Akahele: Tilikum and Wikipedia, by Gregory Kohs Options

[thekohser]

With a special "thank you" to another of my Internet Review Corporation colleagues for bringing me the links, I give you another edition of Akahele!

[MZMcBride]

What an interesting and insightful blog post.

[thekohser]

What an interesting and insightful blog post.

Not sure if you're being sarcastic, but I thought it speaks volumes about Wikipedia. Pithy, yes. But, it gets the job done.

[RDH(Ghost In The Machine)]

Tilikum was at the scene of another death on July 6, 1999, though evidence suggests the Orca was not at fault. A park guest, 27-year-old Daniel Dukes, was found floating naked in Tilikum’s pool, apparently killed by a combination of [[hypothermia]] and [[drowning]]. Dukes had visited SeaWorld the previous day, stayed after the park closed, and evaded security to enter the Orca tank

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.


This post has been edited by RDH(Ghost In The Machine): Fri 26th February 2010, 9:05pm

[Somey]

Not sure if you're being sarcastic, but I thought it speaks volumes about Wikipedia. Pithy, yes. But, it gets the job done.

I would tend to agree, though admittedly it would have been worse if the article had been SeaWorld Orlando (T-H-L-K-D) or Incidents at SeaWorld parks (T-H-L-K-D). Then again, given that the deceased was a trainer rather than a "guest," I suppose it wouldn't have made much difference for the victim either way.

[CharlotteWebb]

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.

Could be a psychological thing. Ignore the thermostat, I've never been in a swimming pool that didn't feel numbingly cold.

[RDH(Ghost In The Machine)]

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.

Could be a psychological thing. Ignore the thermostat, I've never been in a swimming pool that didn't feel numbingly cold.

Or postmortem hypothermia after climbing into the pool with a large docile marine mammal...

[thekohser]

Tilikum was at the scene of another death on July 6, 1999, though evidence suggests the Orca was not at fault. A park guest, 27-year-old Daniel Dukes, was found floating naked in Tilikum’s pool, apparently killed by a combination of [[hypothermia]] and [[drowning]]. Dukes had visited SeaWorld the previous day, stayed after the park closed, and evaded security to enter the Orca tank

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.

You can get warm-water hypothermia in 80-degree water.

[anthony]

Tilikum was at the scene of another death on July 6, 1999, though evidence suggests the Orca was not at fault. A park guest, 27-year-old Daniel Dukes, was found floating naked in Tilikum’s pool, apparently killed by a combination of [[hypothermia]] and [[drowning]]. Dukes had visited SeaWorld the previous day, stayed after the park closed, and evaded security to enter the Orca tank

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.

You can get warm-water hypothermia in 80-degree water.

They keep the water in the tanks at 50-55 degrees year round.

This post has been edited by anthony: Sat 27th February 2010, 11:42pm

[RDH(Ghost In The Machine)]

Tilikum was at the scene of another death on July 6, 1999, though evidence suggests the Orca was not at fault. A park guest, 27-year-old Daniel Dukes, was found floating naked in Tilikum’s pool, apparently killed by a combination of [[hypothermia]] and [[drowning]]. Dukes had visited SeaWorld the previous day, stayed after the park closed, and evaded security to enter the Orca tank

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.

You can get warm-water hypothermia in 80-degree water.

They keep the water in the tanks at 50-55 degrees year round.

That makes sense, since Orcas are cold water animals and they want to keep them comfy.
It still might not explain the blood in the pool, though.
Maybe Tilli got a bit peckish after playing with his new toy and had a little snack...

[anthony]

Tilikum was at the scene of another death on July 6, 1999, though evidence suggests the Orca was not at fault. A park guest, 27-year-old Daniel Dukes, was found floating naked in Tilikum’s pool, apparently killed by a combination of [[hypothermia]] and [[drowning]]. Dukes had visited SeaWorld the previous day, stayed after the park closed, and evaded security to enter the Orca tank

Hypothermia in JULY in ORLANDO FLORIDA...orly? Gee it musta snowed that night.
Maybe they should bid for the Winter Olympics.

You can get warm-water hypothermia in 80-degree water.

They keep the water in the tanks at 50-55 degrees year round.

