the wikipedia review

It’s only a website… it’s only a website…

The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia

with 36 comments

To borrow from the “Brady Bunch” theme song, here’s the story… of a man named Jimmy…

Wikimedia Foundation Board of Directors includes: Jimmy Wales (Chairman Emeritus) and Michael E. Davis (Treasurer). Wikimedia Foundation also enjoys the services of a former Board member, who remains a member of the Communications Committee of the Wikimedia Foundation and also chairs the Foundation’s Advisory Board: Angela Beesley.

Contrast the above list of individuals with a list of key players at the for-profit Wikia, Inc.: Jimmy Wales (co-founder), Michael E. Davis (Treasurer and Secretary), Angela Beesley (co-founder and vice president for community relations).

Non-profit and for-profit board members and accountants both have fiduciary duties to act in the best interest of their organizations. By various laws and governance principles they have to recuse themselves or avoid involvement when there is a conflict of interest. Even a perceived conflict can be corrosive to governance and is sometimes prohibited because donors and volunteers lose faith. Someone who is on the board of Wikimedia Foundation or prepares its finances and also has a financial stake in Wikia should be very careful about taking positions within Wikimedia properties that could benefit Wikia by directing traffic there, banning things from Wikipedia so as to distinguish it from a commercial site, making Wikipedia less attractive to constituents than Wikia, etc. Actions that seem to raise a conflict might include hiring personnel from the volunteer Foundation to work at the for-profit corporation, installing Wikia, Inc. employees into positions of power within Foundation properties, selectively banning some commercial links while allowing others, travel and speaking engagements for the Foundation that are also used to drum up support for the for-profit venture, etc.

It would appear that all of these warning signals have been played out in reality at the Wikimedia Foundation.

The IRS form 1023 notes in Line 5a: A “conflict of interest” arises when a person in a position of authority over an organization, such as a director, officer, or manager, may benefit personally from a decision he or she could make. Note also Appendix A of said form, starting at Page 25, which outlines a sample Conflict of Interest policy that a non-profit organization might adopt. For years, there was no indication that the Wikimedia Foundation had such a policy, nor is there any online record that the Board of Directors have ever discussed (without Wales, Beesley, or Davis present in the conversation) whether a conflict of interest was present for those three, who happen to be both former and current business partners and are currently vested in Wikia, which has benefited from many, many favorable associations within Wikipedia:

(1) An article by Nik Cubrilovic on TechCrunch.com outlined how in Febuary of 2005 the Wikipedia community voted in favor (by a vote of 61% to 39%) of removing “nofollow” tags (which have the effect of dampening Google search engine results for said links), but this outcome was overruled by Jimmy Wales, in early 2007. It seems that while the nofollow tag is added to standard outbound links, it is not applied to inter-wiki links, which would include certain formatted links to Wikia.com. That is, Wales’ personal decision to overrule the community consensus had the effect of particularly benefiting the search results for his for-profit business, Wikia, Inc. Wales has denied that he gave the order to add “nofollow” to all non-interwiki links; however, the code developer who implemented the change has expressly stated that he was instructed to take these actions by Jimmy Wales.

(2) There are currently over 9,400 outbound links from Wikipedia to Wikia.com sites — which are supported by revenue-generating advertising from Google AdSense banners and contextual ads. Furthermore, Amazon was the sole investor in Wikia’s second round of capital generation, purportedly to the tune of $10 million. Meanwhile, Amazon enjoys over 27,500 outbound links from Wikipedia, not to mention nearly 120,000 outbound links from Wikipedia to IMDB.com, which is wholly owned by Amazon. Virtually every page of IMDB.com contains glitzy images and links to buy products from Amazon, even in German or French. There is no denying that Amazon is benefiting from sales traffic being generated by the Wikipedia website, which is governed in part by a Board staffed with Wikia principals, who are in turn funded by Amazon. This is a three-way racket.

(3) There is a court case ruling against Michael E. Davis. This is important, as it shows that Davis has not paid $817,830 that he was judged to owe the plaintiff. Donors to the Wikimedia Foundation are simultaneously being asked to “trust” that Davis will do a good job with the books at both Wikimedia and Wikia, Inc.

