FORUM WARNING [2] Division by zero (Line: 2933 of /srcsgcaop/boardclass.php)
I Declare World Wiki War on Admin Anonymity -
     
 
The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> Help

This forum is for discussing specific Wikipedia editors, editing patterns, and general efforts by those editors to influence or direct content in ways that might not be in keeping with Wikipedia policy. Please source your claims and provide links where appropriate. For a glossary of terms frequently used when discussing Wikipedia and related projects, please refer to Wikipedia:Glossary.

> I Declare World Wiki War on Admin Anonymity, Enjoy my first Wikipedia User Identity List
Rating  1
FLIPSIDE
post
Post #1


Junior Member
**

Group: Contributors
Posts: 67
Joined:
From: Boston
Member No.: 4,761



I have been to many Wikipedia review sites now, and am less than enthused with the endless ball-lessness and lukewarm debate over the ethics over ending Wikipedia Administrative Anonymity. Out of respect for the rules of Wikipedia Review, I am not posting the names here, but I will give you the link to my first dedicated Information Bomb against Wikipedia. It is now my official mission to ruin Anonymity on Wikipedia. If anyone has anything useful to contribute, consider yourselves invited to contact me. I am currently only impressed by the work of Daniel Brandt and Judd Bagley, and observe that the various forums "critical" of Wikipedia are excessively staffed by Wikipedia Admins, as evidenced by their blistering wails (Wales?) whenever solid information comes out.

To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPEDIA USER DATABASE at Haters Magazine

http://www.contextflexed.com/storywikipediaexposed.html
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
Proabivouac
post
Post #2


Bane of all wikiland
*******

Group: Contributors
Posts: 2,246
Joined:
Member No.: 2,647



QUOTE(FLIPSIDE @ Tue 1st April 2008, 4:03pm) *

To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPEDIA USER DATABASE at Haters Magazine

Why on earth are you "outing" ALM scientist? He's not an administrator, isn't part of any cabal, and has done you no wrong.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
bluevictim
post
Post #3


Anonymous Pro-fake-or of Theology
**

Group: You Don't Want to Know
Posts: 71
Joined:
From: USA
Member No.: 5,264



QUOTE(Proabivouac @ Tue 1st April 2008, 9:34pm) *

QUOTE(FLIPSIDE @ Tue 1st April 2008, 4:03pm) *

To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPEDIA USER DATABASE at Haters Magazine

Why on earth are you "outing" ALM scientist? He's not an administrator, isn't part of any cabal, and has done you no wrong.

And he's also outing Alison for no reason.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Somey
post
Post #4


Can't actually moderate (or even post)
*********

Group: Moderators
Posts: 11,816
Joined:
From: Dreamland
Member No.: 275



QUOTE(bluevictim @ Tue 1st April 2008, 11:42pm) *
And he's also outing Alison for no reason.

Ooh, maybe he's a misogynist too? He seems to be into rap music, which has traditionally been notorious for that sort of thing.

Mind you, he does make some fairly good points:
QUOTE
Since the most abusive admins are closest to the top of the Wikipedia hierarchy and since they nominate and approve the other admins as well as hide amongst them claiming "legitimate use of sockpuppets", I will out them all at my convenience until the anonymity function of Wikipedia Administration becomes useless, and the editors have to resort to honesty and straightforwardness. I further hold that my reaction is the natural and justifiable reaction that any reasonable person with surplus time, resources, skill, and pride would make after being kicked off an allegedly free 501 c) Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game by a team of medallion-wearing hentai and anal fisting experts for the crime of having a known identity and a sense of self-esteem and personal authority without having been duly appointed to Admin status or given any "Barnstars" for being obseqious and minuscule.

Nota Bene: Wikipedia had its chance. Wikipedia formally decided in March 2007 that Real Life Editorial and Administrative accountability was *not* going to be permitted. Regarding persons other than themselves, they believe they have a right to nose about in everyone else's business, accusing them of "internet crimes" such as Conflict of Interest, Spam, and Stalking when their identities are revealed. This includes half of the persons allegedly "criticizing" and "reforming" Wikipedia. The truth is that a central cabal of Wikipedia admins, including Risker, AudeVivere, David Gerard, Josh Gordon, Michael Noda, and Jayjg, have such enormously fat heads that they regularly discuss expanding the prosecutorial and probationary police powers of Wikipedia into real communities to have Wikipedians who disagree with Admins ---arrested! That desired capacity alone merits a full-scale attack on Wikipedian Anonymity. That Wikipedia is considered an information authority and uses coding hooks and crooks to place first in Google is another reason. Or perhaps you prefer to be ruled unworthy of existence by the self-proclaimed search engine police.

It's a little blustery, of course, but it's hard to argue with the facts. (Even if he did leave out the "u" in "obsequious"... (IMG:smilys0b23ax56/default/getlost.gif) )

Presumably the bit about "formally decided in March 2007 that Real Life Editorial and Administrative accountability was *not* going to be permitted" is a reference to the post-Essjay "credentials verification" debate. Remember how they got a lot of press for their "credentials verification initiative" as if it were really going to happen, and when it didn't and in fact the opposite happened, the press basically ignored the fact that they'd essentially lied their asses off over the whole thing? They really got away with one there.

