FORUM WARNING [2] Division by zero (Line: 2933 of /srcsgcaop/boardclass.php)
Racism -
     
 
The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> Help

This subforum is for critical evaluation of Wikipedia articles. However, to reduce topic-bloat, please make note of exceptionally poor stubs, lists, and other less attention-worthy material in the Miscellaneous Grab Bag thread. Also, please be aware that agents of the Wikimedia Foundation might use your evaluations to improve the articles in question.

Useful Links: Featured Article CandidatesFeatured Article ReviewArticles for DeletionDeletion Review

> Racism, On Wikipedia
Emperor
post
Post #1


Postmaster
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 1,871
Joined:
Member No.: 2,042



Racism

They seem to have some idea what the definition is but not in the first lines of the article.

QUOTE
Racism is the belief that inherent different traits in human racial groups justify discrimination. In the modern English language, the term "racism" is used predominantly as a pejorative epithet. It is applied especially to the practice or advocacy of racial discrimination of a pernicious nature (i.e. which harms particular groups of people), and which is often justified by recourse to racial stereotyping or pseudo-science. Racism is popularly associated with various activities that are illegal or commonly considered harmful, such as extremism, hatred, xenophobia, (malignant or forced) exploitation, separatism, racial supremacy, mass murder (for the purpose of genocide), genocide denial, vigilantism (hate crimes, terrorism), etc.


Chock full of garbled English and debatable definitions (that differ from Merriam-Webster and Dictionary.com).

Also note the gigantic Bank of America banner in the middle of the article.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
Mister Die
post
Post #2


Junior Member
**

Group: Contributors
Posts: 88
Joined:
Member No.: 75,644



Yeah, I'm aware that only inept types just go out and be like "Hitler was a genius and the Jews got what was coming to them[1] (source: HITLERWASRIGHT DOT COM)," I was just being humorous.

This does remind me, though, of a criticism all the way back in 2005 that still holds just as much today: http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/wikiwoo2.htm#Massacres
QUOTE
This is the big problem with purely volunteer activities. You only get people working on things they care deeply about. In this case, we've had Polish nationalist contributors wanting to show how badly their country has suffered at everybody's hands. (Not just Germans, but Lithuanians, Jews, Ukrainians and Soviets have kicked the Poles around on this list.) We've had neo-Nazi contributors trying to prove that Germany was surrounded by big bad enemies, so of course the Nazis were justified in invading them. We've had anti-American contributors wanting to show that the USA is (and always has been) worse than almost everyone else in history, even worse than the Soviets (7 massacres by Americans versus 1 by the Soviets.). Meanwhile, no one really cares what the Japanese did in Singapore, or what the Italians did in Yugoslavia. ("Whatever. It was a long time ago.")


This post has been edited by Mister Die:
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
radek
post
Post #3


Ãœber Member
*****

Group: Regulars
Posts: 699
Joined:
Member No.: 15,651



QUOTE(Mister Die @ Wed 22nd February 2012, 11:45am) *

Yeah, I'm aware that only inept types just go out and be like "Hitler was a genius and the Jews got what was coming to them[1] (source: HITLERWASRIGHT DOT COM)," I was just being humorous.

This does remind me, though, of a criticism all the way back in 2005 that still holds just as much today: http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/wikiwoo2.htm#Massacres
QUOTE
This is the big problem with purely volunteer activities. You only get people working on things they care deeply about. In this case, we've had Polish nationalist contributors wanting to show how badly their country has suffered at everybody's hands. (Not just Germans, but Lithuanians, Jews, Ukrainians and Soviets have kicked the Poles around on this list.) We've had neo-Nazi contributors trying to prove that Germany was surrounded by big bad enemies, so of course the Nazis were justified in invading them. We've had anti-American contributors wanting to show that the USA is (and always has been) worse than almost everyone else in history, even worse than the Soviets (7 massacres by Americans versus 1 by the Soviets.). Meanwhile, no one really cares what the Japanese did in Singapore, or what the Italians did in Yugoslavia. ("Whatever. It was a long time ago.")



