 SlimVirgin violates 3RR Rule |
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| nobs |
 Mon 27th February 2006, 9:56pm
Post
#1
|
 #2242 most prolific contributor of out of 1 million+ WP users  Group: Regulars Posts: 575 Joined: Mon 27th Feb 2006, 6:08pm From: North America Member No.: 16 WP user page - talk check - contribs  |
SlimVirgin has violated the 3RR despite several users presentation of well sourced material.
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...&action=history |
   |
 
|
  |
Replies
| vulchy |
Fri 3rd March 2006, 7:20am
Post
#2
|
|
New Member Group: Contributors Posts: 39 Joined: Fri 3rd Mar 2006, 6:35am From: Canada Member No.: 49 |
I gave this example to Grace Note:
an article says "X graduated from Harvard" using his explanation, we can't say that person is a "Harvard graduate" unless someone uses those exact words. According to his definition of original research, we can't connect the dots. I seriously doubt any writer for, say, the Guardian seriously thinks whether there's a difference between saying someone was "born to Jewish parents" or "someone was Jewish" (I'm talking about unconverted Jewish people). It's just a game of words. I agreed to his policy (yes, this is vulturell) because it is so obvious to me that once we get to the list of Irish-Americans, which he promised to me we will do, we are going to have to cut down 80% of the names. Very rarely, in my research, are Americans described as "Irish" or "Irish-Americans". More often than not it's of "Irish descent" or "Irish parents". |
|
|
|
Posts in this topic
nobs SlimVirgin violates 3RR Rule Mon 27th February 2006, 9:56pm
Lir
SlimVirgin has violated the 3RR
The 3RR has an ex... Mon 27th February 2006, 10:15pm
guy
The 3RR has an exception which says the cabal can... Mon 27th February 2006, 10:26pm blissyu2 Isn't that article related to the Nobs01 case,... Mon 27th February 2006, 10:37pm nobs
Isn't that article related to the Nobs01 case... Mon 27th February 2006, 10:55pm guanaco SlimVirgin only reverted three times. That is not ... Mon 27th February 2006, 11:32pm Blu Aardvark Anyone notice how SlimVirgin gets away with edit s... Tue 28th February 2006, 12:12am blissyu2 It reminds me of the mess with the Jewish lists (A... Tue 28th February 2006, 6:48am Race Goat
It reminds me of the mess with the Jewish lists (... Tue 28th February 2006, 9:15am jorge
She just didn't understand the importance of ... Tue 28th February 2006, 12:10pm Race Goat
GraceNote, why can you not see that the vast majo... Wed 1st March 2006, 3:43am guy
If you want to add Riesz to a "List of Swedi... Wed 1st March 2006, 8:44am Race Goat
There are excellent references that Riesz was Jew... Wed 1st March 2006, 10:26pm Lir
By the way, even if you found a source that said ... Wed 1st March 2006, 11:43pm guy
She just didn't understand the importance of ... Tue 28th February 2006, 4:07pm Selina I think personally think there shouldn't be an... Tue 28th February 2006, 9:38am guy
I think personally think there shouldn't be a... Tue 28th February 2006, 10:31am nobs OK, so it appears Viriditas, and Will Beback have ... Tue 28th February 2006, 7:58pm Blu Aardvark
OK, so it appears Viriditas, and Will Beback have... Wed 1st March 2006, 12:10am guy "It is not permitted to take two facts and cr... Wed 1st March 2006, 11:35pm |
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 23rd 5 13, 6:56am |