The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> Help

This subforum is for critical evaluation of Wikipedia articles. However, to reduce topic-bloat, please make note of exceptionally poor stubs, lists, and other less attention-worthy material in the Miscellaneous Grab Bag thread. Also, please be aware that agents of the Wikimedia Foundation might use your evaluations to improve the articles in question.

Useful Links: Featured Article CandidatesFeatured Article ReviewArticles for DeletionDeletion Review


Forum Topics Replies Last Post Info
New Posts Biographies of Living Persons
This subforum is used for discussion of actual biographical material on Wikipedia. Its contents are hidden from search engines.
303 5,783 Last Post Thu 26th September 2013, 7:32pm
In: Chelsea Manning
By: Retrospect

21 Pages V  1 2 3 > »  Start new topic
> Articles
    Topic Title Replies Topic Starter Views Last Action
No New Posts  
Luka Rocco Magnotta: Did he kill for Wikipedia?
His article was deleted twice as non-notable. Now he's killed a gu
10 Heat 6,608 15th 9 17, 7:22pm
Last post by: Anonymous editor
No New Posts  
0 victim of censorship 3,875 26th 12 16, 2:36am
Last post by: victim of censorship
No New Posts  
Sam Walsh CEO of Rio Tinto
Another company write up fan page
4 Brutus 8,280 3rd 12 15, 7:39pm
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
Egypt Bans Online Porn  * 123» 5
Should we send them a link to Commons?
81 Ottava 26,421 20th 9 14, 7:07pm
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
2 Brutus 5,147 25th 8 14, 1:32pm
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
5 Brutus 5,777 25th 8 14, 1:25pm
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
Calix Limited
Article written by their marketing manager.
2 Brutus 5,772 19th 4 14, 9:17pm
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
53 Peter Damian 28,872 23rd 9 13, 10:59am
Last post by: Text
No New Posts  
A quick sketch of a method that can be used to find drones.
A quick sketch of a method that can be used to find drones.
2 occono 2,779 13th 3 13, 12:37pm
Last post by: Jay
No New Posts  
23 Daniel Brandt 9,102 13th 3 13, 12:35pm
Last post by: Jay
No New Posts  
2 occono 1,799 5th 3 13, 2:53pm
Last post by: Tarc
No New Posts  
Aegis Limited (BPO)
Vanity management name listing
3 Brutus 5,146 14th 2 13, 8:55am
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
13 Brutus 2,871 3rd 2 13, 7:07pm
Last post by: Emperor
No New Posts  
92 EricBarbour 27,613 13th 1 13, 6:32am
Last post by: Tarc
No New Posts  
0 Ottava 1,450 12th 1 13, 2:19pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
FPSRussia
Stealing Topics the Wiki Way
0 Ottava 2,204 7th 1 13, 11:33pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
0 mikemikev 2,091 4th 1 13, 4:41pm
Last post by: mikemikev
No New Posts  
Legoland Miniland Washington DC  * 123
You know this is not going to be deleted
45 papaya 8,372 5th 12 12, 8:14pm
Last post by: Retrospect
No New Posts  
0 Ottava 1,861 1st 12 12, 7:26pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
Carly Foulkes  * 12
or, How Perverted Are These People?
39 Ottava 7,345 28th 11 12, 3:07pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
0 Ottava 1,466 14th 11 12, 3:54am
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
What's China?
Wikipedia redifining a nation
18 Michaeldsuarez 5,429 28th 10 12, 2:12am
Last post by: Michaeldsuarez
No New Posts  
2 Ottava 1,973 7th 9 12, 10:16pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
7 Ottava 2,943 25th 8 12, 4:19pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
Sally Ride, gay or not?
We need facts, damnit. Not just statements from her sister or foundati
1 Achromatic 2,018 25th 7 12, 2:58pm
Last post by: Michaeldsuarez
No New Posts  
300 Wikitaka 40,278 23rd 7 12, 7:07pm
Last post by: Jay
No New Posts  
11 Mister Die 3,526 1st 7 12, 8:02pm
Last post by: Michaeldsuarez
No New Posts  
Zero fret
Primarily for lower production costs
6 Emperor 2,571 4th 6 12, 1:16pm
Last post by: Web Fred
No New Posts  
Jaynes
Evolution of a blp
3 Text 2,316 20th 5 12, 2:28pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
Starts as a promotion for a site, ends up being a national issue
Starts as a promotion for a site, ends up being a national issue
2 islesv 2,166 26th 4 12, 6:27pm
Last post by: milowent
No New Posts  
Norwegian Elkhound
Moose Dog
5 Emperor 2,483 20th 4 12, 6:07pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
2 Proabivouac 2,018 16th 4 12, 9:18pm
Last post by: Proabivouac
No New Posts  
Electric knife  * 12
Hip and buttock padding
33 Emperor 16,389 15th 4 12, 11:30am
Last post by: Text
No New Posts  
History of Turkey = History of the Turks
Deletion of Western Civilization
5 Emperor 2,346 7th 4 12, 1:16am
Last post by: Somey
No New Posts  
World War II  * 123» 9
The anti-US version
169 Emperor 39,971 31st 3 12, 9:16pm
Last post by: Web Fred
No New Posts  
32 Emperor 6,948 31st 3 12, 11:53am
Last post by: Mister Die
No New Posts  
Wait a minute...
Wait a minute...
16 melloden 5,857 29th 3 12, 9:06pm
Last post by: Web Fred
No New Posts  
 * 12
22 Ottava 9,068 28th 3 12, 2:28pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
Miscellaneous Grab Bag  * 1234
Articles too horrible to dedicate attention to individually
78 Donny 30,589 27th 3 12, 8:38am
Last post by: Mister Die
No New Posts  
goofy and misleading
goofy and misleading
3 Emperor 2,233 26th 3 12, 11:45pm
Last post by: Text
No New Posts  
3 carbuncle 2,545 24th 3 12, 6:41pm
Last post by: Fusion
No New Posts  
Oh May!
Oh May!
6 mbz1 2,773 22nd 3 12, 2:59pm
Last post by: Ottava
No New Posts  
Donkey punch  * 123
The new face of education
44 HRIP7 21,413 21st 3 12, 12:20pm
Last post by: Angela Kennedy
No New Posts  
16 jsalsman 3,853 19th 3 12, 12:17am
Last post by: A Horse With No Name
No New Posts
0 Wikitaka 2,123 18th 3 12, 12:44pm
Last post by: Wikitaka
No New Posts  
3 thekohser 2,357 16th 3 12, 3:11am
Last post by: Shalom
No New Posts  
Why no Doritos Locos Tacos?
Why no Doritos Locos Tacos?
5 Emperor 3,184 15th 3 12, 10:22pm
Last post by: Web Fred
No New Posts  
10 EricBarbour 3,577 10th 3 12, 9:15pm
Last post by: A Horse With No Name
No New Posts  
Racism  * 123» 6
On Wikipedia
107 Emperor 19,561 4th 3 12, 6:43pm
Last post by: Detective
No New Posts  
6 Peter Damian 2,730 26th 2 12, 7:47pm
Last post by: Fusion
21 Pages V  1 2 3 > »  Start new topic
2 User(s) are browsing this forum (2 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

New Posts  New Replies
No New Posts  No New Replies
Hot topic  Hot Topic (New)
No new  Hot Topic (No New) 
Poll  Poll (New)
No new votes  Poll (No New)
Closed  Locked Topic
Moved  Moved Topic
 



-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 15th 12 17, 4:10am