The polls are closed -- watch for results, the 2011 WP:DICK of Distinction awards pageant Options Rating

[Herschelkrustofsky]

Remember your basic instructions: you have a total of 3 points to award to DICK contestants. You may award all three to one candidate by voting for that person as both DICK and runner-up, or you may divide them by giving 2 to a DICK candidate and 1 to a runner-up. The winner will be the contestant with the highest combined point total.

You must cast one vote in every category. The last selection is the equivalent of a "pass."


All other categories are more straightforward: you have one vote for each category. Use it wisely.

Here, for any N00bs, are the definitions for each category:

WP:DICK of Distinction -- for all-around rottenness by an admin

The Tag-Team Event (see Wikipedia:Tag team)

Miss Incongeniality, for original and flamboyant violations of Wikipedia:Civility

Vexatious Litigant, for the person who just can't get enough of those noticeboards and arbitration cases

and for the good guys...

the Straight Shooter award for honest admins

and the Cojones de latón, for the non-admin who has distinguished himself in combat with the cabal

Click here for a history of this exalted competition, if you need the back-story.

All set? Let's vote! Keep it clean. Winners will be announced after the voting peters out in about 10 days.

[CharlotteWebb]

The Climate Cabal: William M. Connelley, Kim Dabelstein Petersen, Dave Souza, Stephan Schulz, and Joshua P. Schroeder née ScienceApologist

Dr. Connolley really hates it when people misspell his name.

[Jon Awbrey]

Dr. Connolley really hates it when people misspell his name.

I move we call him “The WC” from this day forward.

Now Flush The WC And Move On …

Jon (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/tongue.gif)

[Alison]

Porn protection cabal is streaking into the lead, I see.

[Gruntled]

Porn protection cabal is streaking into the lead, I see.

I hope they're having full frontal shots taken of their streaking. That would be vital encyclopedic material. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/mellow.gif)

[Ottava]

Porn protection cabal is streaking into the lead, I see.

(IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/sick.gif)

[Herschelkrustofsky]

Interesting... for the first time, several members in good standing of the Review are making a strong showing in the Bad Guys categories.

[The Adversary]

Interesting... for the first time, several members in good standing of the Review are making a strong showing in the Bad Guys categories.

Are you talking about Ottava? (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/biggrin.gif)


On another note: I think this year is a first (?): neither Jayjg or SlimVirgin have been nominated in any category.

See, what happen when we do not have our normal piñatas to kick: we run around like headless chicken (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/tongue.gif)

[pablo]

"Vexatious litigant" is a tricky one; spoilt for choice ...

[Herschelkrustofsky]

And they're off! In early polling, Cirt leads the pack with 19 points, followed by Sandstein with 14 points, GeorgeWilliamherbert with 11, and the Review's own Lar with 10. The Porn Protectors have established themselves as the team to beat in the tag event, while the Review's own Ottava owns Miss Incongeniality with 12 votes, followed by IronDuke and Tarc with 6 each. The Vexatious Litigant race is wide open with the Review's own Abd leading Baseball Bugs, Cyclopedia and FT2 by a narrow margin. In the Straight Shooter event, Scott MacDonald née Doc glasgow looks unstoppable with Will Beback practically calling him a Scientologist at Wikipedia talk:Requests for arbitration/Scientology. And finally for Cojones de latón, perennial favorite Cla68 has an early lead, but MZMcBride is breathing down his neck with only a one vote margin between them. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/popcorn.gif)

[Doc glasgow]

And they're off! In early polling, Cirt leads the pack with 19 points, followed by Sandstein with 14 points, GeorgeWilliamherbert with 11, and the Review's own Lar with 10. The Porn Protectors have established themselves as the team to beat in the tag event, while the Review's own Ottava owns Miss Incongeniality with 12 votes, followed by IronDuke and Tarc with 6 each. The Vexatious Litigant race is wide open with the Review's own Abd leading Baseball Bugs, Cyclopedia and FT2 by a narrow margin. In the Straight Shooter event, Scott MacDonald née Doc glasgow looks unstoppable with Will Beback practically calling him a Scientologist at Wikipedia talk:Requests for arbitration/Scientology. And finally for Cojones de latón, perennial favorite Cla68 has an early lead, but MZMcBride is breathing down his neck with only a one vote margin between them. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/popcorn.gif)

Gotta give Will beback points for trying? No. Maybe I am a Scientologist - or maybe I just don't think we should describe everyone who once went to a Scientology meeting as "evil cultist bastard" on their BLP?

