FORUM WARNING [2] Division by zero (Line: 2933 of /srcsgcaop/boardclass.php)
Boy Scouts are for spanking? -
     
 
The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> General Discussion? What's that all about?

This subforum is for general discussion of Wikipedia and other Wikimedia projects. For a glossary of terms frequently used in such discussions, please refer to Wikipedia:Glossary. For a glossary of musical terms, see here. Other useful links:

Akahele.orgWikipedia-WatchWikitruthWP:ANWikiEN-L/Foundation-L (mailing lists) • Citizendium forums

> Boy Scouts are for spanking?, More from Wales talk
Peter Damian
post
Post #1


I have as much free time as a Wikipedia admin!
*********

Group: Regulars
Posts: 4,400
Joined:
Member No.: 4,212



As part of the increasingly incestuous relationship between the Wales page and WR, see here

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...for_spanking.3F

QUOTE

Mr. Wales, it may be time for you to either pay more attention to what's happening with this Wikipedia/Wikia relationship, or begin setting down some rules at Wikia along the lines of, "Don't embarrass Wikia or the Wikipedia project with your actions on Wikia or Wikipedia." You'll wonder what I'm talking about? I'm delighted to see that Wikipedia has a GFDL image of some boys involved in the Boy Scouts mission. I'm not so delighted to see that photo copied into a Wikia called "Spanking Art", to enhance an article about Boy Scouts that reads:

While nowadays the Scouting movement prohibits the use of corporal punishment as part of its activities, this was not always so, and in spanking stories they often go hand in hand, especially with Beaver and Cub Scouts. There are also some spanking drawings that show young scouts, e.g. by Comixpank.

Because of the connotations of discipline that comes with scouting, some adult spankophiles like to roleplay/ageplay a boy or girl scout (similar to playing schoolboys).

Exactly what kind of perverts are Wikia and the Wikimedia Foundation enabling, by allowing them free and unfettered access to simple pictures of boys, that are then twisted and exploited on your for-profit company's website, so that they are interwoven into adult perversions and roleplay?


QUOTE

I know I'm not supposed to link there [direct link to WR, horrors], but you really ought to spend a minute or two reviewing this analysis of what's going on, before you unwittingly spawn a worldwide boycott of Amazon.com, the primary investor in Wikia "Spanking Art", for being a pro-pedophilia corporation. - John Russ Finley (talk) 02:56, 22 January 2008 (UTC)


I see he uses the word 'perverts' for which Giano was temporarily blocked, and I was indef blocked. Be careful John.

QUOTE

Is there a reason that you are complaining on Wikipedia when the problem you have is with Wikia? Another site is using our image (or rather the Wikimedia Commons' image) in accordance with copyright in a way that you find inappropriate. There is nothing that Wikipedia can do. Mr.Z-man 04:13, 22 January 2008 (UTC)
Sorry, I saw above that this is the place to praise Mr. Wales for his development of Wikia, Inc. I assumed that it would also be the place to bring criticisms of Wikia to light. - John Russ Finley (talk) 04:21, 22 January 2008 (UTC)
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Jimbo_Wales"


Hey and before you unwittingly spawn a worldwide boycott of Amazon.com, the primary investor in Wikia "Spanking Art", for being a pro-pedophilia corporation has got to be a WP:LEGAL if I saw one. I DEMAND a community ban (as Durova argued in my case).

