| |
 Gerard blocks Giano for sockpuppetry, invokes good/bad hand accounts policy - wrongly |
|
|
|
  |
Replies
| everyking |
 Wed 19th November 2008, 5:57am
|
Postmaster
Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,368
Joined: Mon 27th Mar 2006, 7:24am
Member No.: 81
|
None of these joke account sockpuppets should be allowed, and they certainly should not be allowed to run for ArbCom. Just before I found about about this incident, I was thinking about asking some tough questions on "Catherine's" questions page about the disruptive nature of the candidacy. On the other hand, this idea that it was a "good hand/bad hand" situation or that it was deceptive sockpuppetry is simply ludicrous, as there was clearly no malice or deception involved in it. Gerard just saw it as an opportunity to take Giano down a notch, to pursue the grudge, and his conduct (in this as well as many, many other instances) certainly warrants desysopping.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posts in this topic
 privatemusings Gerard blocks Giano for sockpuppetry Tue 18th November 2008, 10:25pm Doc glasgow
hee hee
impressively dumb!
(sorry DG, you... Tue 18th November 2008, 10:31pm LessHorrid vanU David Gerard has blocked Giano for operating the C... Tue 18th November 2008, 10:37pm Alex This thread is a duplicate. Should be merged.
Mod... Tue 18th November 2008, 10:47pm Alex Friday's opinion:
Tue 18th November 2008, 10:51pm  Son of a Yeti
Friday's opinion:
It's getting better... Tue 18th November 2008, 11:00pm Milton Roe
Friday's opinion:
It's getting bette... Tue 18th November 2008, 11:37pm sarcasticidealist Giano's handling this with uncharacteristic go... Tue 18th November 2008, 11:07pm Alex Now a request for arbitration is opened. Phil Sand... Tue 18th November 2008, 11:30pm Basil Phil Sandifer demonstrating that he hasn't los... Tue 18th November 2008, 11:35pm CrazyGameOfPoker ====Statement by [[User:Alex Bakharev|Alex Bakhare... Wed 19th November 2008, 1:01am Kato I might as well export a post I made to another th... Wed 19th November 2008, 1:15am EricBarbour
[b]All that blather about [i]those nasty arbcom m... Wed 19th November 2008, 5:36am The Joy I think it if this is accepted, it'll just be ... Wed 19th November 2008, 2:11am SirFozzie I have a sneaky suspicion that all folks who run f... Wed 19th November 2008, 2:15am The Wales Hunter
I have a sneaky suspicion that all folks who run ... Wed 19th November 2008, 2:27am SirFozzie That verification is REAL LIFE information (your n... Wed 19th November 2008, 2:28am The Wales Hunter Fair point. Though I wouldn't have any problem... Wed 19th November 2008, 2:37am Anonymous editor http://img513.imageshack.us/img513/6817/facepalmmu... Wed 19th November 2008, 4:32am Giano
None of these joke account sockpuppets should be ... Wed 19th November 2008, 9:27am Cla68
None of these joke account sockpuppets should be... Thu 20th November 2008, 6:08am Herschelkrustofsky
I usually just go to Jimbo's talk page and as... Sat 22nd November 2008, 9:56pm Pumpkin Muffins ..and behold! This debate is now [url=http://e... Sun 23rd November 2008, 3:31am The Joy
..and behold! This debate is now [url=http://... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:28am Lar
I don't believe I've ever witnessed an on... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:44am The Joy
I don't believe I've ever witnessed an o... Sun 23rd November 2008, 6:08am Giggy
I'm not trying to gloat, Lar, and I can tell ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:28am Deacon This recent block, done in the middle of a GMT nig... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:45am GlassBeadGame
I don't believe I've ever witnessed an o... Sun 23rd November 2008, 3:52pm everyking
..and behold! This debate is now [url=http://... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:47am Milton Roe
[quote name='Cla68' post='142155' date='Wed 19th ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 3:44am Kato Probably Giano should have said that all the goth ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:57am Milton Roe
[quote name='Milton Roe' post='142577' date='Sun ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:03pm Peter Damian I can't be bothered to comment. It's all ... Wed 19th November 2008, 9:09am maggot3 Already a thread about it, just for your informati... Wed 19th November 2008, 9:13am Peter Damian
Already a thread about it, just for your informat... Wed 19th November 2008, 9:17am Doc glasgow David Gerard was obviously trolling, but he's ... Wed 19th November 2008, 9:33am Giano
David Gerard was obviously trolling, but he's... Wed 19th November 2008, 9:54am Doc glasgow
I just don't like the thought of David Gerar... Wed 19th November 2008, 1:01pm Alex
I just don't like the thought of David Gerard... Wed 19th November 2008, 1:42pm Piperdown There's just something wrong with any organisa... Fri 21st November 2008, 1:29am Kato On an unrelated note, I generally loathe historica... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:44am Peter Damian Lovely comment on Giano talk page:
Oh yes and A... Sun 23rd November 2008, 8:59am Moulton [quote name='The Joy' post='142585' date='Sun 23rd... Sun 23rd November 2008, 10:49am Herschelkrustofsky
Oh yes and Adler knows his stuff. Mr. Adler, if ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 3:07pm SirFozzie and SlimVirgin has unblocked.
