QUOTE(gomi @ Wed 18th February 2009, 7:50pm)
The wikistalk tool reports that:
- Jayjg and Brewcrewer both edited 194 articles and 319 pages overall
- Jayjg and IronDuke both edited 88 articles and 311 pages overall
Virtually all of those articles are related to the Middle East conflict.
This omits the various blocks, protections, and other admin actions that Jayjg issues to protect articles in his area of interest. In reviewing his last 10,000 edits, it is difficult to find a content edit Jayjg has made outside his narrow field of interest.
Jayjg is not above labeling anyone he doesn't like "Anti-Semitic", while immediately erasing as "BLP" any suggestion that someone is "Anti-Arab" or "Anti-Muslim".
Jayjg and his henchmen, more than anyone else on Wikipedia, are responsible for its bias, lack of scholarship, lack of editorial integrity and distance, and general crappyness on topics related to the Middle East, Judaism, and Islam.
Brewcrewer and IronDuke get Kabal Kounts of 19 and 21 respectively. (For you new readers, that's number of mainspace articles edited by them, with the local Israel Lobby on WP, defined arbitrarily as a core of Jayjg, SlimVirgin, and Jpgordon.)
Here is Brewcrewer:
#1 Yigal_Amir - edited by 4 of 4 users
#2 World_War_I - edited by 4 of 4 users
#3 Steven_Spielberg - edited by 4 of 4 users
#4 Palestine - edited by 4 of 4 users
#5 Kristallnacht - edited by 4 of 4 users
#6 Israeli-occupied_territories - edited by 4 of 4 users
#7 Israel_Shahak - edited by 4 of 4 users
#8 Israel - edited by 4 of 4 users
#9 History_of_Israel - edited by 4 of 4 users
#10 Hamas - edited by 4 of 4 users
#11 Gas_chamber - edited by 4 of 4 users
#12 British_National_Party - edited by 4 of 4 users
#13 Ariel_Sharon - edited by 4 of 4 users
#14 Arab_citizens_of_Israel - edited by 4 of 4 users
#15 Anti-Zionism - edited by 4 of 4 users
#16 American_Jews - edited by 4 of 4 users
#17 Alan_Dershowitz - edited by 4 of 4 users
#18 Al-Qaeda - edited by 4 of 4 users
#19 Adolf_Hitler - edited by 4 of 4 users
And here is IronDuke:
#1 Zionism - edited by 4 of 4 users
#2 Yasser_Arafat - edited by 4 of 4 users
#3 Temple_Mount - edited by 4 of 4 users
#4 Palestine - edited by 4 of 4 users
#5 Osama_bin_Laden - edited by 4 of 4 users
#6 New_antisemitism - edited by 4 of 4 users
#7 Jewish_lobby - edited by 4 of 4 users
#8 Jesse_Jackson - edited by 4 of 4 users
#9 Jerusalem - edited by 4 of 4 users
#10 Israel_Shahak - edited by 4 of 4 users
#11 Islamofascism - edited by 4 of 4 users
#12 Hamas - edited by 4 of 4 users
#13 Elie_Wiesel - edited by 4 of 4 users
#14 David_Irving - edited by 4 of 4 users
#15 David_Duke - edited by 4 of 4 users
#16 Daniel_Pipes - edited by 4 of 4 users
#17 Ariel_Sharon - edited by 4 of 4 users
#18 Antisemitism - edited by 4 of 4 users
#19 Anti-Zionism - edited by 4 of 4 users
#20 Anti-Defamation_League - edited by 4 of 4 users
#21 Adolf_Eichmann - edited by 4 of 4 users
These are scores high enough for honorable mention (and look at those topics!). But we've seen much worse.
As for Jayjg, he is to the Israel Lobby on WP as Jossi was to Prem Rawat. Some user named Marden (not Rachel) was once actually banned for asking Jayjg again and again if he was paid to do what he does. Which is sit in Quebec, and apparently single-handedly attempt to turn large parts of Wikipedia into Bar Mitzvah conversation. I hope he at least got a Rolex for it.
G-Dett's description of Jayjg, As usual, hits the nail squarely on the head
Thu 19th February 2009, 12:35am
