A holding page is up at
www.WikiAbuse.com. If anyone is interested in helping--it will not be a lot of work, initially, at all--PM me please and we can sort it out for you to access the backdoor stuff, so that we can discuss if this is a viable project.
I figured a simple phase one would be simply hashing out ideas in private for it, on a disposable page. Please PM me if you're interested in this. It is, in it's simplest terms, envisioned as an accountability project. No silly outing, no silly attacks--we will use Wikipedia's own tools and content history against those that would abuse their peers, civilians, and the projects. A full dossier page detailing and analyzing malfeasance by every single admin or higher level user, including former/resigned/deadminned types. If you were ever in a position of power granted by your peers on a Wikimedia Project, admin, b'cat, CU, Steward, board, or higher--you'll have a page on you eventually. Pass RFA? You get a page/article/dossier added.
All material ideally should come from GFDL sources on WMF projects, so that it can be readily imported back in. If AdminX abuses UserY, UserY can review AdminX's entire history on WikiAbuse.com and take the relevant diffs and substantiating evidence to document patters of abuse, and paste them back into the RFC/RFA/AN/ANI/RFAR of their choosing. No one can RV them out as importing material from an attack site--since it's all just material from Wikipedia anyway; a chronological detailing of diffs and edits to show what AdminX has been up to.
Good people will have very, very, very short WikiAbuse.com dossiers. Ideally, everyone will have a page that says, "Admin Bob is darn nice guy. The end." Some will have dossiers, that if printed, would run dozens of pages. C'est la vie. Think of it as a fact-based recording of all your dirty business; your public record of doing things against Wikipolicy--in one central place for review by all.
Please PM if interested, so we can see if this is a viable and noble idea and goal. Externally enforced oversight, a third party ombudsman service for all Wikimedia people of power.
http://www.WikiAbuse.com