(Block log); 04:12 ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:18am Cla68
and SlimVirgin has unblocked.
(Block log); 04:12... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:29am Cedric
That's a power play if I've ever seen one... Sun 23rd November 2008, 10:34am Proabivouac
and SlimVirgin has unblocked.
(Block log); 04:12 ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 10:44am Deacon
and SlimVirgin has unblocked.
Was wondering wh... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:29am SirFozzie .. No. I don't agree with the block, but I wou... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:33am Deacon
.. No. I don't agree with the block, but I wo... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:48am Peter Damian I expect I will be accused of harrassing FT2 again... Sun 23rd November 2008, 3:45pm Herschelkrustofsky
The only remotely uncivil remark he made was this... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:43pm Kato I may be missing something, but can anyone explain... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:06pm Peter Damian
I may be missing something, but can anyone explai... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:31pm Deacon Giano is seen as, and to a large extent is, the le... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:37pm wikiwhistle
Giano is seen as, and to a large extent is, the l... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:40pm Herschelkrustofsky
Giano is seen as, and to a large extent is, the l... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:46pm Peter Damian
[quote name='Deacon' post='142623' date='Sun 23rd... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:51pm Obesity
That remark makes me think seriously of leaving W... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:06pm Peter Damian
That remark makes me think seriously of leaving ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:11pm groody
Please, Peter. This is vintage Kato. Anyone who... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:25pm Milton Roe
Can't speak for Kato, but I can speak for mys... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:35pm groody ...vandalized stuff does NOT go "out of exist... Sun 23rd November 2008, 8:16pm Lar
As Mr. Spock once said about logic, it's a wr... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:16pm Milton Roe
[quote name='Milton Roe' post='142657' date='Sun ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:32pm Lar
[quote name='Milton Roe' post='142657' date='Sun... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:34pm Kato
Please, Peter. This is vintage Kato. Anyone who... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:26pm Obesity
I don't recall writing anything of the sort y... Sun 23rd November 2008, 6:14pm Kato
If I hurt your feelings, I'm sorry, but your ... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:02pm Kato
That remark makes me think seriously of leaving W... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:46pm wikiwhistle
I may be missing something, but can anyone explai... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:37pm Pumpkin Muffins
I may be missing something, but can anyone explai... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:38pm Doc glasgow
[quote name='Kato' post='142620' date='Sun 23rd N... Sun 23rd November 2008, 8:56pm Peter Damian
His "content contributors vs ruling admins... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:03pm Doc glasgow
His "content contributors vs ruling admins... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:15pm Newyorkbrad
[quote name='Peter Damian' post='142681' date='Su... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:25pm Peter Damian
[quote name='Peter Damian' post='142681' date='Su... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:38pm Newyorkbrad
[quote name='Peter Damian' post='142681' date='S... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:48pm Peter Damian
[quote name='Peter Damian' post='142691' date='Su... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:51pm Doc glasgow
[quote name='Peter Damian' post='142681' date='S... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:54pm Pumpkin Muffins Kato is right, and Pumpkin Muffins is talking crap... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:46pm Peter Damian Like this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_Pal... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:44pm wikiwhistle
Like this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_Pa... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:59pm maggot3
Precisely, he's only worked on a few articles... Sun 23rd November 2008, 6:03pm Piperdown Most "uncivil".
http://en.wikipedia.org... Sun 23rd November 2008, 4:58pm Mike H
We went from Peter Damian to Michael Damian. Lov... Sun 23rd November 2008, 5:14pm Peter Damian Even our own Wikiwhistle joins the anti-Giano hord... Sun 23rd November 2008, 6:01pm JoseClutch True or not, Giano is also widely seen as the vict... Sun 23rd November 2008, 6:34pm Kelly Martin he gets a pass when he returns the level of civili... Sun 23rd November 2008, 6:50pm wikiwhistle Here is the content contribution in giano's la... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:39pm GlassBeadGame It is not surprising that people disenchanted with... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:47pm Peter Damian
Here is the content contribution in giano's l... Sun 23rd November 2008, 8:51pm Deacon In other news, FT2 has launched an Arbitration cas... Sun 23rd November 2008, 7:58pm One OK, this thread has gone on long enough without th... Sun 23rd November 2008, 8:06pm Milton Roe
OK, this thread has gone on long enough without t... Sun 23rd November 2008, 8:18pm The Wales Hunter
OK, this thread has gone on long enough without t... Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:00pm D.A.F. Interesting Sun 23rd November 2008, 9:16pm
2 Pages  1 2 >
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
| |
