FORUM WARNING [2] Division by zero (Line: 2933 of /srcsgcaop/boardclass.php)
SOPA and a strike -
     
 
The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> SOPA and a strike, Jimbo requests comments
HRIP7
post
Post #1


Senior Member
****

Group: Regulars
Posts: 483
Joined:
Member No.: 17,020



Jimbo has asked for comments on whether Wikipedia should reserve the right to go on strike to prevent the Stop Online Piracy Act from passing.

Views?
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
SB_Johnny
post
Post #2


It wasn't me who made honky-tonk angels
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,128
Joined:
Member No.: 8,272



And now "wikiality" comes full circle. Best comment:

QUOTE
Keep If it is not notable then why bother doing it - surely the whole point of it is to make an impact. Vrenator talk 09:48, 17 January 2012 (UTC)
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Doc glasgow
post
Post #3


Wikipedia:The Sump of All Human Knowledge
******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,138
Joined:
From: at home
Member No.: 90



QUOTE(SB_Johnny @ Tue 17th January 2012, 10:40am) *

And now "wikiality" comes full circle. Best comment:

QUOTE
Keep If it is not notable then why bother doing it - surely the whole point of it is to make an impact. Vrenator talk 09:48, 17 January 2012 (UTC)




Oh, that's hilarious - newsworthy in itself.

Maybe I should write an article about the media storm that will occur when they discuss the irony of that article - then someone can AFD that, and the circle will be complete


My protest statement:

QUOTE
Protesting the death of an encyclopedia.

The blackout of the English Wikipedia destroys for ever the concept of its political and geographical neutrality. It means rather than an open group of international contributors, uniting solely round their commitment to writing an encyclopedia, with nothing else implied, Wikipedia is now associated with a particular political position in a particular nation. While many, or most, Wikipedians may happen to hold this political position in common, it ought to have been irrelevant to editing here. Now it is not, a precedent has been set, and something important has died.

Some will say, "but SOPA is so important, and it affects us, so we must do something". But here is my problem. Do I agree with opposing SOPA? Or, do I have a different opinion that makes me wish to disassociate myself from the action that is being taken in the name of the community? Either way, my opinion on a political issue is now pertinent to my association with this community. You asked me a question that ought to have been irrelevant to editing here. That is new. That is wrong. Wikipedians came here united around five pillars - and five pillars only. I was not asked, and do not wish, to negotiate a sixth. Yes I know that, even were I to vocally support SOPA, I would still be welcome here. But that I am even asked the question changes everything. For the first time, Jimbo Wales has asked, and the community has agreed, that we no longer leave our own ideologies at the door.

In protest at this action, and mourning the day that the five pillars ceased to be the sole ideology of Wikipedia, I will not be contributing.

See also, "Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point". Yes, even a point you think is righteous.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
thekohser
post
Post #4


Member
*********

Group: Regulars
Posts: 10,274
Joined:
Member No.: 911



QUOTE(Doc glasgow @ Tue 17th January 2012, 6:11am) *

My protest statement:

QUOTE
Protesting the death of an encyclopedia.

The blackout of the English Wikipedia destroys for ever (sic) the concept of its political and geographical neutrality. It means rather than an open group of international contributors... (blah, blah)...

In protest at this action, and mourning the day that the five pillars ceased to be the sole ideology of Wikipedia, I will not be contributing.



So far, I'm counting nine (9) contributions since your announcement that you would not be contributing.

QUOTE(Wikicrusher2 @ Thu 19th January 2012, 11:46pm) *

I did sign the petition, as I agree that large corporations and certain congresspeople are trying to sabotage our rights online with nasty laws like PIPA and SOPA.


Your right to download free Hollywood movies from Kazakhstani web servers must not be abridged!
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Wikicrusher2
post
Post #5


Member
***

Group: Contributors
Posts: 102
Joined:
From: "The name of our country is América." -Bolivar
Member No.: 14,796



QUOTE(thekohser @ Fri 20th January 2012, 6:26am) *

QUOTE(Wikicrusher2 @ Thu 19th January 2012, 11:46pm) *

I did sign the petition, as I agree that large corporations and certain congresspeople are trying to sabotage our rights online with nasty laws like PIPA and SOPA.


Your right to download free Hollywood movies from Kazakhstani web servers must not be abridged!