Oh yeah, I used to really appreciate Mr. White's website. Back in the day before Wikipedia became all encompassing it was the first hit on search engines if you wanted to look up a lot of military history stuff or massacres or wars or whatever. It was/is a "amateurish" (I think) but in a good sense - an "amateur" who knows his stuff, is passionate about it, and can back up his position and ideas with sources. And then he got squeezed out by Wikipedia, whose comparative collection of information is pathetic.

He also tried editing Wikipedia at one point and just gave up, I think. Is this someone I'm supposed to know? Anyone from the present company? (If so I apologize in advance for not being aware).
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
Emperor   Racism  
Selina   Oh, somehow the racists managed to get a separate ...  
Malik Shabazz   Oh, somehow the racists managed to get a separate...  
Mister Die   It's very obvious sometimes that certain artic...  
Emperor   It's very obvious sometimes that certain arti...  
Mister Die   If I were a neonazi this would be exactly the arti...  
Emperor   [quote name='Emperor' post='298677' date='Wed 22n...  
radek   [quote name='Emperor' post='298677' date='Wed 22n...  
Selina   Whatever team of POV pushers made the "racial...  
Emperor   Also note the gigantic [b]Bank of America banner ...  
EricBarbour   Now, you guys are onto something. The secret of co...  
Selina   "zionist" is pretty much used as a codew...  
nableezy   "zionist" is pretty much used as a code...  
Malik Shabazz   "zionist" is pretty much used as a cod...  
nableezy   [quote name='nableezy' post='298738' date='Wed 22...  
Kelly Martin   She seemed to be saying that when somebody uses th...  
nableezy   [quote name='nableezy' post='298742' date='Wed 22...  
Wikifan   give me a break. you're biased just like eve...  
Mister Die   It shouldn't be too hard to find sources that ...  
lilburne   Ez9JCSIEbpY Just a reminder.  
Cunningly Linguistic   Ez9JCSIEbpY Just a reminder. A great and thoug...  
lilburne   A great and thought provoking speech from my MP (...  
Cunningly Linguistic   A great and thought provoking speech from my MP ...  
Detective   I thought you said you DIDN'T live in a Live...  
lilburne   [quote name='Cunningly Linguistic' post='299730' ...  
Cunningly Linguistic   [quote name='Cunningly Linguistic' post='299730'...  
Fusion   A great and thought provoking speech from my MP (...  
Selina   I never said it always means it, no - but neo-nazi...  
Selina   The fact that mentioning "jew" around so...  
nableezy   The fact that mentioning "jew" around s...  
Emperor   And where [b]pray tell did this happen? [b]SOCK...  
nableezy   And where [b]pray tell did this happen? [b]SOC...  
EricBarbour   :yecch:  
Emperor   Anyway Radek, Mr Die, Selina, thank you for your t...  
radek   Anyway Radek, Mr Die, Selina, thank you for your ...  
Selina   Malik Zulu Shabazz, leader of the New Black Panthe...  
radek   Malik Zulu Shabazz, leader of the New Black Panth...  
Emperor   [quote name='Selina' post='298791' date='Wed 22nd...  
Malik Shabazz   [quote name='Selina' post='298791' date='Wed 22n...  
Selina   I wish I didn't know who that was Emperor... ...  
radek   Well, yes, I know who Malik is named after. And ...  
Selina   They murdered him only two days later.  
radek   They murdered him only two days later. And how ...  
Selina   Because he supports them... wikipediareview.com/?s...  
radek   Because he supports them... [url=http://wikipedia...  
Selina   I'm not talking about the sources, I'm tal...  
radek   I'm not talking about the sources, I'm ta...  
Selina   Read the whole post instead of just skimming it th...  
radek   Read the whole post instead of just skimming it t...  
Selina   The sad thing is though that this thread was crap ...  