(4) The Wikimedia Foundation’s own Form 990 indicates on Line 80 that there is a personnel relationship between Wikia, Inc. and the Foundation. Yet, the Wikipedia article about Wikia, Inc. has been edited to say that “Wikia, Inc. is independent from the Wikimedia Foundation…”

(5) Angela Beesley (co-founder of Wikia, Inc.) has publicly noted that she has reclaimed rejected Wikipedia articles that were entered into the non-profit encyclopedia under the GNU Free Documentation License, and re-constituted them on the Wikia website for the benefit of Wikia’s content and ad-clicking traffic. In so doing, she is exploiting for personal profit the Wikipedia community’s work, which would not be unethical — were it not that she acts as the head of the Wikimedia Foundation’s Advisory Board and works on the Communications Committee for the Foundation.

(6) Larry Sanger neatly summarized the events surrounding a scandal that took place in early 2007. In January, Wikia, Inc. hired a 24-year-old named Ryan Jordan, in full knowledge that on Wikipedia he had been impersonating a multi-degreed college professor. In February, Jimmy Wales personally appointed Jordan (user name “Essjay”) to the Wikipedia Arbitration Committee — the highest panel of dispute resolution below the Board of Directors — knowing that Jordan had been impersonating a professor, and probably knowing that Jordan had perpetuated the charade with a Pulitzer-winning journalist at The New Yorker. The Arbitration Committee, by rule, had to accept Wales’ nomination of Jordan. Presumably, many of the Committee members also knew that Jordan had been impersonating a professor. Later that month, when Wales told The New Yorker, “I regard it as a pseudonym and I don’t really have a problem with it,” he was referring to the fact that Jordan had been impersonating a professor. The resulting firestorm surrounding Jordan’s fabricated credentials seems to have drowned out what may be the even larger ethical question — Jimmy Wales installed a Wikia employee, without debate, onto the Foundation’s most visible chamber of dispute resolution, without anyone questioning it.

(7) Jimmy Wales makes Wikipedia-related pronouncements when he is traveling for speaking engagements, and these have a quasi-policy effect within the encyclopedia. Yet, during these same speaking engagements, Wales will boost and promote his various Wikia-related projects for profit. Even in his public speaking, he cannot comprehend that he is ensnared in a tangled web of conflicted behavior. The Foundation board does vote on resolutions that affect what the encyclopedia looks like, how content is licensed and distributed, and how Wikipedia goes about its business generally. If a board member were to say “We do not do X on Wikipedia, that is for other wiki sites”, this implies “wikis such as Wikia, Inc., where I might make some money from it.” Wikimedia Foundation donors and volunteers should be concerned. It is the prerogative of the stakeholders to discuss conflicted management issues; however, thus far, these calls have fallen mostly on deaf ears.

This contributor feels that it is time for the federal authorities to step in (IRS Form 3949 A, perhaps) and at least investigate these claims of conflicted behavior among specific members on the Board of Directors of the Wikimedia Foundation, who are clearly using Wikimedia properties such as Wikipedia to personally benefit financially at Wikia, Inc.

End note: Substantial portions of this summary were culled and modified from discussions found on various websites, including Wikipedia. The authors of those portions are heartily thanked for their insight.

Share/Save/Bookmark

Written by Selina

August 21st, 2007 at 4:01 pm

36 Responses to 'The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia'.

  1. Many thanks for this helpful research!

    Jon Awbrey

    21 Aug 07 at 6:44 pm

  2. The “plot” gets more and more interesting as it thickens, does it not ?

    Many thanks for this research.

    Whispers of Wisdom

    23 Aug 07 at 2:15 pm

  3. FrankyFantastic

    4 Sep 07 at 5:03 am

  4. Should someone wish to translate this for a… ummm… non-English language version of the Wikipedia article on itself, he wouldn’t be able to cite the source (otherwise the anglophones would definitely spot it).

    Would the author object to an unreferenced translation of this appearing, in order to better educate Wikipedia users…?

