| |
 Moulton arbitration request |
|
|
|
  |
Replies
| Cynick |
 Fri 11th April 2008, 12:17am
|
New Member
Group: Contributors
Posts: 23
Joined: Sun 18th Nov 2007, 1:20pm
Member No.: 3,881
|
QUOTE(michael @ Wed 5th December 2007, 11:46pm)  There's currently a request at WP:RFAR to review Moulton's indefinite block. I'm a bit confuzzled. No arb has yet voted on whether to accept it or not, and I know they're active - the Episodes and characters RFAR just went from evidence fo voting. Will he win a reprieve like Ferrylodge? Or will he be sunk like Iantresman? Looks like Iantresman has bobbed to the surface in ArbCom, together with all the usual suspects, including JoshuaZ, ScienceApologist, JzG, and Raul654. Insults, innuendo, and insinuations are already flying. Clinton and Barack could probably pick up a couple of tips. |
|
|
|
|
|
| Proabivouac |
Fri 11th April 2008, 12:23am
|
Bane of all wikiland
Group: Contributors
Posts: 2,246
Joined: Thu 23rd Aug 2007, 8:25am
Member No.: 2,647
WP user page -
talk
check -
contribs
|
QUOTE(Cynick @ Fri 11th April 2008, 12:17am) QUOTE(michael @ Wed 5th December 2007, 11:46pm) There's currently a request at WP:RFAR to review Moulton's indefinite block. I'm a bit confuzzled. No arb has yet voted on whether to accept it or not, and I know they're active - the Episodes and characters RFAR just went from evidence fo voting. Will he win a reprieve like Ferrylodge? Or will he be sunk like Iantresman? Looks like Iantresman has bobbed to the surface in ArbCom, together with all the usual suspects, including JoshuaZ, ScienceApologist, JzG, and Raul654. Insults, innuendo, and insinuations are already flying. Clinton and Barack could probably pick up a couple of tips. This is a really unfortunate situation. The trouble with Iantresman isn't behavior, but content. No mechanism exists to politely say, Ian, you seem like a decent fellow, but Wikipedia isn't the right place for this content. Instead, Iantresman is personally banned. It's the only solution within the current system, but it doesn't seem right. |
|
|
|
|
|
| Cynick |
Sat 12th April 2008, 3:58pm
|
New Member
Group: Contributors
Posts: 23
Joined: Sun 18th Nov 2007, 1:20pm
Member No.: 3,881
|
QUOTE(Proabivouac @ Fri 11th April 2008, 1:23am) QUOTE(Cynick @ Fri 11th April 2008, 12:17am) QUOTE(michael @ Wed 5th December 2007, 11:46pm) There's currently a request at WP:RFAR to review Moulton's indefinite block. I'm a bit confuzzled. No arb has yet voted on whether to accept it or not, and I know they're active - the Episodes and characters RFAR just went from evidence fo voting. Will he win a reprieve like Ferrylodge? Or will he be sunk like Iantresman? Looks like Iantresman has bobbed to the surface in ArbCom, together with all the usual suspects, including JoshuaZ, ScienceApologist, JzG, and Raul654. Insults, innuendo, and insinuations are already flying. Clinton and Barack could probably pick up a couple of tips. This is a really unfortunate situation. The trouble with Iantresman isn't behavior, but content. No mechanism exists to politely say, Ian, you seem like a decent fellow, but Wikipedia isn't the right place for this content. Instead, Iantresman is personally banned. It's the only solution within the current system, but it doesn't seem right. Iantresman's community ban proposed pseudoscience "POV pushing" (content) and harassing two editors from Wikipedia (behavoral). The banning editor says he was banned for "persistent disruption" which is behavoral. Any idea what pseudoscience was pushed? |
|
|
|
|
|
Posts in this topic
 michael Moulton arbitration request Wed 5th December 2007, 10:46pm The Joy I think ArbCom has entered its lame duck period an... Wed 5th December 2007, 10:48pm Moulton KillerChihuahua hasn't responded to the RfC ye... Wed 5th December 2007, 11:40pm Amarkov Well, the arbitrators are starting to reject it, p... Thu 6th December 2007, 6:35am Jonny Cache
From where did the strange idea here come, that t... Thu 6th December 2007, 12:48pm Moulton Well, the arbitrators are starting to reject it, p... Thu 6th December 2007, 2:08pm Poetlister It's a subtle dig at Wikinews, which does purp... Thu 6th December 2007, 12:43pm GlassBeadGame Krill's edit declining Arbitration is telling.... Thu 6th December 2007, 3:13pm Moulton [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wik... Thu 6th December 2007, 3:48pm AB From the statement by MastCell (diff, minor amendm... Thu 6th December 2007, 4:19pm Moulton [quote name='AB' post='64512' date='Thu 6th Decemb... Thu 6th December 2007, 4:29pm Moulton The questions I have placed on ArbCom's table ... Thu 6th December 2007, 4:50pm Moulton Josh Gordon evidently believes there are already w... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:02pm Jonny Cache
Josh Gordon evidently believes there are already ... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:18pm Moulton Sorry. Didn't mean to upstage you.
There... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:25pm Jonny Cache
Sorry. Didn't mean to upstage you.
There... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:30pm AB Have you considered asking for the right to vanish... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:29pm Moulton Have you considered asking for the right to vanish... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:42pm AB Have you considered asking for the right to vanis... Thu 6th December 2007, 10:49pm Jonny Cache
[quote name='Moulton' post='64586' date='Thu 6th... Fri 7th December 2007, 1:06pm Moulton Do you remember that famous Bob & Ray Komodo D... Thu 6th December 2007, 11:02pm Cedric
Do you remember that famous Bob & Ray Komodo ... Fri 7th December 2007, 10:47am Moulton Speaking of a lack of listening skills, have you e... Fri 7th December 2007, 11:38am Moulton Alas, I'm not dealing with children, who are g... Fri 7th December 2007, 3:27pm Jonny Cache
Alas, I'm not dealing with children, who are ... Fri 7th December 2007, 3:50pm Moulton Wikipediot is a social experiment that has shown u... Fri 7th December 2007, 4:01pm Jonny Cache
Wikipediot is a social experiment that has shown... Fri 7th December 2007, 4:06pm Moulton It's also about reading the reports of other o... Fri 7th December 2007, 4:29pm Jonny Cache
[quote name='Jonny Cache' post='64776' date='Fri ... Fri 7th December 2007, 4:40pm Somey We used to have an active participant, Nobs, who h... Fri 7th December 2007, 5:13pm Moulton You mean I am not sui generis?
I am so chagrined. Fri 7th December 2007, 4:43pm Moulton Can you summarize his concept of "ideological... Fri 7th December 2007, 5:19pm Somey Can you summarize his concept of "ideological... Fri 7th December 2007, 6:54pm nobs
[quote name='Moulton' post='64800' date='Fri 7th ... Sat 8th December 2007, 6:34pm Jonny Cache No, I wasn't comparing Moulton to Nobs in that... Fri 7th December 2007, 5:36pm Disillusioned Lackey Now's not the ideal time to go to Arbcom.
Fr... Fri 7th December 2007, 5:38pm Moulton Inside the Prankster's Studio
One of the feat... Fri 7th December 2007, 6:11pm Moulton Hrmmm. Those are political ideologies and/or hist... Fri 7th December 2007, 7:03pm Moulton It appears that the requirement to abide by WP pol... Sat 8th December 2007, 4:40pm Moulton Iantresman was community banned and is seeking to ... Fri 11th April 2008, 1:10am The Joy
Iantresman was community banned and is seeking to... Fri 11th April 2008, 2:31am Moulton As I understand it, a community ban requires a com... Fri 11th April 2008, 3:00am Proabivouac
In other words, the members of the Wikipedia Proj... Fri 11th April 2008, 4:10am dtobias The reasons to justify a block/ban tend to be like... Fri 11th April 2008, 3:43am KamrynMatika
The reasons to justify a block/ban tend to be lik... Fri 11th April 2008, 3:50am Milton Roe
The reasons to justify a block/ban tend to be lik... Fri 11th April 2008, 5:37am Moulton Is there a concise summary of what happened in tha... Fri 11th April 2008, 4:36am Proabivouac
Is there a concise summary of what happened in th... Fri 11th April 2008, 4:45am the fieryangel
[quote name='Moulton' post='91793' date='Fri 11th... Fri 11th April 2008, 8:11am Moulton Thank you. I see this commentary from the ArbCom ... Fri 11th April 2008, 5:05am Kato It is inevitable that Wikipedia is going to be edi... Fri 11th April 2008, 5:25am Moulton Again, we see the damage done by editors who are n... Fri 11th April 2008, 12:44pm thekohser
He must have attended the Guy Chapman School of ... Fri 11th April 2008, 7:53pm Milton Roe [quote name='Moulton' post='91845' date='Fri 11th ... Fri 11th April 2008, 8:23pm Moulton Now take a look at the entirety of that otherwise ... Fri 11th April 2008, 8:18pm Cedric
Now take a look at the entirety of that otherwise... Sat 12th April 2008, 4:19pm Moulton The issue is further muddled by the observation th... Fri 11th April 2008, 8:30pm Moulton I don't have time to go look this up, so I... Sat 12th April 2008, 4:10pm Moulton Given that those initial 100 scientists and academ... Sat 12th April 2008, 11:14pm
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
| |