Anyway, can I put in his early nomination for next year's "Vexatious Litigant"?

[DollyD]

Go MZMcBride for Cojones de latón!

[EricBarbour]

For sheer quantity of hatred and backstabby stuff, Cirt deserves the big win.

(Do you realize that not one of the past DICK winners has changed their behavior
in the slightest as a result of winning? It would be nice to think that people like SV,
Jayjg and JzG were eventually sanctioned partly as a result of winning, but you'd have
some real difficulty proving it. Being called a DICK, repeatedly, hasn't affected
Gerard in the slightest.)

[JayT]

For sheer quantity of hatred and backstabby stuff, Cirt deserves the big win.

(Do you realize that not one of the past DICK winners has changed their behavior
in the slightest as a result of winning? It would be nice to think that people like SV,
Jayjg and JzG were eventually sanctioned partly as a result of winning, but you'd have
some real difficulty proving it. Being called a DICK, repeatedly, hasn't affected
Gerard in the slightest.)

I've got a feeling most of the top contenders are the types to see being reviled by WR as a 'badge of honor' or something. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/yecch.gif)

This post has been edited by JayT:

[TungstenCarbide]

For sheer quantity of hatred and backstabby stuff, Cirt deserves the big win.

(Do you realize that not one of the past DICK winners has changed their behavior
in the slightest as a result of winning? It would be nice to think that people like SV,
Jayjg and JzG were eventually sanctioned partly as a result of winning, but you'd have
some real difficulty proving it. Being called a DICK, repeatedly, hasn't affected
Gerard in the slightest.)

you can't polish a turd.

[Doc glasgow]

For sheer quantity of hatred and backstabby stuff, Cirt deserves the big win.

(Do you realize that not one of the past DICK winners has changed their behavior
in the slightest as a result of winning? It would be nice to think that people like SV,
Jayjg and JzG were eventually sanctioned partly as a result of winning, but you'd have
some real difficulty proving it. Being called a DICK, repeatedly, hasn't affected
Gerard in the slightest.)

you can't polish a turd.

Or put Lipstick on Davy Gerrard?

[Milton Roe]

Or put Lipstick on Davy Gerrard?

You can do the last, but it comes out looking like Goth Zombie lipstick.

[lilburne]

Or put Lipstick on Davy Gerrard?

You can do the last, but it comes out looking like Goth Zombie lipstick.

Yeah but lets hear it for the porn protection cabal



Take it away Gmaxwell and make it real.

[Herschelkrustofsky]

At the close of the second day, Cirt still leads the pack with 25 points, followed by Georgewilliamherbert and Sandstein with 15 each. In the tag-team event, the Porn Protectors still maintain a 4 vote lead over the Climate Changers. Ottava still enjoys a comfortable lead over IronDuke for Miss Incongeniality, while Baseball Bugs has edged ahead of Abd for Vexatious Litigant, with FT2 now tied for second place. Scott MacDonald née Doc glasgow appears to control the Straight Shooter match, but for Cojones de latón, MZMcBride is now neck and neck with Cla68 in a real cliff-hanger.

[HRIP7]

For sheer quantity of hatred and backstabby stuff, Cirt deserves the big win.

(Do you realize that not one of the past DICK winners has changed their behavior
in the slightest as a result of winning? It would be nice to think that people like SV,
Jayjg and JzG were eventually sanctioned partly as a result of winning, but you'd have
some real difficulty proving it. Being called a DICK, repeatedly, hasn't affected
Gerard in the slightest.)

you can't polish a turd.