This post has been edited by Peter Damian:
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
Peter Damian   Boy Scouts are for spanking?  
Kato   Noted in another thread, about Wiki-Commons: http...  
JohnA   Cue Taxwoman in 3...2...1...  
thekohser   Cue Taxwoman in 3...2...1... Roger, that. Thin...  
Peter Damian   It's one thing for a 40-year-old man to wear ...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   I checked out the strange spanking-related Wikia...  
LamontStormstar   It's one thing for a 40-year-old man to wear ...  
Peter Damian   Actually Finley, if that is who he is, really is h...  
thekohser   It would appear that the photographer of the Boy S...  
Peter Damian   Even better, somehow find the moms and dads of t...  
Moulton   Oh, great. Now we have the Spankish Inquisition.  
Moulton   Obliviousness precludes advancement to the Ethics ...  
The Joy   I warned them! :) The Joy  
Miltopia   http://spankingart.wikia.com/wiki/Image:Cmxpack.jp...  
thekohser   I still don't understand why the wiki- and pe...  
Kato   I still don't understand why the wiki- and pe...  
Pwok   In normal, healthy life, there are diligent organi...  
Peter Damian   A few more comments on Wales' page suggesting ...  
Samuel Culper Sr.   Maybe David Shankbone (i.e. resident wikid reporte...  
the fieryangel   Maybe David Shankbone (i.e. resident wikid report...  
Somey   Man, the chick doing the spanking in that photo lo...  
Peter Damian   [quote name='the fieryangel' post='74916' date='T...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   Man, the chick doing the spanking in that photo l...  
dogbiscuit   Different kinds of offensiveness, IMO. What con...  
Jonny Cache   It's interesting that the woman's face in...  
Peter Damian   See http://spankingart.wikia.com/wiki/Web_group ...  
privatemusings   well done for bringing this out into the open - I ...  
dogbiscuit   In the UK, any adult has to be CRB checked (includ...  
Peter Damian   any adult has to be CRB checked Yes absolutely ...  
dogbiscuit   But this now raises some interesting questions. ...  
Peter Damian   The unintended consequence of this is not that th...  
The Joy   I don't really like WAS 4.250 now. :angry:  
sarcasticidealist   Long time troller, first time poster. I think peo...  
Kato   You guys are arguing against freedom. Against free...  
GlassBeadGame   [quote=WAS 4.250]You guys are arguing against fre...  
Peter Damian   You guys are arguing against freedom. Against free...  
The Joy   You guys are arguing against freedom. Against fre...  
The Joy   Privatemusings leading the charge! http://spa...  
Miltopia   This isn't just any wiki either, it's like...  
The Joy   It seems Wikia is now acting on the complaints. h...  
Miltopia   If I ever have to buy that much equipment to get o...  
Moulton   My estimate is that about 30% of the content of Wi...  
Peter Damian   OK enough is enough. I have just found this http...  
BobbyBombastic   OK enough is enough. I have just found this htt...  
thekohser   I'm waiting for a famous Jimbo quote. I thin...  
Jonny Cache   I see he uses the word "perverts" for w...  
Miltopia   These are just all disturbing really: http://span...  
Moulton   Wikia needs a good spanking.  
Miltopia   So Wikipedia is no good for kids because it's ...  
dogbiscuit   So Wikipedia is no good for kids because it's...  
UserB   What is ludicrous is that anyone defends this stuf...  
Moulton   If Wikipedians believed in academic freedom, they ...  
Peter Damian   Aha, someone now heading for a block on WP:LEGA...  
dogbiscuit   Did they have the idea themselves or did someone...  
Achromatic   Aha, someone now heading for a block on WP:LEGAL?...  
Peter Damian   Heading for? Economics Guy is already angling in ...  
dogbiscuit   [quote name='Achromatic' post='75056' date='Wed 2...  
dogbiscuit   I think we need a new category of Wikipediots, b...  
Amarkov   I think we need a new category of Wikipediots, ...  
UserB   I think we need a new category of Wikipediots, ...  
The Joy   The free information movement needs to consider be...  
Kato   The worst quote is by WAS 4.250 who writes in defe...  