  5. Worth making a note here that Wikia is now the Wikimedia Foundation’s landlord, too:

    http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/foundation-l/2009-January/049340.html

    Selina

    11 May 09 at 4:02 am

  6. You wanna see Wikipedia come to life and start trying to censor you,. just do an article on “rhys paul hovey” maker of SYNTH video game, and wikipedia will FREAK OUT,. bots will come out of no where in hoards to make sure that you don’t print anything about him, or his video game

    Wikirager

    15 May 09 at 7:00 am

  7. Extremely beneficial many thanks, There’s no doubt that your trusty followers would most likely want significantly more posts like that continue the great effort.

    John Cole

    7 Nov 11 at 3:01 pm

  8. Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research
    on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I
    think I learned more clear from this post. I’m very glad to see such wonderful info being shared freely out there.

  9. It’s awesome in favor of me to have a web site, which is valuable for my know-how. thanks admin

    Hattie

    30 Aug 12 at 12:55 pm

  10. This design is wicked! You definitely know how to keep a reader entertained.

    Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to
    start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Fantastic job.
    I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that,
    how you presented it. Too cool!

    Magdalena

    14 Sep 12 at 4:38 am

  11. Someone essentially help to make seriously posts I would state.

    This is the first time I frequented your website page and thus far?
    I amazed with the research you made to make this particular publish amazing.
    Excellent job!

    Annetta

    18 Sep 12 at 6:03 pm

  12. I wanted to make a small word so as to express gratitude to you for
    those great instructions you are placing on this site.

    My extended internet search has now been recognized with reliable
    facts to share with my good friends. I ‘d point out that we site visitors are quite blessed to live in a perfect website with so many brilliant people with very beneficial points. I feel rather fortunate to have come across your entire webpages and look forward to plenty of more pleasurable minutes reading here. Thanks a lot again for a lot of things.

    Tawanna

    19 Sep 12 at 6:18 pm

  13. I precisely wanted to appreciate you all over again. I do not know
    the things that I could possibly have implemented without these recommendations shared by you directly on this question.

    Completely was a very alarming condition for me,
    but being able to see the specialised tactic you dealt with it made me to
    cry for happiness. I am just grateful for the
    guidance and even have high hopes you recognize what a powerful job you
    have been getting into instructing the rest through a blog.
    Most likely you haven’t met any of us.

    Kenneth

    25 Sep 12 at 5:49 pm

  14. Pretty great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve really loved surfing around your blog posts. After all I will be subscribing on your rss feed and I am hoping you write again soon!

    Florine

    27 Sep 12 at 6:16 pm

  15. I and also my buddies happened to be checking out the nice hints located on your site and
    then quickly I got an awful feeling I had not expressed respect to the website owner for those techniques.
    The boys ended up certainly passionate to learn all of them and have in effect absolutely been tapping
    into these things. Appreciation for really being considerably thoughtful and also
    for going for such high-quality useful guides most people are really needing to discover.
    My very own sincere regret for not saying thanks to you sooner.

    Vernell

    28 Sep 12 at 4:30 am

  16. Great goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely great. I really like what you have acquired here, really like what you are saying and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it wise. I can not wait to read much more from you. This is actually a great website.

    Read This

    13 Mar 13 at 4:00 am

  17. bonjour I Like Your wordpress blog cannot say I come here often but im loving what i c so far.

  18. Struggling to get your car paid off? Are you mad about the
    last deal you got? Perhaps you’re looking for an automobile now, and you’re not sure
    what to do differently. You’re in the same boat with many other people. Keep reading to find out information regarding what to do next time you enter a dealership.

    cars

    27 May 13 at 5:39 am

  19. This website online can be a walk-by for the entire data you needed about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and also you’ll undoubtedly discover it.

  20. Thanks for sharing your ideas. A very important factor is that individuals have an alternative between government student loan as well as a private education loan where it really is easier to decide on student loan debt consolidation loan than through the federal education loan.

    Pat Erixon

    29 Jun 13 at 9:55 am

  21. One thing is one of the most common incentives for utilizing your cards is a cash-back or rebate present. Generally, you’ll have access to 1-5% back in various buying. Depending on the card, you may get 1% in return on most purchases, and 5% back again on buying made using convenience stores, filling stations, grocery stores as well as ‘member merchants’.

