Printable Version of Topic
Click here to view this topic in its original format
_ Wikipedia in Blogland _ Doodling for Wikipedia
Posted by: thekohser
I am very concerned about this woman's http://garvoille.wordpress.com/2010/03/05/day-118-tenets-of-wikipedia/, and how the "pillars" of Wikipedia are being indoctrinated into young minds.
The school is the Durham (NC) http://www.dsa.dpsnc.net/.
QUOTE
Each students was assigned...
Posted by: thekohser
Garvoille's http://garvoille.wordpress.com/2010/03/05/day-118-tenets-of-wikipedia/#comment-48 now.
Posted by: BelovedFox
How exactly is that "mad"? She's acknowledging you have germane experience in the field, and is inviting your comments... she takes issue with your rhetoric. Furthermore the post she links (http://rebelliousreader.blogspot.com/2009/04/writing-wikipedia-pages-in.html) is quite reasonable. Rather than outright banning Wikipedia from schools, she suggests using it as a teaching tool.
FTA:
QUOTE
In this paper, we will present a theoretical framework for using Wikipedia in the classroom, not as a source for research, but as an opportunity to conduct research and engage in critical thought.
Posted by: The Joy
QUOTE(BelovedFox @ Thu 11th March 2010, 5:22pm) 
How exactly is that "mad"? She's acknowledging you have germane experience in the field, and is inviting your comments... she takes issue with your rhetoric. Furthermore the post she links (http://rebelliousreader.blogspot.com/2009/04/writing-wikipedia-pages-in.html) is quite reasonable. Rather than outright banning Wikipedia from schools, she suggests using it as a teaching tool.
FTA:
QUOTE
In this paper, we will present a theoretical framework for using Wikipedia in the classroom, not as a source for research, but as an opportunity to conduct research and engage in critical thought.
She also deleted Greg's comment. Not very nice or proper for an academic.
Posted by: thekohser
QUOTE(The Joy @ Thu 11th March 2010, 5:53pm)
She also deleted Greg's comment. Not very nice or proper for an academic.
Yes, it would seem rather inefficient for me to provide her any additional ideas, seeing how she deleted my earlier comment. How does that fit in with what she said about her students posting a checked draft to Wikipedia, where "it would be saved forever in the history of an article"?
I guess her blog doesn't hold to that same wonderful attribute of permanence that she readily praised in the AACE-Ed Media Conference Proceedings.
Looks like we've simply found ourselves yet another "model Wikipedian".
QUOTE(BelovedFox @ Thu 11th March 2010, 5:22pm)
...the post she links (http://rebelliousreader.blogspot.com/2009/04/writing-wikipedia-pages-in.html) is quite reasonable.
QUOTE
"Most adolescents rightly see Wikipedia as a viable source..."
QUOTE
"With Wikipedia edits in hand, our adolescents will have gained the power to impact readers all over the world..."
Yeah, sounds very reasonable and objective, like any impartial teacher should be.