Hey, nothing wrong with that (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/smile.gif) Copying is not theft.

It seems that the United States Government simply will not tolerate free Hollywood movies on servers in its country, so that rules out (at least legally) using US servers. Thankfully, if what you're saying is true about Kazakh servers, the Kazakh government isn't as mean (at least in that regard) as the US.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
SB_Johnny
post
Post #6


It wasn't me who made honky-tonk angels
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,128
Joined:
Member No.: 8,272



QUOTE(Wikicrusher2 @ Fri 20th January 2012, 6:43pm) *

QUOTE(thekohser @ Fri 20th January 2012, 6:26am) *

QUOTE(Wikicrusher2 @ Thu 19th January 2012, 11:46pm) *

I did sign the petition, as I agree that large corporations and certain congresspeople are trying to sabotage our rights online with nasty laws like PIPA and SOPA.


Your right to download free Hollywood movies from Kazakhstani web servers must not be abridged!

Hey, nothing wrong with that (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/smile.gif) Copying is not theft.

It seems that the United States Government simply will not tolerate free Hollywood movies on servers in its country, so that rules out (at least legally) using US servers. Thankfully, if what you're saying is true about Kazakh servers, the Kazakh government isn't as mean (at least in that regard) as the US.

The reason something like SOPA is needed is because of little shits like you.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Abd
post
Post #7


Postmaster
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,919
Joined:
From: Northampton, MA, USA
Member No.: 9,019



QUOTE(SB_Johnny @ Fri 20th January 2012, 7:01pm) *
QUOTE(Wikicrusher2 @ Fri 20th January 2012, 6:43pm) *
Hey, nothing wrong with that (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/smile.gif) Copying is not theft.
The reason something like SOPA is needed is because of little shits like you.
Leave it to SBJ to make it personal. He's more like Ottava than he'd like to admit.

Copyright violation is not "theft." That's a trope promoted by involved interests and people who want to amplify their arguments with some hyperbole.

Copyright violation is copyright violation, a creature of law. Theft is a common-law violation. Copyright violation is, under common law, at worst, a tort.

This post has been edited by Abd:
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
lilburne
post
Post #8


Chameleon
*****

Group: Contributors
Posts: 890
Joined:
Member No.: 21,803



QUOTE(Abd @ Sat 21st January 2012, 12:46am) *


Copyright violation is copyright violation, a creature of law. Theft is a common-law violation.