That makes sense, since Orcas are cold water animals and they want to keep them comfy.
It still might not explain the blood in the pool, though.
Maybe Tilli got a bit peckish after playing with his new toy and had a little snack...

Yeah, I find it hard to picture the whole thing. The guy was found draped across the back of the orca? Was that because the orca picked him up after he was dead? On its back?

"Authorities later concluded that the man, Daniel Dukes, likely suffered hypothermia in the 55-degree water and drowned, but they said it also appeared Tilikum bit the man's body and tore off his swimming trunks after he had died." (http://www.hispanicbusiness.com/newswire/2010/2/25/tilikum_known_to_be_dangerous_killer.htm)

I assume they did a full autopsy to conclude the cause of death, since they had to rule out the possibility that the guy was murdered and then dropped off at Seaworld (thus "framing" Tilikum). This is the first I'm reading that they suspect the guy wasn't already naked before he got into the water.

Why would anyone lie about the cause of death? Would it have actually been worse publicity for Seaworld if they had concluded that the orca did attack and kill some guy who sneaked in in the middle of the night? Seaworld doesn't hide the fact that all the orcas are dangerous creatures.

Here's the YouTube of the 2006 incident with a different orca. The trainer was bitten and taken under water, and got away with only a broken foot. That's a trained professional, wearing a specially designed wetsuit, with a smaller orca which unlike Tilikum *was* trained to swim with humans, and with three other trainers pounding the water trying to get the orcas attention and then holding them back while he swims to safety. Daniel Dukes had no training, was in his swim trunks, up against a bigger orca, which may very well have been woken up by him. To claim that he died of hypothermia, and not drowning, just doesn't make much sense to me.



You might have to watch it a few times to figure out what happening. The guy and the orca start out on the right hand side of the screen. The guy starts swimming to the edge, when the orca grabs him and pulls him under water. Then the camera zooms to the other trainers trying to get the orcas attention, and you see the guy's head pop up in the bottom left. Once the trainers feel they have the orcas under control you see them call to the guy to start swimming for safety, which he does, and then you see him limping off behind the scenes (he broke his foot but otherwise was okay).

I don't know how well they can determine in an autopsy which came first, the hypothermia or the drowning (*), but an incident similar to the one in that youtube (only with a bigger whale which had less prior experience swimming with humans) causing a drowning, with hypothermia only coming in later, seems more likely to me, barring a conclusive autopsy to the contrary.

(*) They can do it on CSI, but is that something which can actually be done in real life?

This post has been edited by anthony: Wed 3rd March 2010, 2:59am

[RDH(Ghost In The Machine)]

Yeah, I find it hard to picture the whole thing. The guy was found draped across the back of the orca? Was that because the orca picked him up after he was dead? On its back?

"Authorities later concluded that the man, Daniel Dukes, likely suffered hypothermia in the 55-degree water and drowned, but they said it also appeared Tilikum bit the man's body and tore off his swimming trunks after he had died." (http://www.hispanicbusiness.com/newswire/2010/2/25/tilikum_known_to_be_dangerous_killer.htm)

I assume they did a full autopsy to conclude the cause of death, since they had to rule out the possibility that the guy was murdered and then dropped off at Seaworld (thus "framing" Tilikum). This is the first I'm reading that they suspect the guy wasn't already naked before he got into the water.

Why would anyone lie about the cause of death? Would it have actually been worse publicity for Seaworld if they had concluded that the orca did attack and kill some guy who sneaked in in the middle of the night? Seaworld doesn't hide the fact that all the orcas are dangerous creatures.

Indeed.
They could've spun it instead-
Brave Orca takes down crazed night intruder; prevents harm to his podmates!


Orcas will take out Great Whites, in fact Jacques Cousteau once reported one carried a White shark carcass alongside the Calypso like "A proud cat presenting a dead mouse".

Here's a similar incident of Orcas owning Jaws:



Magnificent creatures. They really do need to provide them with better living conditions in captivity, though. Maybe large, artificial lakes, where they would have much more room to roam. These could be connected to their holding tanks by channels which would also help chill the lake water for their comfort. Hell, make it part of the tourist park! Have fake waterfalls, glass-bottom boat and mini-sub tours and even a fake grotto where the Orcas could go to escape the sun!


This post has been edited by RDH(Ghost In The Machine): Thu 4th March 2010, 10:50pm