussion that led to this comment in early July 2008.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Herschelkrustofsky
    post Fri 15th July 2011, 12:27am
    Post #12


    Member
    *********

    Group: Members
    Posts: 5,199
    Joined: Tue 18th Apr 2006, 12:05pm
    From: Kalifornia
    Member No.: 130

    WP user page - talk
    check - contribs



    QUOTE(Cla68 @ Thu 14th July 2011, 4:13pm) *

    I would be curious to see the behind-the-scenes discussion that led to this comment in early July 2008.

    Like he said.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Rhindle
    post Fri 15th July 2011, 4:23am
    Post #13


    Senior Member
    ****

    Group: Contributors
    Posts: 324
    Joined: Mon 30th Jun 2008, 8:51pm
    Member No.: 6,834



    QUOTE(Cla68 @ Thu 14th July 2011, 4:13pm) *

    I would be curious to see the behind-the-scenes discussion that led to this comment in early July 2008.

    Thirded. I was just starting to read WR before I joined it a little bit later and, after rereading the PD page, forgot how long it took them to make a decision on this case. This would probably be the case I'm most interested reading about. I am curious to see how much private activity was going on while everyone was waiting around trying to find out what the outcome will be.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Cla68
    post Fri 15th July 2011, 4:55am
    Post #14


    Postmaster
    *******

    Group: Regulars
    Posts: 1,763
    Joined: Fri 18th Apr 2008, 5:53pm
    Member No.: 5,761

    WP user page - talk
    check - contribs



    QUOTE(Rhindle @ Fri 15th July 2011, 4:23am) *

    QUOTE(Cla68 @ Thu 14th July 2011, 4:13pm) *

    I would be curious to see the behind-the-scenes discussion that led to this comment in early July 2008.

    Thirded. I was just starting to read WR before I joined it a little bit later and, after rereading the PD page, forgot how long it took them to make a decision on this case. This would probably be the case I'm most interested reading about. I am curious to see how much private activity was going on while everyone was waiting around trying to find out what the outcome will be.


    Actually, any discussion that took place before or after that proposal might be illuminating.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Text
    post Sun 17th July 2011, 1:00am
    Post #15


    Senior Member
    ****

    Group: Contributors
    Posts: 491
    Joined: Sun 1st Nov 2009, 3:08pm
    Member No.: 15,107



    Anything with:

    - Blissyu2 / Zordrac
    - Blu Aardvark
    - Melsaran
    - MidnightBlueMan / Mister Flash
    - VampWillow / AlisonW
    - Zanthalon
    - Pol64
    - Midnight68

    ?
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    The Adversary
    post Sun 17th July 2011, 4:07pm
    Post #16


    CT (Check Troll)
    *****

    Group: Regulars
    Posts: 801
    Joined: Sat 20th May 2006, 12:09am
    Member No.: 194



    QUOTE(Cla68 @ Fri 15th July 2011, 4:55am) *

    QUOTE(Rhindle @ Fri 15th July 2011, 4:23am) *

    QUOTE(Cla68 @ Thu 14th July 2011, 4:13pm) *

    I would be curious to see the behind-the-scenes discussion that led to this comment in early July 2008.

    Thirded. I was just starting to read WR before I joined it a little bit later and, after rereading the PD page, forgot how long it took them to make a decision on this case. This would probably be the case I'm most interested reading about. I am curious to see how much private activity was going on while everyone was waiting around trying to find out what the outcome will be.


    Actually, any discussion that took place before or after that proposal might be illuminating.

    Fourth.
    Also, the Requests for arbitration/Allegations of apartheid, in Aug., Oct-2007, was a fascinating case, me think.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Proofreader77
    post Tue 19th July 2011, 5:57pm
    Post #17


    Neophyte


    Group: Contributors
    Posts: 19
    Joined: Mon 25th Jan 2010, 5:30am
    From: California
    Member No.: 16,819

    WP user page - talk
    check - contribs



    My sincere thanks to Dr. House. :-)
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Gary_Niger
    post Tue 2nd August 2011, 1:10am
    Post #18


    New Member
    *

    Group: Contributors
    Posts: 32
    Joined: Fri 29th Jul 2011, 2:07am
    From: Tarzana, California
    Member No.: 60,914



    QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Thu 30th June 2011, 8:06pm) *

    GNAA [no incident] (no date)


    Frankly, there are far too many incidents for me to place a date on this. I am, however, very well informed on the GNAA-Wikipedia relationship and could most likely place a date on this if/when this is made public.

    QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Thu 30th June 2011, 8:06pm) *

    ED [no incident] (no date)


    Would probably be interesting too, as well as anything related to Blu Aardvark.

    This post has been edited by Gary_Niger: Tue 2nd August 2011, 1:18am
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    It's the blimp, Frank
    post Tue 2nd August 2011, 2:29am
    Post #19


    Über Member
    *****

    Group: Regulars
    Posts: 734
    Joined: Mon 27th Mar 2006, 3:54pm
    Member No.: 82



    QUOTE(The Adversary @ Sun 17th July 2011, 4:07pm) *

    Also, the Requests for arbitration/Allegations of apartheid, in Aug., Oct-2007, was a fascinating case, me think.


    Yeah, let's see that one.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post
    Gary_Niger
    post Tue 2nd August 2011, 4:34pm
    Post #20


    New Member
    *

    Group: Contributors
    Posts: 32
    Joined: Fri 29th Jul 2011, 2:07am
    From: Tarzana, California
    Member No.: 60,914



    QUOTE(Gary_Niger @ Mon 1st August 2011, 9:10pm) *

    QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Thu 30th June 2011, 8:06pm) *

    GNAA [no incident] (no date)


    Frankly, there are far too many incidents for me to place a date on this. I am, however, very well informed on the GNAA-Wikipedia relationship and could most likely place a date on this if/when this is made public.

    QUOTE(MaliceAforethought @ Thu 30th June 2011, 8:06pm) *

    ED [no incident] (no date)


    Would probably be interesting too, as well as anything related to Blu Aardvark.

    The incident is probably included in this, BTW.
    User is offlineProfile CardPM
    Go to the top of the page
    +Quote Post

    Reply to this topicStart new topic
    3 User(s) are reading this topic (3 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
    0 Members:

     

    -   Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 22nd 10 17, 7:19pm