So how then can you be convicted of theft of government information even if all you did was copy the information. The government still having the information?
http://lawschool.courtroomview.com/acf_cas...states-v-girard
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
HRIP7   SOPA and a strike  
Herschelkrustofsky   What do you suppose Jimbo's angle is here; tha...  
Kelly Martin   What do you suppose Jimbo's angle is here; th...  
lilburne   Wikipedia has long relied on the safe harbor prov...  
SB_Johnny   How so? My understanding is that it is targeted a...  
lilburne   How so? My understanding is that it is targeted ...  
SB_Johnny   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='290590' date='Sat 1...  
lilburne   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='290590' date='Sat ...  
powercorrupts   He's showing his contempt for government again...  
TungstenCarbide   He's showing his contempt for government agai...  
powercorrupts   He's showing his contempt for government aga...  
TungstenCarbide   [quote name='TungstenCarbide' post='290591' date='...  
thekohser   He's showing his contempt for government agai...  
EricBarbour   I didn't see Jimbo show much contempt for gov...  
Zoloft   I didn't see Jimbo show much contempt for go...  
powercorrupts   He's showing his contempt for government aga...  
Fusion   I'd be strongly in favor of a strike. It woul...  
radek   They shouldn't be wimpy about it though. Eit...  
Malik Shabazz   They shouldn't be wimpy about it though. Eit...  
Ottava   Anyone else think that if Jimbo really cared about...  
Eppur si muove   Anyone else think that if Jimbo really cared abou...  
Michaeldsuarez   Has humanity forgotten how to write to their repre...  
mydog   (Temporarily) See the RFC on his talk page. I th...  
radek   (Temporarily) See the RFC on his talk page. I t...  
The Joy   (Temporarily) See the RFC on his talk page. I t...  
TungstenCarbide   Jimbo really believes that a Wikipedia strike can ...  
radek   Jimbo really believes that a Wikipedia strike can...  
Cla68   I've always thought that the most likely event...  
SB_Johnny   I've always thought that the most likely even...  
SB_Johnny   Jimbo really believes that a Wikipedia strike can...  
SB_Johnny   IOW:  
Michaeldsuarez   If there is a strike, Jimbo is sure to be intervi...  
Ottava   I can tell you this - a change.org petition wont i...  
SB_Johnny   And if the WMF does get a lobbyist, seeing their ...  
TungstenCarbide   And if the WMF does get a lobbyist, seeing their t...  
Ottava   that's not implied - he flat out states that...  
SB_Johnny   [quote name='TungstenCarbide' post='290632' date=...  
Cla68   [quote name='Ottava' post='290633' date='Sun 11th...  
thekohser   I [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title...  
TungstenCarbide   I [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?titl...  
Tarc   [quote name='thekohser' post='290642' date='Mon 1...  
Cla68   [quote name='TungstenCarbide' post='290648' date=...  
cookiehead   Jimbo views wikipedia editors as subordinates. He...  
thekohser   Here's one example of that. Jimbo edits Manuk...  
cookiehead   Here's one example of that. Jimbo edits Manu...  
Detective   No Wikipedia article about Dow Lohnes. Must be a...  
thekohser   Dow Lohnes is not registered with the U.S. Senate...  
mnemonic   [quote name='Cla68' post='290638' date='Sun 11th ...  
thekohser   WMF's hiring of Dow Lohnes is public now, as ...  
Peter Damian   Poor Marek's comments (he is our 'Radek...  
radek   Eh, if anything, him hatting these comments prob...  
SB_Johnny   He's probably using the term "lobbyist...  
Eppur si muove   I know that a bit of bellowing and chest-thumping ...  
Emperor   Taking Wikipedia down even for an hour would prove...  
Peter Damian   Taking Wikipedia down even for an hour would prov...  
carbuncle   No comment...  
thekohser   No comment... Deliciously classic.  
Peter Damian   No comment... Deliciously classic. Quite, ...  
SB_Johnny   [quote name='thekohser' post='290652' date='Mon 1...  
mbz1   Jimbo's acting as CEO of Wikipedia :D  
Ottava   Here is the lobbyist database. Jim Burger does not...  
carbuncle   That means that the WMF is dead in the water in t...  
SB_Johnny   I doubt Jimbo will have any trouble getting this ...  
radek   I doubt Jimbo will have any trouble getting this...  
radek   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='290709' date='Tue 1...  
cookiehead   Jimmy is assuming bad faith with his "hostile...  
Ottava   One of the first rules of lobbying is that you don...  
Emperor   Professional lobbyists are a waste of money. They...  
nableezy   Professional lobbyists are a waste of money. The...  
The Joy   Professional lobbyists are a waste of money. The...  
Ottava   Professional lobbyists are a waste of money. The...  
cookiehead   This brings up a point I think often overlooked by...  
iii   This brings up a point I think often overlooked b...  
Peter Damian   Meanwhile the news leaks out onto the internet. h...  
SB_Johnny   Interesting: (del/undel) 10:52, 10 D...  
Michaeldsuarez   Interesting: (del/undel) 10:52, 10 ...  
lilburne   Now there is fuckwittery of the Godwin kind. Se...  
EricBarbour   New Register article.  
thekohser   And, as usual, Seth Finkelstein is brilliant in ho...  
Michaeldsuarez   New Register article. I wonder whether Jimbo wi...  
mbz1   Jimmy is still unhapy about Cla What track recor...  
Cla68   [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Us...  
cookiehead   Cla68 does not profit off of Wikipedia, yet contri...  
thekohser   Cla68 does not profit off of Wikipedia, yet contr...  
EricBarbour   They haven't banned you yet? Just *who* are ...  
cookiehead   They haven't banned you yet? Just *who* are...  
SB_Johnny   They haven't banned you yet? Just *who* are...  
radek   [quote name='cookiehead' post='290759' date='Tue ...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...oldid...  
SB_Johnny   http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...oldi...  
radek   [quote name='Michaeldsuarez' post='290781' date='...  
EricBarbour   Funny thing is, III is correct. Plus: Jimbo posted...  
TungstenCarbide   Funny thing is, III is correct. Plus: Jimbo poste...  
lilburne   Godwin's replacement speaks: http://blog.wiki...  
TungstenCarbide   Godwin's replacement speaks: Wowah! The W...  
EricBarbour   Bullshit. Commons contains thousands of images sn...  
Ottava   Bullshit. Commons contains thousands of images s...  
Cla68   Bullshit. Commons contains thousands of images s...  
lilburne   Whenever someone from corporate management, any ...  
TungstenCarbide   If Geoff really was so smart, he wouldn't work...  
Kelly Martin   Geoff's blog post makes Godwin look like a chi...  
EricBarbour   Made Slashdot today. Plus the "visual editor...  
lilburne   SOPA seems to be targeted at link farms to torrent...  
thekohser   Geoff says: Hey, dipwad... what do you think the...  
thekohser   I think we should tell Congress to stop online pir...  
Peter Damian   I think we should tell Congress to [url=http://vi...  
lilburne   I think we should tell Congress to [url=http://v...  
SB_Johnny   Restored: Dow Lohnes.  
thekohser   Restored: [wp]Dow Lohnes. You restored a [url=ht...  
Michaeldsuarez   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='290885' date='Wed 1...  
thekohser   [quote name='thekohser' post='290907' date='Wed 1...  
SB_Johnny   Restored: [wp]Dow Lohnes. You restored a [url=h...  
carbuncle   No comment (other than to note that Wehwalt is a l...  
lilburne   No comment (other than to note that Wehwalt is a ...  
EricBarbour   Just in: a group letter, signed by the high nabobs...  
thekohser   Just in: a group letter, signed by the high nabob...  
lilburne   Just in: a group letter, signed by the high nabob...  
SB_Johnny   Anyone know why this doesn't seem to show up?  
Michaeldsuarez   Anyone know why [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/w/in...  
lilburne   And better yet:  
thekohser   And better yet: Exactly, Lilburne. Which i...  
GlassBeadGame   Exactly, Lilburne. Which is why it is generall...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Vil..._earl...  
lilburne   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Vil..._ear...  
EricBarbour   Are they seriously suggesting that they are going...  
carbuncle   So users of WP with US IP addresses will see a ban...  
EricBarbour   So users of WP with US IP addresses will see a ba...  
RMHED   So users of WP with US IP addresses will see a b...  
Fusion   So users of WP with US IP addresses will see a ba...  
EricBarbour   In case you hadn't heard....... Jimbo posted ...  
thekohser   In case you hadn't heard....... Jimbo posted...  
Fusion   Anyone who knew his REAL history would conclude h...  
EricBarbour   [quote name='EricBarbour' post='291507' date='Sat...  
Michaeldsuarez   In case you hadn't heard....... Jimbo posted...  
SB_Johnny   http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...on_r....  
lilburne   Ongoing whining from the thieves on the foundation...  
mbz1   [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wik...  
Kelly Martin   BTW, is a charitable organization that exists on d...  
anthony   BTW, is a charitable organization that exists on ...  
Kelly Martin   If they shut down completely, this is true. But t...  
anthony   If they shut down completely, this is true. But ...  
thekohser   Apparently, they still allow a select few intellig...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:SOP...itiat...  
Michaeldsuarez   [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:SOPA_...  
Emperor   Stuff like this is a welcome warning. Now do you ...  
Fusion   Stuff like this is a welcome warning. Now do you...  
Emperor   Stuff like this is a welcome warning. Now do yo...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_tal...ence_...  
EricBarbour   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_tal...ence...  
Michaeldsuarez   [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...oldid...  