However, he seems to be saying that someone - User:Irishguy? - deleted his user account, when in fact it was his user page that was deleted, along with the talk page, by User:MZMcBride, who seems to make a habit of that sort of thing. However, the account had fewer than 50 edits, so maybe they've got some sort of policy about that (they always do)...

Apparently User:Contextflexed had accused Irishguy of "linkstalking" him, which isn't a term I'm familiiar with...? It looks like Irishguy was removing a link to this review from the article on Peter_Gelderloos, author of How Nonviolence Protects the State. To be honest, I don't see how the link Irishguy removed is significantly less "notable" than the ones that were left in, though there's no question that it's a terribly negative review, accusing Gelderloos of having written the "worst swindle since Rock n Roll."

Of course, some of us here may prefer to conclude that the real reason for all this is his criticism of Chip Berlet.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
FLIPSIDE   I Declare World Wiki War on Admin Anonymity  
Peter Damian   [url=http://www.contextflexed.com/storywikipediae...  
dogbiscuit   [url=http://www.contextflexed.com/storywikipedia...  
FLIPSIDE   [url=http://www.contextflexed.com/storywikipedia...  
tarantino   [quote name='FLIPSIDE' post='89705' date='Tue 1st...  
BobbyBombastic   Comment about this line: I'm not sure what ...  
Alex   I have been to many Wikipedia review sites now, a...  
FLIPSIDE   [quote name='FLIPSIDE' post='89705' date='Tue 1st...  
LessHorrid vanU   Sometimes - and this actually a serious point, wit...  
FLIPSIDE   Sometimes - and this actually a serious point, wi...  
wikiwhistle   Sometimes - and this actually a serious point, wi...  
Alison   I have been to many Wikipedia review sites now, a...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   I never "fake retired" as I'd remain...  
bluevictim   [quote name='Alison' post='89773' date='Tue 1st A...  
Alison   [quote name='Alison' post='89773' date='Tue 1st A...  
FLIPSIDE   Tsk. You didn't spell my name right. Sorr...  
wikiwhistle   You implied you were leaving wikipedia (I think yo...  
Alison   You implied you were leaving wikipedia (I think y...  
Lar   Thanks! :) The "back for the specific ta...  
michael   That was horrible. If you're going to out use...  
Somey   If you're going to out users, make it classy, ...  
FLIPSIDE   That was horrible. If you're going to out us...  
bluevictim   I believe things like this and hivemind should be ...  
Milton Roe   I believe things like this and hivemind should be...  
Lar   I believe things like this and hivemind should be...  
guy   Does it need to be in a peer reviewed (academic) ...  
Lar   Does it need to be in a peer reviewed (academic)...  
guy   There are those that have pointed out that the de...  
Proabivouac   It's a little blustery, of course, but it...  
Somey   It's a complete non sequitur to criticize a ru...  
Alison   To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPED...  
FLIPSIDE   Why on earth are you "outing" ALM scien...  
EricBarbour   :angry: :lol: Flipside's list is the fun...  
Proabivouac   Why on earth are you "outing" ALM scie...  
Viridae   Yay I see my name.  
Miltopia   If this is an attempt to inject false positives in...  
Milton Roe   To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPEDI...  
Giggy   Oh wow, he couldn't even get the right usernam...  
One   Good admixture of truth and garbage. No wonder you...  
bluevictim   I don't really think one should have to have a...  
FLIPSIDE   I don't think we should care that the Wikiped...  
Amarkov   Come on, dude. You've made it very clear th...  
FLIPSIDE   It doesn't really matter what you intended b...  
Alison   [quote name='Amarkov' post='90001' date='Wed 2nd ...  
Somey   Actually no, let's stay with the ethics issue ...  
FLIPSIDE   Now, it's very easy to get all these WP user...  
Random832   We got an e-mail from User:Risker a couple of day...  
Lar   It doesn't really matter what you intended ...  
Milton Roe   If we may move off the ethics issue back to the e...  
Rootology   It doesn't really matter what you intended by ...  
FLIPSIDE   "Why are Wikipedia editors special creature...  
Alison   [quote name='Alison' post='90009' date='Wed 2nd Ap...  
FLIPSIDE   All I'm doing is asking questions, just you...  
Rootology   [quote name='Rootology' post='90008' date='Wed 2n...  
FLIPSIDE   This is a simplification into the pointlessly fa...  
Proabivouac   It's a simple question: why and how did Wikip...  
Amarkov   It doesn't really matter what you intended by...  
bluevictim   The website that Flipside gives for Andrew Morrow ...  
Alison   The website that Flipside gives for Andrew Morrow...  