guy   Nobody of Consequence: Is that our No one of conse...  
Miltopia   Y'know Wikia has terms of service against exce...  
The Joy   Y'know Wikia has terms of service against exc...  
dogbiscuit   I think the Spanking page are having an Ely*. I wa...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   Hm - http://spankingart.wikia.com/index.php?tit...  
thekohser   http://spankingart.wikia.com/index.php?tit...ser...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   I'll just remind Jimbo here, that the boycot...  
dtobias   Florida isn't actually a particularly liberal ...  
thekohser   What does Florida have to do with Wikia, Inc.? No...  
Moulton   Taboo Or Not Taboo. That Is the Question.  
Peter Damian   I see this has just appeared here http://en.wikip...  
dogbiscuit   I see this has just appeared here http://en.wiki...  
thekohser   BTW, I agree about being dubious as to the wisdom...  
dogbiscuit   [quote name='dogbiscuit' post='75183' date='Thu 2...  
AB   BTW, I agree about being dubious as to the wisdo...  
thekohser   Seriously, could you please do something like tha...  
AB   Seriously, could you please do something like th...  
thekohser   Original image is deleted (even from my personal h...  
AB   Original image is deleted (even from my personal ...  
Nathan   [I was actually thinking it would be better to pu...  
thekohser   Thank God, this may be coming to an end. The User...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   As of this minute, the page for http://spankingart...  
thekohser   I think they still have some more work to do if th...  
dogbiscuit   I think they still have some more work to do if t...  
Achromatic   Of course, WAS 4.250 is still deranged: Sorry,...  
thekohser   So Wales is going to sue one of us? [Edit] Greg,...  
dogbiscuit   I'm too conflicted to make the decision on e...  
Miltopia   WIKIPEDIA REVIEW IS THROWING UP MUD Dear Geniuses...  
dogbiscuit   That's the start of a sensible response, wel...  
jorge   It sets a tone where other people need to conside...  
dogbiscuit   It sets a tone where other people need to consid...  
Disillusioned Lackey   A really good response would be an open debate o...  
AB   A really good response would be an open debate o...  
dogbiscuit   [quote name='Disillusioned Lackey' post='75225' d...  
Disillusioned Lackey   That's a rhetorical question, right AB? Becau...  
AB   That's a rhetorical question, right AB? Beca...  
Derktar   WIKIPEDIA REVIEW IS THROWING UP MUD Dear Geniuse...  
Miltopia   I feel that Comixpank is pure pedocruft; why else ...  
privatemusings   I thought I'd echo here Greg's comments ov...  
Peter Damian   I thought I'd echo here Greg's comments o...  
thekohser   [quote name='privatemusings' post='75327' date='Th...  
JohnA   I think those naughty people at Wikia deserve a go...  
dogbiscuit   With regard to my comment on the appropriate respo...  
thekohser   ...we should remember that the majority of people...  
GlassBeadGame   With regard to my comment on the appropriate resp...  
dogbiscuit   With regard to my comment on the appropriate res...  
privatemusings   thanks for your comment, Greg! - I think your ...  
thekohser   It would appear that our celebration of dramatic p...  
Kato   This is the nexus of the whole thing Greg. The gra...  
Amarkov   You are confusing libertarianism with Objectivism....  
thekohser   After being blocked after 4 minutes of discussion ...  
Peter Damian   After being blocked after 4 minutes of discussion...  
Chris Croy   This whole brouhaha (I'm with the AP writer. ...  
thekohser   This whole brouhaha (I'm with the AP writer. ...  
Peter Damian   This whole brouhaha (I'm with the AP writer. ...  
Peter Damian   Spankart himself now comments on WR: 1. Having...  
dogbiscuit   It appears that Spanking Art has been closed down....  
Peter Damian   It appears that Spanking Art has been closed down...  
dogbiscuit   It appears that Spanking Art has been closed dow...  
Peter Damian   I note the Spanking Art comment, and UK law speci...  
AB   Of course it's not UK law in question here...  
dogbiscuit   However, now that we know that the spanking Wikia...  
AB   However, now that we know that the spanking Wiki...  