lilburne   No one from Kansas I note, but at least one from...  
EricBarbour   Prodego is a typical deletionist evil patroller. H...  
Eppur si muove   Acoording to this, the number of "very active...  
EricBarbour   Acoording to [url=http://stats.wikimedia.org/EN/T...  
SB_Johnny   Acoording to this, the number of "very activ...  
Eppur si muove   [quote name='Eppur si muove' post='293956' date='...  
thekohser   If Wikipedia decides to black itself out, I have a...  
SB_Johnny   Maybe not a newsflash, but it looks like Jimmy may...  
GlassBeadGame   Maybe not a newsflash, but it looks like Jimmy ma...  
Michaeldsuarez   Maybe not a newsflash, but it looks like Jimmy ma...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://www.dailydot.com/news/sopa-postponed/ The ...  
SB_Johnny   http://www.dailydot.com/news/sopa-postponed/ The...  
EricBarbour   NY Times Slate  
melloden   NY Times Slate By publicly attacking legislation...  
EricBarbour   By publicly attacking legislation, how can Wikipe...  
radek   [quote name='EricBarbour' post='294036' date='Mon...  
Emperor   Prediction: this will backfire big time. WMF can...  
Anonymous editor   doesn't make a big difference to me, but I don...  
Emperor   The whole idea of Wikipedia was to pirate content ...  
dogbiscuit   The whole idea of Wikipedia was to pirate content...  
radek   Since it will probably be removed. (hopefully not ...  
Doc glasgow   I have posted my own protest statement.  
carbuncle   I have posted my own protest statement. I chortl...  
Peter Damian   News of the blackout was on the front page of the ...  
EricBarbour   Good for you, Scott. You should have done this yea...  
Doc glasgow   You can count! None of them really "co...  
thekohser   You can count! None of them really "c...  
Doc glasgow   Let me know when you're ready to do some pai...  
Wikicrusher2   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='294270' date='Fri 2...  
SB_Johnny   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='294270' date='Fri ...  
HRIP7   So what about the arrest of Kim Schmitz and the sh...  
Vigilant   [quote name='Wikicrusher2' post='294276' date='Fr...  
thekohser   Modifications to the copyright laws on behalf of ...  
SB_Johnny   You didn't piss me off, it's just that y...  
lilburne   I didn't say I'm particularly endeared to...  
anthony   Copyright as originally envisioned was a way to p...  
anthony   Creative material's classification as "p...  
Eppur si muove   So the strongest action gets supported even though...  
Doc glasgow   There's another issue. In their rush to do th...  
Eppur si muove   I wonder how many radio phone-ins there are going ...  
Shalom   This story should be called a SOPA opera.  
Wikicrusher2   Even a stopped clock is right twice a day. Wikip...  
EricBarbour   However, the blackout was not a unilateral decisi...  
thekohser   Right or not, the WMF is a nonprofit, and in both...  
Wikifan   pretty worthless block. Just refresh the page and ...  
Michaeldsuarez   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Art...rt_SO...  
SB_Johnny   And so the transformation from encyclopedia to pol...  
anthony   And so the transformation from encyclopedia to po...  
Emperor   [quote name='SB_Johnny' post='294318' date='Sat 2...  
Michaeldsuarez   Copyright as originally envisioned was a way to p...  
anthony   http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-cop...  
lilburne   [quote name='Michaeldsuarez' post='294320' date='...  
SB_Johnny   IOW all property is an artificial concession of s...  
Doc glasgow   Indeed, although by one logic one has more claim o...  
anthony   Indeed, although by one logic one has more claim ...  
lilburne   +5 that  
EricBarbour   So much of Wikipedia is comedy...... Seen the ...  
radek   So much of Wikipedia is comedy...... Seen the ...  
Emperor   Quote of the day.  
Kelly Martin   A G+ acquaintance informed me a couple days ago th...  
NuclearWarfare   A G+ acquaintance informed me a couple days ago t...  
Kelly Martin   [quote name='Kelly Martin' post='294491' date='Mon...  
Michaeldsuarez   [quote name='NuclearWarfare' post='294802' date='...  
Rhindle   IIRC, Jimbo had a real hardon for this guy, Mr For...  
Michaeldsuarez   IIRC, Jimbo had a real hardon for this guy, Mr Fo...  
Abd   [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbit...  
Kelly Martin   IIRC, Jimbo had a real hardon for this guy, Mr Fo...  
Peter Damian   Jimmy gave him an enormous hug when they met last ...  
GlassBeadGame   Jimmy gave him an enormous hug when they met last...  
EricBarbour   [quote name='Peter Damian' post='294869' date='Tu...  
HRIP7   Jimbo reports that he's Also note the threa...  
thekohser   "While I believe that they have been arrogant...  
radek   "While I believe that they have been arrogan...  


Reply to this topicStart new topic
6 User(s) are reading this topic (6 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now:
 
     
FORUM WARNING [2] Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home2/wikipede/public_html/int042kj398.php:242) (Line: 0 of Unknown)