FLIPSIDE   [quote name='bluevictim' post='90062' date='Wed 2...  
carbuncle   Well, I'm about as unimportant as an editor ca...  
EricBarbour   But yeah - here's the site in all its masturb...  
Count DeMonet   But yeah - here's the site in all its mastur...  
michael   And if you had any decency you'd obscure the e...  
Viridae   YOu want credentials? Here is my very broad degree...  
bluevictim   I was looking at the current version of it and I t...  
Somey   What I [i]didn't get to see was the thing abou...  
dogbiscuit   Thanks for sharing - NOT! Just off to scrub t...  
guy   Welcome carbuncle. As far as we're concerned,...  
Viridae   [quote name='bluevictim' post='90062' date='Wed ...  
wikiwhistle   Amorrow was assed out of wikipedia years ago actu...  
Alison   [quote name='Viridae' post='90277' date='Fri 4th ...  
FLIPSIDE   Gonna change your site, get a scoop on the other...  
east.718   Nah. I'm busy researching Dreadstar, Naerii, ...  
FLIPSIDE   [quote name='FLIPSIDE' post='90446' date='Fri 4th...  
east.718   [quote name='east.718' post='90462' date='Fri 4th...  
wikiwhistle   I'm sure you've stalked my logs Do you ...  
guy   I'm sure you've stalked my logs Do you...  
wikiwhistle   [quote name='wikiwhistle' post='90473' date='Sat ...  
Castle Rock   [quote name='wikiwhistle' post='90473' date='Sat ...  
wikiwhistle   It depends. If you have his Contributions page b...  
east.718   [quote name='wikiwhistle' post='90473' date='Sat 5...  
Random832   ...speak Wikipedian. "stalked" does no...  
Milton Roe   Maybe I am being too raw about it. But I am gett...  
Random832   Just a discussion page revert on User:contextflex...  
FLIPSIDE   [quote name='FLIPSIDE' post='90465' date='Fri 4th...  
Castle Rock   [quote name='FLIPSIDE' post='90465' date='Fri 4t...  
wikiwhistle   [quote name='Viridae' post='90277' date='Fri 4th...  
Viridae   Amorrow was assed out of wikipedia years ago act...  
Lar   [quote name='wikiwhistle' post='90279' date='Fri ...  
wikiwhistle   He (Amorrow) is loopy by all accounts. And writes...  
Viridae   [quote name='wikiwhistle' post='90279' date='Fri...  
FLIPSIDE   Wikiped-ese or not, "stalked my logs" so...  
Alison   Wikiped-ese or not, "stalked my logs" s...  
FLIPSIDE   Wikiped-ese or not, "stalked my logs" ...  
wikiwhistle   Aah, a "friend of JzG" :D  
FLIPSIDE   Aah, a "friend of JzG" :D Well, if you...  
bluevictim   FLIPSIDE: So, you're such a great sleuth. Well...  
Somey   You're... William Shakespeare? Holy shit...  
Kato   You're... [i]William Shakespeare? Holy shit...  
bluevictim   I'd also like to say, this is not me. I don...  
Somey   I just now searched on Clusty and found that someo...  
Somey   Here's another thought that struck me recently...  
wikiwhistle   This is the point, though: Traditionally, if you...  
Moulton   If you go into a university library and scan the b...  
bluevictim   I had never heard the verb "out", the pa...  
Proabivouac   I had never heard the verb "out", the p...  
FLIPSIDE   As you say, Brandt's information was wrong; h...  
Moulton   I have been in online discussion forums where the ...  
KStreetSlave   I find it hilarious that his list has, in close su...  
Somey   I find it hilarious that his list has, in close su...  
wikiwhistle   Gaylord is a lovely name for a man- all the old-fa...  
Lar   Gaylord is a lovely name for a man- all the old-f...  
Proabivouac   Verified. I have him on Larry Pieniazek's F...  
jorge   We were talking about Dmcdevit, who is himself st...  
Proabivouac   [quote name='Proabivouac' post='90710' date='Sun ...  
dogbiscuit   [My question is, what's with misspelling his ...  
WikiWatch   A fair number of user names and email addresses on...  
FLIPSIDE   A fair number of user names and email addresses o...  
WikiWatch   On the other hand, a lot of Tiscali users are try...  
FLIPSIDE   On the other hand, a lot of Tiscali users are tr...  
NVS   I don't hate the people on my list. I love...  
Phoenix-wiki   Please identify yourself FLIPSIDE, tell us your na...  
guy   My question is, what's with misspelling his o...  
FLIPSIDE   Which friend of mine are you? Thought that infor...  
Proabivouac   Maybe you're the common man. I am certainly ...  
KStreetSlave   Which friend of mine are you? Thought that info...  
Milton Roe   The common man cares about your vendetta to out W...  
Yehudi   Gaylord is a lovely name for a man- all the old-f...  
jorge   Gaylord is a lovely name for a man- all the old-...  
Viridae   Gaylord is a lovely name for a man- all the old-...  
Lar   Depending on your privacy settings the names can ...  
thekohser   To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPEDI...  
FLIPSIDE   To whatever end, I now offer you the new WIKIPED...  


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now: