The Wikipedia Review: A forum for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia
Wikipedia Review Op-Ed Pages

Welcome, Guest! ( Log In | Register )

> Wikis That Work?, Is it the concept or the implementation that is a problem?
dogbiscuit
post Sun 6th June 2010, 3:03pm
Post #1


Could you run through Verifiability not Truth once more?
********

Group: Members
Posts: 2,972
Joined: Tue 4th Dec 2007, 12:42am
From: The Midlands
Member No.: 4,015



It occurred to me that a recent interest of mine had got me using a wiki, and that the experience was satisfying and the results of it were useful.

I do a lot of walking and cycling and so have an interest in maps. Having got a GPS navigation device, I was interested in getting maps (though maps on the smaller devices aren't very usable for actual navigation) and came across www.OpenStreetMap.org which is a great big open source map of the world based on a Wiki approach, albeit with specialised mapping software.

To my surprise, it is accurate and pretty complete for the areas I am interested in, though missing just enough that it has suckered me in to contributing. Of course, in the UK we have some of the best maps in the world with the publicly funded Ordnance Survey, so it is interesting to have something where I can measure the results of a public work against a professional source - even more so because the OS released some of their mapping into the public domain so people have been able to link the two together.

Thoughts are that this is a Wiki with a pretty clear set of goals, the only conflict seems to be cyclists vs walkers vs motorists where there is still a little bit of clarity required. The other noticeable thing is that the administration of the project is virtually invisible. I've been poking around for a couple of months and simply have not seen anything of what might appear to be management - the Wiki is just magically there and it works. The mailing lists are the model of civility (in the real sense of the word!). People and companies are producing tests and checks to validate the quality of the mapping, and even over a couple of months you can see the end product getting more refined.

Has anyone else any involvements in wikis that really work and are producing measurable quality output? What are their defining characteristics?
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
anthony
post Sun 6th June 2010, 3:21pm
Post #2


Postmaster
*******

Group: Regulars
Posts: 2,034
Joined: Mon 30th Jul 2007, 1:31am
Member No.: 2,132



QUOTE(dogbiscuit @ Sun 6th June 2010, 3:03pm) *

The mailing lists are the model of civility (in the real sense of the word!).


Which mailing lists have you been reading? Surely not the one that was referred to as a "men's locker room" in this email. You know, the one where the founder of the project regularly gets into flamewars with contributors.

OSM reminds me a lot of Wikipedia before it got really really popular (back when it was Slashdot popular but not Steven Colbert popular).

This post has been edited by anthony: Sun 6th June 2010, 3:50pm
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
dogbiscuit
post Sun 6th June 2010, 5:20pm
Post #3


Could you run through Verifiability not Truth once more?
********

Group: Members
Posts: 2,972
Joined: Tue 4th Dec 2007, 12:42am
From: The Midlands
Member No.: 4,015



QUOTE(anthony @ Sun 6th June 2010, 4:21pm) *

Which mailing lists have you been reading?

The nice ones wink.gif
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
dogbiscuit   Wikis That Work?   Sun 6th June 2010, 3:03pm
Peter Damian   Interesting post. I can think of a few wikis that...   Sun 6th June 2010, 3:18pm
Milton Roe   Has anyone else any involvements in wikis that re...   Sun 6th June 2010, 5:43pm
GlassBeadGame   It occurred to me that a recent interest of mine ...   Sun 6th June 2010, 5:46pm
Kelly Martin   A wiki can work when it is used as a tool for coll...   Sun 6th June 2010, 8:12pm
radek   A wiki can work when it is used as a tool for col...   Sun 6th June 2010, 9:41pm
GlassBeadGame   A wiki can work when it is used as a tool for col...   Mon 7th June 2010, 12:51am
Kelly Martin   I suspect that the GPS wiki escapes the problems o...   Mon 7th June 2010, 1:21am
radek   It occurred to me that a recent interest of mine ...   Sun 6th June 2010, 9:26pm
jayvdb   I'd like to think that Wikisource is a wiki wh...   Wed 9th June 2010, 11:23pm
CharlotteWebb   As a result, I think English Wikipedia needs to b...   Thu 10th June 2010, 12:38am
Milton Roe   I suppose if one improves (re-writes?) the softwa...   Thu 10th June 2010, 3:10am
Kelly Martin   It's so the goddamn YOU HAVE A MESSAGE ON YOUR...   Thu 10th June 2010, 3:25am
jayvdb   [quote name='jayvdb' post='240064' date='Wed 9th ...   Thu 10th June 2010, 3:35am
CharlotteWebb   The missing component is that the admins are not ...   Thu 10th June 2010, 5:38am
jayvdb   [quote name='jayvdb' post='240083' date='Thu 10th...   Thu 10th June 2010, 8:34am


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

-   Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 19th 5 13, 9:43pm