On the other hand, note that David Gerard has actually backed Scott up. Time for a 5-minute moratorium on Gerard-bashing?

[Herschelkrustofsky]

On the other hand, note that David Gerard has actually backed Scott up. Time for a 5-minute moratorium on Gerard-bashing?

Interesting. Yes, I think the 5 minutes is fully justified.

[It's the blimp, Frank]

Bad sportsmanship?

[Herschelkrustofsky]

Cirt has now emerged as the dominant contestant for WP:DICK with 32 points, trailed by Georgewilliamherbert with 20. The Porn Protectors are maintaining a 5 vote lead over the Climate Changers in the Tag Team event, but here's a message for Malleus Fatuorum and Parrot of Doom -- it ain't over until the Slim Virgin sings. A little extra effort on your part, with some fancy teamwork and really egregious POV pushing, might still take you over the top. Meanwhile, Ottava is still the man to beat in the Miss Incongeniality category, with IronDuke and Tarc tied for second place. The Vexatious Litigant event is now adrenaline city with Abd, Baseball Bugs and FT2 neck-and-neck at 10 votes each. Scott MacDonald née Doc glasgow has left the rest in the dust for the Straight Shooter honors, while MZMcBride has actually pulled ahead of Cla68 in the Cojones de latón race. The fans are on their feet!

[Gruntled]

Cirt has now emerged as the dominant contestant for WP:DICK

That's scarcely surprising, given all the publicity there's been for his anti-Scientology antics. (Not that I'm exactly pro-Scientology myself, I stress.)

Meanwhile, Ottava is still the man to beat in the Miss Incongeniality category

Let's give Ottava all praise when he deserves it. He's run a staggeringly good and determined campaign for the honour. Look at this thread for example. How could even IronDuke compete?

This post has been edited by Gruntled:

[MZMcBride]

I'm surprised the climate cabal is losing out to the porn cabal. Sex sells, I guess.

I voted for Scott for straight shooter (seems like a lock) and Giano for cojones de latón (mostly as he does a much better job than almost anyone at paying attention and pointing out problems).

My two-point dick vote went to Rlevse; my one-point dick vote went to Cirt (looks like I'll be winning there).

Miss Incongeniality going to Ottava isn't really a surprise given the primary voter base here, but I voted for TenPoundHammer. Looks unlikely that he'll be able to pull ahead at this point, but he'll always be the biggest, craziest diva to me. I mean ... the otters? Come on!

[EricBarbour]

On the other hand, note that David Gerard has actually backed Scott up. Time for a 5-minute moratorium on Gerard-bashing?

Interesting. Yes, I think the 5 minutes is fully justified.

You must be joking. Gerard has always been hostile towards Scientology, and I suspect his hostility is a major reason why McWhiney and Cirt spend so much time attacking past and current CoS members on WP.

He empowers the powerless (and the pointless).

[Sarcasticidealist]

Is campaigning still allowed? Because I knew I recognized Silver Seren from somewhere. If those are cojones de laiton, we ought perhaps to prefer a different alloy.

[Herschelkrustofsky]

Is campaigning still allowed?

Sure, why not. But given the way that particular event is shaping up, I don't think your link is going to significantly impact SS's chances.

[Herschelkrustofsky]

Bad sportsmanship?

Apparently, the Tag-Team Event is one of the most coveted awards. I just found this:

mikeu: on another topic, i have a won a 2009 Wikipedia Review WP:DICK of Distinction Award
Sybil: I am not saying he is right or wrong.
Sybil: I just want to understand it.
mikeu: for the Tag-Team Event
mikeu: http://wikipediareview.com/index.php?showtopic=22736

[carbuncle]

Is campaigning still allowed? Because I knew I recognized Silver Seren from somewhere. If those are cojones de laiton, we ought perhaps to prefer a different alloy.

Perhaps cojones de ratón?

[Ottava]

Miss Incongeniality going to Ottava isn't really a surprise given the primary voter base here, but I voted for TenPoundHammer. Looks unlikely that he'll be able to pull ahead at this point, but he'll always be the biggest, craziest diva to me. I mean ... the otters? Come on!

I find it interesting that I get votes along with those I've disputed with - Abd, FT2, Porn Cabal, etc. Fun.

[SB_Johnny]

Miss Incongeniality going to Ottava isn't really a surprise given the primary voter base here, but I voted for TenPoundHammer. Looks unlikely that he'll be able to pull ahead at this point, but he'll always be the biggest, craziest diva to me. I mean ... the otters? Come on!

I find it interesting that I get votes along with those I've disputed with - Abd, FT2, Porn Cabal, etc. Fun.

Why is that interesting? The list of people you haven't been a dispute with is, after all, vanishingly small. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/tongue.gif)

[A Horse With No Name]

...while MZMcBride has actually pulled ahead of Cla68 in the Cojones de latón race.

Wow, MZMcBride really has elastic balls! (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/rolleyes.gif)

[the fieryangel]

Porn protection cabal is streaking into the lead, I see.

I hope they're having full frontal shots taken of their streaking. That would be vital encyclopedic material. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/mellow.gif)

yes, especially if they're, like, non-white....

[KStreetSlave]

...while MZMcBride has actually pulled ahead of Cla68 in the Cojones de latón race.

Wow, MZMcBride really has elastic balls! (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/rolleyes.gif)

I haven't been following, what was Cla68's reason for being in that section?

[Milton Roe]

Is campaigning still allowed? Because I knew I recognized Silver Seren from somewhere. If those are cojones de laiton, we ought perhaps to prefer a different alloy.

Perhaps cojones de ratón?

Cojones de estaño. (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/wink.gif) That one's for the little tin gods who lord it over their anonymous WP domain. Then cower at the thought that anybody in the real world might find them and punch their lights out for their online behavior. You know-- stuff they'd never be dumb enough to do in an office, or say in a bar.

[Herschelkrustofsky]

...while MZMocBride has actually pulled ahead of Cla68 in the Cojones de latón race.

Wow, MZMcBride really has elastic balls! (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/rolleyes.gif)

I haven't been following, what was Cla68's reason for being in that section?

Cla68 has been a stalwart foe of WikiKorruption for some time now, and has won the Cojones de latón honors for the past two years running. MZMcBride may have been a bit of a dark horse -- I haven't followed his exploits on-Wiki, but he clearly has many members of the Academy in his camp. Meanwhile, Georgewilliamherbert is putting on the steam, leaving Sandstein behind in the runner-up DICK contest. Could he still give Cirt a run for their money? And don't rule out the Climate Changers for tag-team -- they still pose a credible challenge to the Porn Protectors.

Meanwhile, the Vexatious Litigant event has got everyone on the edge of his seat. At the moment, FT2 has acquired a 1 vote lead over Abd and Baseball Bugs, but this race has been full of surprises, and no contestant can claim a decisive advantage at this juncture.

[Lar]

Apparently I'm less congenial than ScienceApologist? Well that's certainly food for thought.

[Herschelkrustofsky]

Apparently I'm less congenial than ScienceApologist? Well that's certainly food for thought.

It's important to remember that awards pageants of this sort are never purely technical assessments of the contestants. There is always a generous serving of Tinseltown politics involved as well. Have you thought about getting a better publicist?

On the bright side, your grudge match with Ottava is going well (or poorly, depending on how ironic you want to be.)

[Herschelkrustofsky]

It looks like Cla68 is narrowing the gap with MZMcBride. If Cla68 crosses the finish line first, that will be an unheard-of 3 year streak, which not even David Gerard has attempted. The Vexatious Litigant race continues to be a roller-coaster ride, with our own Abd currently in the lead by a slender 1-vote margin.