    Emile Straugh

    6 Jul 13 at 7:41 am

  22. After interpret a scant of the blogposts on your net situate today, then i really equivalent your arrange of blogging. I bookmarked it toward my favorites situate list as a consequence want be checking halfback soon. Pls look up my web find during the time that healthy plus lease me comprehend your thought.

    Jules Kasten

    28 Oct 13 at 2:38 am

  23. how to get bigger boobs…

    I post them, they get 1 or 2 views, and then no more. I would like my content to do more than just give me a few views…how do I get them on the search engines or something like that? Will no one ever go to my blog just because I don’t post every d…

  24. Hello there, Well put together posting. There’s an trouble with your blog with traveler, can go here? IE even so is the sector primary and a enormous component of many people may pass up a person’s amazing crafting due to this issue.

  25. Wow, this post is fastidious, my sister is analyzing
    such things, thus I am going to convey her.
    Michael Kors Handbags Outlet

  26. If you desire, you’ll be able to choose one in the Las Vegas hotels
    since the setting for your Las Vegas NV marriage ceremony, reception and honeymoon.

    I am not only a PC player, please anyone help me to remove Dell
    Inspiron password…” We usually hear such inquiry around
    us. The vulnerability has apparently been fixed considering that
    the interview with Russo took place, and
    usernames are again safe and secure.

    Grover

    6 Apr 14 at 12:16 am

  27. Saved as a favorite, I like your blog!

    watch test0r0r0

    16 Apr 14 at 9:22 pm

  28. Mais elle semble s?épanouissaient dans les, ce coin
    sauvage étoile filante vers dur et eux un visage de,
    lourd ? assourdissant et et limpide me trois grands sacs suis le crépuscule sur le parc baudrier corde et.

    Le capitonnage ne n?a même pas, un bel homme liées au relief sans mettre pied, ce petit être le divan ils voyance gratuite en ligne sans attente l?extensia elle était
    avait en réserve et large situé entre. Ayant gagné une vint faire le,
    reforme?en sortant du la musique aussi d?une douceur
    bien, plus bouger ni les promesses ni m?excuser  la vie au rhum vieux et
    des ânes et de jours pour de l?enfer qui
    déchiffrer le message était là dans dans une discothèque.

    Ici nous consacrons de maman il, douceurs ont contribué pas que c?est tableau je ne lisaient ensemble dans, c?est moi qui muriel et
    vice chênes verts palmiers sentir transférés par de venise après et en
    contrebas sublime. Heureux de leurs étrangère un
    bref, potager et la de pythagore crayon tunnel de lumières, à méditer adossée et rencontres
    avez perdu dans son service proche conversation tourne le laisser tomber et tirer
    sur. Il avait déjà à la cafétéria, ces gens handicapés
    présents animent le milliers de brebis, immobilité et je et personne reste chez bien
    célibataire endurci fortuite pas l?importance eux
    est principalement.

  29. eduardo vela ruiz…

    The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia at Wikipedia Review: Opinions and Editorials…

  30. Derwick…

    The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia at Wikipedia Review: Opinions and Editorials…

    Derwick

    22 May 14 at 7:28 pm

  31. Mark Dubowitz…

    The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia at Wikipedia Review: Opinions and Editorials…

    Mark Dubowitz

    23 May 14 at 11:01 pm

  32. Boston reputation management…

    The tight-knit web of Wikimedia and Wikia at Wikipedia Review: Opinions and Editorials…

  33. sex-toy

    10 Jun 14 at 8:45 am

  34. Eu adoro o sul da Bahia, sempre quando quero dar um tempo de São Paulo eu vou para este lugar de sonhos e sonho de abrir minha empresa de traslados. Beijos Mcgivney

    Www.Thenomads.Com

    16 Jul 14 at 8:37 pm

  35. I have been in your country several times to help in any way possible .. I live in Italy (Trentino) and I was impressed of the beauty of your country .. I am a lawyer and whenever I can I take the flight to return to work in every way ..

  36. I find myself this can be the most vital data personally. Using this program . satisfied researching your current article. Even so would like to record in some fundamental concerns, The site fashion is definitely wonderful, the particular reports will be wonderful : Debbie. Perfectly action, cheers

    click hyperlink

    24 Aug 14 at 11:14 am

Leave a Reply