Aloft   No, still there. It went dead a few minutes ago (...  
Peter Damian   [quote name='Peter Damian' post='75594' date='Sat...  
the fieryangel   [quote name='Aloft' post='75601' date='Sat 26th J...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   Now, according to the UK law, wouldn't hosti...  
dogbiscuit   [quote name='the fieryangel' post='75607' date='S...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   [quote name='UseOnceAndDestroy' post='75615' date...  
UseOnceAndDestroy   I'm just getting a straight "301 Moved Pe...  
BobbyBombastic   I'm just getting a straight "301 Moved P...  
Somey   It's probably a bit late in the game for any a...  
thekohser   I just completed a most painful e-mail exchange wi...  
BobbyBombastic   Apparently, Jimbo thought that the ONE photo of ...  
Disillusioned Lackey   Gosh, how typical and predictable. What or who f...  
BobbyBombastic   I just completed a most painful e-mail exchange w...  
guy   This nomination becomes rather funny in retrospec...  
Aloft   Can anyone explain to me exactly how Jimbo gets aw...  
Nathan   Yes, it should've been done a while ago but th...  
thekohser   Yes, it should've been done a while ago but t...  
Nathan   Yes, it should've been done a while ago but ...  
Peter Damian   Nicely put.  
dogbiscuit   Is it me or is even the nomination for Spank Art g...  
Moulton   Closely Watched Brains Someday this story could b...  
Disillusioned Lackey   Closely Watched Brains Someday this story could ...  
Peter Damian   Nothing but opera would suffice Surely the Ring...  
euphonias   Update: Wikia CEO Gil Penchina posted a detailed ...  
dogbiscuit   Update: Wikia CEO Gil Penchina posted a detailed...  
euphonias   Believe it or not the image database is also avail...  
thekohser   Believe it or not the image database is also avai...  
Cedric   I spent most of the wee hours of Friday night / S...  
thekohser   I spent most of the wee hours of Friday night / ...  
JohnA   [quote name='Cedric' post='76537' date='Tue 29th ...  
dogbiscuit   Good work, Greg. Did you also manage to capture ...  
Kato   Someone writes in protest to Wikia removing the si...  
Aloft   I read that thread, and I'm amazed at how many...  
Robster   If there are sane people in that group, they will ...  
Peter Damian   Yay. Much more in that vein here: http://www....  
Moulton   I have cognitive dissonance over the notion that ...  
dogbiscuit   To put this in context, there was a minor brouhaha...  
Kato   This quote concerning the Advertising Standards Au...  
Disillusioned Lackey   This quote concerning the Advertising Standards A...  
Peter Damian   Giggle (not my IP, by the way).  
Moulton   Wouldn't it have been more appropriate to say ...  
thekohser   And, since Jimbo and Gil made sure to save everyth...  
The Joy   And, since Jimbo and Gil made sure to save everyt...  
GlassBeadGame   And, since Jimbo and Gil made sure to save everyt...  
guy   And, since Jimbo and Gil made sure to save everyt...  
euphonias   [quote name='thekohser' post='77069' date='Sun 3r...  
euphonias   Despite having his Wiki deleted, SpankArt's us...  
Kato   "We did not plan to make the URL of our rela...  
Somey   Is it just me, or was Wikia vastly more discerning...  
thekohser   Can they not say "no"? I assume they ju...  
dogbiscuit   Again from the forum; Still haven't seemed ...  
Somey   Still haven't seemed to have grasped that it i...  
Peter Damian   Long story short, being associated with "spa...  
Moulton   Is it time yet to craft a definitive comic opera, ...  
The Joy   The good Wikia sites like Uncyclopedia weren't...  
euphonias   Connoisseurs of fine spanking art will be glad to ...  
Robster   They're clearly putting the ass in class.  
dogbiscuit   From the new site Though the spanking site isn...  
Peter Damian   [url=http://spankingartwii.animeotk.com/wiki/Span...  
Selina   [url=http://spankingartwii.animeotk.com/wiki/Spa...  


Closed TopicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now:
 
     
FORUM WARNING [2] Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home2/wikipede/public_html/int042kj398.php:242) (Line: 0 of Unknown)