Malik Shabazz   @Malik: "WP:V"? That's not the kind...  
Herschelkrustofsky   Mod's note: Selina has blocked Nableezy until ...  
Fusion   [i]Mod's note: Selina has blocked Nableezy un...  
The Joy   [i]Mod's note: Selina has blocked Nableezy un...  
Wikifan   yeah, good luck with that. you've already se...  
Ego Trippin' (Part Two)   sourced from ADL but quotes are available elsew...  
Wikifan   sourced from ADL but quotes are available else...  
Ego Trippin' (Part Two)   What are you implying by bolding that particular...  
Emperor   These are the kinds of things you learn in colleg...  
Wikifan   so wall street financiers=jews? LF and other noi...  
Ego Trippin' (Part Two)   so wall street financiers=jews? LF and other no...  
Fusion   Not all of them were Jews, of course, but some we...  
Ego Trippin' (Part Two)   so then what's your beef? the need to expla...  
Wikifan   so then what's your beef? the need to expl...  
Malik Shabazz   i dont understand why this appeals to malik. Hav...  
Wikifan   [quote name='Wikifan' post='298966' date='Fri 24t...  
lilburne   funny thing about soviet union, they basically ...  
Mister Die   I don't see how Trotsky was said to be involve...  
radek   I don't see how Trotsky was said to be involv...  
Mister Die   [quote name='Mister Die' post='299015' date='Fri ...  
lilburne   When I was a member of the CPGB a number of the ...  
Detective   Sockhunting by similarity of views is great fun. ...  
Emperor   They've also got the flag of Sardinia there, w...  
Text   They've also got the flag of Sardinia there, w...  
jsalsman   Does anyone remember the 2008 article "Wikipe...  
radek   Does anyone remember the 2008 article "Wikip...  
jsalsman   [quote name='jsalsman' post='300050' date='Thu 1st...  
iii   So are the "real but irrelevant Wikipedia fa...  
radek   You didn't read the answer correctly, hence ...  
Emperor   The more I read the article the more I realize wha...  
Wikifan   this is just my synthesis, but most of the whol...  
Alexkrsz   Conflating the culture, people, government and...  
Emperor   Makes sense, kind of fits with the wacky Wikipedia...  
Wikifan   Makes sense, kind of fits with the wacky Wikipedi...  
Emperor   Is this some kind of defense of Noam Chomsky or so...  
Wikifan   Is this some kind of defense of Noam Chomsky or s...  
Somey   nah, just typical far-left reactionary noise. fun...  
Wikifan   [quote name='Wikifan' post='300125' date='Thu 1st...  
Selina   The Jeffrey Latham who who has been screaming agai...  
thekohser   The Jeffrey Latham who who has been screaming aga...  
Emperor   [quote name='Selina' post='300118' date='Thu 1st ...  
thekohser   And Greg, come on. Enough already. Okay, how...  
Emperor   Okay, how's this... A possible explanation f...  
jsalsman   A possible explanation for how racism is documente...  
TungstenCarbide   African American wikipedians seem to stay around l...  
EricBarbour   I don't see Bcorr on that list - he was one o...  
jsalsman   [quote name='jsalsman' post='300310' date='Sat 3r...  
lilburne   [quote name='TungstenCarbide' post='300312' date=...  
thekohser   Surprising didn't Fred Bauber say that Africa...  
Detective   though how anyone could consider that "mains...  
Selina   The common thread is I upset slimeballs with egos ...  
The Joy   The common thread is I upset slimeballs with egos...  
Selina   4LE3vtU8CZk lalexosgwUk youtu.be/Z6MRdL89CzQ#t=1...  
SB_Johnny   [youtube]4LE3vtU8CZk I had an unfortunate experie...  
Emperor   Opponents of affirmative action assert that it i...  
Selina   [/quote] [url=http://blackpeopleloveus.com]blackpe...  


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now:
 
     
FORUM WARNING [2] Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home2/wikipede/public_html/int042kj398.php:242) (Line: 0 of Unknown)